Know the Score: The Benefits of Gamification  in Online Communities

Randal RedbergEE Managing Member
At its core, gaming is about competition, whether against yourself or other players. You’re trying to get a better score, level up, or have the most points for the round. Learn why 63% of American adults said that making everyday activities more like a game would make them more fun and rewarding.
Ever since gaming became its own subculture it has been fraught with controversy, taking the blame for everything from laziness in young adults to the horrors of the Columbine shooting. However, despite the standard media narrative that gaming is destructive, the fundamentals of gaming offers society more positives than negatives.
At its core, gaming is about competition, whether against yourself or other players. You’re trying to get a better score, level up, have the most points for the round, or get the best loot from the raid. It’s no surprise then that there are 183 million active gamers in the US who play an average of 13 hours per week. Games are popular not just because they allow players to
escape into a world where they can call the shots, but because they tap into a fundamental aspect of what makes us human: the desire to push ourselves to be better.
This time spent is not time wasted either. In fact, game designer Jane McGonigal thinks that not enough hours are spent gaming. In her TED Talk, “Gaming Can Make a Better World”, she explores the reasons why gamers are better problem solvers and how these skills can be converted to solving real problems. Their high sense of collaboration, unwavering optimism after experiencing failure, and motivation to better themselves are all qualities that can effect real-world change. Interestingly enough, she also states that the way to transfer these abilities from the virtual world to the real-world is to make everyday life more closely resemble a game. Most of the public agrees: 63% of American adults said that making everyday activities more like a game would make them more fun and rewarding.

Real-World Benefits of Gamification

To start tackling the concept of gamifying real life, we can look at what organizations stand to gain from incorporating game-mechanics into their culture. Contrary to how it might seem, incorporating things like leaderboards, points, and awards into the workplace can actually lead to more productivity. Organizations have spent millions to incorporate these tactics and have seen a 205% improvement in performance related metrics. For those that implement these strategies into their online communities, engagement numbers increase by 150%. Organizations are taking notice of those numbers: as of 2015, these companies will collectively spend $2.8 billion USD on implementing gamification mechanics.

The fact is, gamification is no longer a novelty: it’s expected by modern employees and community members. Experts Exchange, a tech Q&A and networking forum, was one of the first to implement gamification onto their site in 1996. People come to the site looking for answers to technical problems, and members with years of experience will provide possible ways to solve the problem. When a suggestion proves to work, the asker will ‘award’ the respondent, highlighting that they provided the correct answer, resulting in points.

The more these knowledgeable members are able to answer correctly, the more points they acquire. Experts Exchange also gives badges to these members at certain point thresholds, allowing them to rise the ranks to a different status each time. There is also a leaderboard which ranks the top 100 experts on the site, allowing them to feel a sense of accomplishment. There is a lot of competition involved over these points and being considered an expert in their field.

Experts Exchange has proven this model is successful, and other companies have since followed in their footsteps. Since 2010, more than 350 companies have launched large scale gamification projects, including major brands like MLB, Adobe, NBC, Ford, Southwest, eBay, and more. HP’s Project Everest gamification earned the company $1 billion in revenue
growth in just the first few months of 2012.

Gamification Done Right

It’s clear that when done right, organizations who implement gamification stand to benefit greatly from their investments. However, there can be some risk involved. According to a Gartner report, 80% of current gamified enterprise applications will fail to meet their objectives, due mainly to poor design.

Because they were one of the first to implement gamification mechanics, Experts Exchange has honed in on exactly what makes their version of

User-Generated Ratings. Let the community be the judge. Use ratings and algorithms that highlight user-approved contributions and bury invalid ones. This encourages high-quality content. It also fosters self-motivation and a community-directed filtering system.

Points, Rewards & Leaderboards. Create a point system with a low threshold for initial rewards and achievements, but also provide depth in order to give members something to work towards. A system of some kind – badges, ribbons, certificates, freebies, VIP offers – is crucial to the success of a gamification strategy; without it the points and competition framework become meaningless. Leaderboards also serve as an inspiration for the community that appeals to their competitive drive.

Strategy. Glean community enrichment from gamifying by rewarding the behaviors you want to increase. Consider offering multiple incentives to participate in creating the kind of content that your community demands – allowing game strategy to reinforce your community and customer support strategies.

Additionally, because Experts Exchange is focused on self-improvement and knowledge sharing, the game is always alive and active. Instead of pure selfish gains like ‘get the most points and win’, members are rewarded when they help others. Additionally, articles that are concise, well written, and useful to the community will receive more points, thereby promoting quality over quantity.

The End Goal for Gamification

Gamification is not going away any time soon. Because it taps into something that’s so innately human, it makes sense that other aspects of our lives will start to get the gamification treatment. However, it’s not a guaranteed win for organizations. It still has to be implemented correctly, or else it will fail. Ultimately, if the goal is to increase community engagement, education is the best framework. When people stand to learn and grow while also demonstrating their competitive spirit, they get the best of both worlds. Gamification without the proper motivation is just an empty system waiting to be abused.
Randal RedbergEE Managing Member

Comments (1)


This is one of the most useful articles for me that I've ever seen here.

You succinctly put into words what I have been groping with for more than a decade.
I can use this in some of my projects.  I could have used this model well before the Internet!



Have a question about something in this article? You can receive help directly from the article author. Sign up for a free trial to get started.

Get access with a 7-day free trial.
Continue Growing Your Skills and Your Career
  • Interact with leading experts on your specific technology problems.
  • Receive the guidance of experienced professionals.
  • Learn from troubleshooting others have experienced.
  • Gain knowledge from a library of courses, all included.