UNIX Pipes problem

Various (book) examples shows how to communicate between parent/child processes using one pipe. I need to create an FTP wrapper which requires I create two pipes, one for read and one for write. Furthermore I need to
capture stderr as well as stdout from the FTP child process using dup2.

I CAN'T GET THIS TO WORK I can get only stderr or stdout not both, and sometimes my parent process read hangs up!!. Can anyone send my som sample
code or explain this. It would be highly appreciated..

Thanks

Henrik

hldAsked:
Who is Participating?
I wear a lot of hats...

"The solutions and answers provided on Experts Exchange have been extremely helpful to me over the last few years. I wear a lot of hats - Developer, Database Administrator, Help Desk, etc., so I know a lot of things but not a lot about one thing. Experts Exchange gives me answers from people who do know a lot about one thing, in a easy to use platform." -Todd S.

remboCommented:


You can't execute ftp using pipe communication.  I would
recommend using the expect tool.  You can find it at:

ftp.cme.nist.gov

Here's a sample script that should do what you want:

#!/usr/local/bin/expect

set bug [lindex $argv 0]
set vers [lindex $argv 1]

send_user "Getting bug # $bug for RDBMS Version $vers\n"
send_user "This will take a minute, please be patient.\n"

exec mkdir bug$bug
exec cd bug$bug

spawn ftp tcpatch
expect
send "patch\r"
expect
send "Weav1r\r"
expect
send "cd ATT/bug_fixes/$vers/bug$bug \r"
expect send "binary\r"
expect
send "prompt\r"
expect
send "mget *\r "
expect
send "quit\r"
expect



0
aditya070797Commented:
Hi,
I am not completely sure of what your problem is, but you seem
to want a program that would fork off a child that would execute the FTP program and a parent that would control it. The below code should be able to show you how you can go about doing that.
The code shows two pipes for two-way communication between the parent and child. The STDOUT and STDERR of the child are
dup'ed onto the write end of a pipe in the child which the parent reads at the other end. This should give you a server that can actually monitor the child executing the FTP program. The parent  
would be able to read all of the child's output and can write to the child through the pipe. Since the pipe-ends are all duped in the child, the stdout, stderr and stdin of the child ( becomes the FTP program after exec )all refer to the pipe-ends from the parent.

/******************************************
 * This code is purely for illustration,
 * might contain errors.
 * Here's the first :)
 * --Aditya Vedula.
 *******************************************/

#include <stdio.h>
#include <unistd.h>

main(argv, argc)
char **argv;
int argc;
{
int pipefd1[2];
int pipefd2[2];
int rv;

pipe(pipefd1);
pipe(pipefd2);

rv = fork()

if (rv > 0) { /* PARENT */

close (pipfd1[1]); /* close write-end, read from pipefd1[0] */
{
int pipefd1[2];
int pipefd2[2];
int rv;

pipe(pipefd1);
pipe(pipefd2);

rv = fork()

if (rv > 0) { /* PARENT */

close (pipfd1[1]); /* close write-end, read from pipefd1[0] */
close (pipefd2[0]); /* close read-end, write into pipefd2[1] */

        /* do the parent thing... */

/*
 * Ex: read 50 chars from ftp child and write 50 chars to pipe
 *     read (pipefd1[0], buf1, 50);
 *     write (pipefd2[1], buf2, 50);
 */
}

else if (rv == 0) { /* CHILD */

close (pipefd1[0]); /* used by parent to read */
close (pipefd2[1]); /* used by parent to write */

        /* redirect stdout and stderr from child to pipefd1[1] */

close (1);        /* STDOUT, equivalent to dup2(pipefd1[1], 1) */
dup (pipefd1[1]);

dup2 (pipefd1[1], 2); /* STDERR */

close (pipefd1[1]);

        /* from now on, all stdout and stderr from this process
         * should go to pipefd1[1] to be read by parent at pipefd1[0]
         */

dup2 (pipefd2[1], 0);  /* STDIN */

        /* from now on, all stdin into this process will be from pipefd2[1]
         */

        /* do the child thing.... */

execlp("ftp", "ftp", arg1, NULL); /* Ex: execlp("ftp", "ftp", "129.78.4.8", NULL
 ); */
perror("Cannot exec..");
exit(2);

}
else { /* FORK FAILED */
        perror("Cannot fork...");
        exit(1);
}

}

0

Experts Exchange Solution brought to you by

Your issues matter to us.

Facing a tech roadblock? Get the help and guidance you need from experienced professionals who care. Ask your question anytime, anywhere, with no hassle.

Start your 7-day free trial
aditya070797Commented:
Whoops.. looks like the cut-and-paste messed up.
Here is the code again:
-----------------------------------------------------------------
#include <stdio.h>
#include <unistd.h>

main(argv, argc)
char **argv;
int argc;
{
int pipefd1[2];
int pipefd2[2];
int rv;

pipe(pipefd1);
pipe(pipefd2);

rv = fork();

if (rv > 0) { /* PARENT */

close (pipfd1[1]); /* close write-end, read from pipefd1[0] */
close (pipefd2[0]); /* close read-end, write into pipefd2[1] */

        /* do the parent thing... */

/*
 * Ex: read 50 chars from ftp child and write 50 chars to pipe
 *     read (pipefd1[0], buf1, 50);
 *     write (pipefd2[1], buf2, 50);
 */

}

else if (rv == 0) { /* CHILD */

close (pipefd1[0]); /* used by parent to read */
close (pipefd2[1]); /* used by parent to write */

        /* redirect stdout and stderr from child to pipefd1[1] */

close (1);        /* STDOUT, equivalent to dup2(pipefd1[1], 1) */
dup (pipefd1[1]);

dup2 (pipefd1[1], 2); /* STDERR */

close (pipefd1[1]);

        /* from now on, all stdout and stderr from this process
         * should go to pipefd1[1] to be read by parent at pipefd1[0]
         */

dup2 (pipefd2[1], 0);  /* STDIN */

        /* from now on, all stdin into this process will be from pipefd2[1]
         */

        /* do the child thing.... */

execlp("ftp", "ftp", arg1, NULL); /* Ex: execlp("ftp", "ftp", "129.78.4.8", NULL
 ); */
perror("Cannot exec..");
exit(2);

}
else { /* FORK FAILED */
        perror("Cannot fork...");
        exit(1);
}

}

0
hldAuthor Commented:
Aditya's , you fully undestood my problem and it looks like you solved it. I will try it out. Thank You, Thank You

Henrik
0
It's more than this solution.Get answers and train to solve all your tech problems - anytime, anywhere.Try it for free Edge Out The Competitionfor your dream job with proven skills and certifications.Get started today Stand Outas the employee with proven skills.Start learning today for free Move Your Career Forwardwith certification training in the latest technologies.Start your trial today
System Programming

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.