Diagnosing a Memory Error

    Question by:
    On

    Topics:

    I'm running a Dell Precision Workstation 650 (1 yr old). It has 2GB, 266MHz,Double Data Rate SDRAM,ECC,4x512 memory. It's still covered by a service agreement; however, sometimes I like to get some expert advice before calling tech support.
          A few months ago, at boot, I would get the message "Uncorrectable memory failure ...Press F1 to continue". The Dell Diagnostics "March A Test" identified the problem in addresses 73D00000h - 73DFFFFFh as Error Code 2F00:0419, ECC Error encountered. Suspected DIMM B.
         Dell sent me 4 new DIMMs. However, I would still get the message sometimes--not all the time. I would just "Press F1 to continue..." since the machine worked fine. More recently, the machine has been freezing.
         I ran the Dell diagnostics, and got the same error code, this time for DIMM A. If I switch the first and last DIMMs, I get the same error message, identifying DIMM A as the problem. Does it seem likely that the problem really is the DIMM or something in the system board?

    Good Question?
    0
     

    ?

    The member who asked this question verified this comment provided the solution that solved their problem.

    Accepted Solution on 2004-04-20 at 19:39:52ID: 10874627

    This is my offered dianosis based on the following symptoms:
    1. failures have been noted for both sockets(B, then A) and with multiple memory modules(originals and replacements).
    2. works for a while then fails with increasing frequency.
    Dx: improper installation due to flexing of the mainboard.
    Tx: use a nonconductive support under the sockets when installing(don't forget to remove) the DIMMs to prevent mainboard flex as the modules are "snapped" into place. The module must be correctly aligned in the sockets retention tabs and both ends simultaneouly pressed firmly into place, snap. The mainboard must not flex and the module must not be rocked into position. It is best practice to install the memory prior to installation of the mainboard on the standoffs in the chassis to avoid this situation.
    Info: if the mainboard is flexed during installtion of the modules, the heat up and cool down cycles of operation will degrade the memory contacts causing intermittant and unpredictable memory failures progressively. Before pronouncing any more deaths (mainboard) try CPR using the above technique.
    If proper installation does not solve the problem, call the coroner and send the mainboard to the morgue.
    T

    Top Expert Contributor

    Essential articles and videos from the Experts

    More valuable questions with Expert answers

    201601-LO-Qu-076

    Extend your technology team with the Experts Exchange community.

    — trusted by —

    Who answers my questions?Our community has technology experts around the world.

    Mdragga

    ktaczala

    Expert in:

    • Visual Basic.NET
    • Windows Server 2008

    sirbounty

    Expert in:

    • VB Script
    • Windows XP
    • MS DOS
    • Visual Basic Classic
    • Windows 2000

    ☠ MASQ ☠

    6

    Articles

    Expert in:

    • Computer Games
    • Hardware
    • Windows XP
    • Components
    • Miscellaneous

    strung

    Expert in:

    • Mac OS X
    • Apple Hardware
    • Apple OS
    • Apple Software
    • Apple Networking

    garycase

    Expert in:

    • Components
    • Hardware
    • Desktops
    • Hard Drives
    • Laptops/Notebooks

    John Hurst

    16

    Articles

    Expert in:

    • Microsoft OS
    • Outlook
    • Windows 7
    • Windows OS
    • Laptops/Notebooks

    Knightsman

    DrTribos

    2

    Articles

    Expert in:

    • MS Word
    • MS Excel
    • MS Office

    RELATED TOPICS view all topics

    1. PCs
      (11,852)
    2. Components
      (33,422)
    3. Hardware
      (63,692)
    4. Windows XP
      (118,085)
    5. Windows 7
      (42,738)
    6. Microsoft OS
      (56,454)
    7. Hard Drives
      (16,727)
    8. Displays / Monitors
      (7,752)
    9. Laptops/Notebooks
      (21,216)
    10. Windows OS
      (98,838)