Editor's Choice: This article has been selected by our editors as an exceptional contribution.

# Fun with Oracle SQL - Solving Checkouts in a Game of 501 Darts

Published:
I like to play darts and I like SQL, so naturally I thought to myself: "How can I combine these two interests?"  It came to me while watching some professional 501 darts tournaments on TV.  As the players closed in on the finish, a little window appeared on the screen showing the player's checkout combination.  Frequently the player would choose a different strategy than what had been displayed and that's where the idea was born.

For each possible checkout score, how many checkouts are there and what are they?
Some checkouts are mathematically possible but clearly poor strategy; so I want to eliminate those and just return the list of professionally viable choices.

If this intrigues you and you'd like to give it a shot and explain your take on it, here's a forum.

## First, a primer on the game of 501.

Each turn you get to throw up to 3 darts.  The "checkout" is the turn where you go to exactly 0.  If you go below 0 your turn is dead and your score reverts to what it was at the beginning of your turn.
One dart can score anywhere from 1 to 60 (triple 20), a Bull (the most inner circle of the dart board is worth 50 and is considered a double), the ring immediately around the Bull is worth 25 and is considered a single.  Thus giving you a maximum possible score of 180 points in turn.
An additional caveat to this game is you must throw a double with your last dart, so the maximum possible score in a checkout is 170 (Triple-20, Triple-20 and Bull).  Similarly, the minimum score for a checkout is 2, you throw one dart for a Double-1.  Strategically it's bad to leave yourself with a D1 throw because if you accidentally miss and leave yourself a score of 1, you can't win because you can't double to hit it.

2 and 3 are the only scores that require a D1, so I hardcoded them as special cases at the end and explicitly removed D1 from the calculations in the interesting part of the query.

## So, that's the game,  the tech challenge is...

Assuming 10gR2 or higher database and using only DUAL, list all possible checkouts by the following rules:

Must double on final dart
Must use fewest number of darts (3 3 D3 is not ok, D6 is better)
Avoid D1 as last throw if possible
Avoid obviously more difficult throws for the same score
...don't throw doubles when a single will do  (D7 when a 14 is easier)
...don't throw triples when a single or double will do (T12 when D18 is easier)
3-dart checkouts must be arranged so first dart is higher scoring than second dart
Double-25 is called a Bull
Final dart does determine a distinct checkout.  Thus (D19 Bull) is distinct from (Bull D19)

## For presentation consistency...

A single-dart is represented by N, DN, TN, 25 or Bull where N is 1-20, D meaning Double, T meaning Triple
A multi-dart checkout consists of single darts concatenated in order of throws separated by a single space

This article started as a question but I got no takers, so the question was deleted after a month of inactivity; but I thought it was an interesting topic, so I'll try again as an article.  This is probably a better forum anyway because I'm not really interested in a "solution"; I'm more interested in the conversation and trade of ideas.

Here is my best attempt so far.

Have fun!

``````WITH points AS (    SELECT LEVEL p
FROM DUAL
CONNECT BY LEVEL <= 20
UNION ALL
SELECT 25 FROM DUAL),
ab_throws
AS (SELECT p, m
FROM     points
INNER JOIN
(SELECT 0 m FROM DUAL
UNION ALL
SELECT 1 FROM DUAL
UNION ALL
SELECT 2 FROM DUAL
UNION ALL
SELECT 3 FROM DUAL)
ON (m IN (0, 1)) OR (m = 2 AND p >= 11)
OR  (m = 3
AND p IN
(7, 9, 11, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20)))
SELECT n, s
FROM (SELECT DISTINCT n, s, c
FROM (SELECT n,
LTRIM(
CASE
WHEN x = 0 THEN NULL
WHEN x = 1 THEN TO_CHAR(a)
WHEN x = 2 AND a = 25 THEN 'Bull'
WHEN x = 2 THEN 'D' || TO_CHAR(a)
WHEN x = 3 THEN 'T' || TO_CHAR(a)
END
|| CASE
WHEN y = 0 THEN NULL
WHEN y = 1 THEN ' ' || TO_CHAR(b)
WHEN y = 2 AND b = 25 THEN ' Bull'
WHEN y = 2 THEN ' D' || TO_CHAR(b)
WHEN y = 3 THEN ' T' || TO_CHAR(b)
END
|| CASE
WHEN c = 25 THEN ' Bull'
ELSE ' D' || TO_CHAR(c)
END
)
s,
x,
y,
a,
b,
c,
-- Rank by number of throws, then difficulty
-- Exception: Throwing multiple Bulls is difficult due to blocking/deflection
-- Thus, a Bull is more difficult than a triple.
RANK()
OVER (
PARTITION BY n
ORDER BY
(SIGN(x) + SIGN(y) + 1),
CASE WHEN x = 2 AND a = 25 THEN 4 ELSE x END
+ CASE WHEN y = 2 AND b = 25 THEN 4 ELSE y END
)
r
FROM (    SELECT LEVEL + 3 n
FROM DUAL
CONNECT BY LEVEL < 168)
INNER JOIN (SELECT p a, m x FROM ab_throws)
ON a <= n - 4 OR x = 0
INNER JOIN (SELECT p b, m y FROM ab_throws)
ON b <= n - 4 OR y = 0
INNER JOIN (SELECT p c
FROM points
WHERE p > 1) -- avoid Double-1 as your last throw
ON 2 * c <= n
WHERE ((x * a > y * b) OR (x * a = y * b AND x = y)) -- remove unsorted duplicates
AND (x * a + y * b + 2 * c = n) -- throws must sum to the checkout
)
WHERE r = 1
UNION ALL
SELECT 2 n, 'D1' s, 2 c FROM DUAL -- 2 requires a Double-1 as the only possible checkout
UNION ALL
SELECT 3 n, '1 D1' s, 2 c FROM DUAL -- 3 requires a Double-1 as the only possible checkout
ORDER BY n, c DESC, s);``````
3
6,446 Views