Hyper-v VS Vmware

Abbas HaidarSenior Infrastructure Manager

Virtualization Software

Choosing virtualization software is one of the most important steps a network administrator can take as he will be dealing with that software for a long period. Troubleshooting, ease of configuration and installation and cost are the three most important factors, the decision maker should be aware of off. It also depends on which operating systems or application server, the company will be hosting on the virtual machine. The competition between different Virtual software providers in the market is really immense.  Riding the best virtualization boat is not that easy, and choosing the right product is for a company requires a deep look on the market side and see what it is offering.

VMware and Hype-V are the two leading solutions is the virtualization market. Historically, VMware is older in the market and was known to have a great stability and online support, a lot of open forums and sources are known to be one of the most useful and successful Vmware features. Known as the leading operating systems manufacturer in the whole globe, and as the best seller of Operating systems in the world, Microsoft introduced hyper-v software to be their competitor virtualization product in the market, so they can run their own server and operating systems on.

To choose the right virtualization software, it is really useful to start by doing a comparison between the available leading products in the market, that’s why Hyper-V vs. Vmware is an ideal example between two virtualization software leaders.  To improve their market leadership, Microsoft offered hyper-v for free with Microsoft windows server 2008 and the only cost which applies will be the system centre management framework. “Microsoft includes management of physical and virtual environments along with Hyper-V and Vmware”. Live migration is offered by hyper-v at no cost and that’s due to the Windows 2008 platform robustness which was proved since provided in the market, but VMotion and Vmware offer it with an extra charge. The following table will show a side-by side comparison between hyper-v and Vmware real cost:

In terms of cost Microsoft is offering a very good and competitive price comparing to Vmware. A total cost of £6000 compared to £32000 is almost 5 times cheaper than Vmware has a great advantage of sales comparing it to Vmware, but is it all about the cost?

Looking at the above tables give us the idea that Microsoft is really leading in the market but we should never forget that this is comparing only the hiperv-R2/SMSE which works for free and basically on windows 20008 R2 platforms so companies which has an operating system which older then the 2K8 families will not be able to benefit from the free hyper-V! Another problem with hyper-v is that is does not support most of the Linux systems, knowing that Vmware is almost compatible with every single Operating system software and supporting Vmware is much easier, and that is due to the availability of online free forums... “Hyper-V lets you manage virtual and physical environments and uses common deployment, provisioning, monitoring, and backup methodologies across both. VMware’s answer to management is to use Virtual Infrastructure Enterprise and Virtual Centre, but even these tools won't allow managing multiple hypervisors, physical resources or applications.”

Referring to all the above, Hyper-V will be the software used by the company as it is more reliable and cost the company less money if we think of getting windows 2003 R2, and use IIS 6.0 as a web server, exchange 2003 as an email server and MSSQL 2004 as a database server.  The staff have a good knowledge of VMware solutions but saving five times the cost is worth changing to another Virtual solution. The virtualization concept is the same and Microsoft Hyper-V has as much management tools as VMware solution, in the addition of a great support team and lot of free web feeds and forums.

Virtual machine configuration

The Hyper-V R2 requires a 64 bit system which is available with our Dell™ PowerEdge™ R805, the virtual machine hardware are hyper-v capable and the virtualization software will work properly on it.

The Hyper-V configuration tool is intended to support the administrator with a menu driven User Interface (UI) to configure Hyper-V Server. The Hyper-V configuration tool starts automatically at login of the system administrator or it can be started manually. At the first logion screen, the Hyper-V R2 software will prompt to assign it a new password for the Administrator account.

Then it is time to join the virtual machine to a domain which we going to need because  on the virtual machine we will be installing the following Operating system and application servers as follows:

1-      Virtual machine 1: HTTP server will be on Microsoft Windows 2008 Server R2, using IIS 7 as web hosting solution. IIS proved to be the most successful application for hosting websites on a Microsoft Platform. This machine will be used as the domain controller, active directory users will be created on this machine.

2-      Virtual machine 2: Microsoft Exchange server 2007 which is known to be a very good and competitive email server, and compatible with most of the mobile phone, and offering the capability of E-fax, spam and content filtering as well as its main features of giving clients capability of synchronising their mailbox, calendar, tasks, public folders, contacts and the capability of receiving faxes.

3-      Virtual machine 3: MSSQL server 2008 will be installed on this virtual machine. MSSQL is known to be very strong database software, which is leading the market these days.

4-      Virtual machine 4: this machine will be the “Double Take” software which will be used to take over in case the domain controller fails. The “double-Take” server wakes up when the domain controller is no longer available on the network.

To start the installation of a new virtual machine, we need to go to the server manager on windows 2008 R2 and add the virtualization role:

Hyper-V installation
Then click next on the introductory screen which gives a brief description about Hyper-V with links to more reading. On the next screen we need to choose the NICS which will be used for the network configuration, and to allow internet access. After following the screen instruction, the virtualization software will ask for a system reboot.

Now we can add the three remaining virtual machines, as the first one which as setup will be used for the domain controller. In the Server Manager still, expand the Roles now to find your Hyper-V role and then under that the Hyper-V Manager. Click on the Hyper-V Manager to change the right-side of the window to Hyper-V related tasks. Click on Connect to Server to begin.  

These will pop-up a small window prompting you to choose between Local Computer and Hyper-V server. On the far-right side, under Actions you’ll see the option New. Click it and follow the arrow to select a new Virtual Machine…

Now it is time to choose, the media source of the operating system we want to install, and for all of our virtual machine we will be using Microsoft windows 2008 R2. It always a good idea to mount the Windows 2008 R2 media, so later on installing the operating system will not require us to run the installation from the windows 2008 R2 media disks.

After installing the operating system, on the virtual machine, we can now install the Operating systems and we are ready to assign the hardware share for the virtual machine. By clicking on the virtual machine settings on left hand side pan, we get to the following screen and we can start editing hardware configuration for each individual machine. We will assign two processors for the domain controller and 1 processor for each of the other virtual machine, with 8 GB memory capability for each virtual machine and then by clicking on ok, we will be able to save the settings.

Virtual Machine HW settings

Referring to the Microsoft documentation about hardware requirements for windows 2008 R2, Exchange Server 2007, MSSQL 2008, the configuration we chose above should be ideal to run the virtual machines and their operating systems as well as their application servers.
VSS-aware backup client will be an ideal solution to backup the virtual machines as it allows having a full backup of the virtual machines. Microsoft provides Windows 2008 R2 with a free backup which is an ideal solution to recover files and even partitions.  The shadow copies can be enabled on each of the servers which allow having several instant backup when it is the case of recovering individual files. The backup requires having some kind of network access storage solution which is not really expensive these days, it has been proved to be a very good solutions. The Double-Take server machine can take control when the domain controller fails to load, by doing a domain controller election when the original domain controller is not available and promote itself to act as the new domain controller till the original domain controllers come back online. We should add that active directory is necessary on the domain controller and all of the other virtual machine (hosting Windows 2008 R2) should be joined to the domain controller domain.


1-      Windows Server 2008 Hyper-V: Insiders Guide to Microsoft's Hypervisor  By John Kelbley, Mike Sterling, Allen Stewart
2-      Mastering Virtual Machine Manager 2008 R2,  By Stewart, Hector Linares, Michael Michael
3-      Microsoft Windows Hyper-V VS VMware Virtual Infrastructure 3.5, http://www.itcomparison.com/Virtualization/MShypervvsvi35/HyperVvsvmware35esx.htm  2008
4-       http://www.milesconsultingcorp.com/Hyper-V-versus-VMware-Comparison.ASPX , Hyper-V vs. VMware Comparison
5-      Windows Server 2008 Hyper-V: Insiders Guide to Microsoft's Hypervisor
 By John Kelbley, Mike Sterling, Allen Stewart
6-       http://www.windowsreference.com/hyper-v/hyper-v-how-to-create-a-new-virtual-machine/, how to create a new virtual machine on hyper-v
7-       http://www.doubletake.com/english/Pages/default.aspx, by Mike Talon, Double-Take Software
8-      Pro Hyper–V, By Harley Stagner
Abbas HaidarSenior Infrastructure Manager

Comments (1)

Expert of the Year 2021

in the screenshot by Miles..., I'm not sure what VMware product they are comparing Microsoft Windows Server 2008 Hyper-V R2 to, VMware VI Enterprise, it's not a current VMware product.

VMware vSphere 5.0 Enterprise and Enterprise Plus (current product) have a backup product included called VMware Data Recovery included.

VMware Consolidated Backup has been discontinued in 2008. End of General Support was in 2010. It's been replaced by VMware Data Recovery

 See here for End of Life Statements

In your article you state "Referring to all the above, Hyper-V will be the software used by the company as it is more reliable" - you need to qualify this statement, the review is based on out of date material and information.

both the following references are not current.

3-      Microsoft Windows Hyper-V VS VMware Virtual Infrastructure 3.5, http://www.itcomparison.com/Virtualization/MShypervvsvi35/HyperVvsvmware35esx.htm  2008
4-      http://www.milesconsultingcorp.com/Hyper-V-versus-VMware-Comparison.ASPX , Hyper-V vs. VMware Comparison

Last release of VI 3.5 was released in December 2009. End of Support was 2010.

Have a question about something in this article? You can receive help directly from the article author. Sign up for a free trial to get started.