Link to home
Start Free TrialLog in
Avatar of jpas
jpasFlag for United States of America

asked on

Upgrade motherboard or cpu?

I have a Dell P120 that I was thinking about upgrading and am looking for recommendations on whether to upgrade the motherboard or cpu.

According to Dell, I can only upgrade the cpu to a 166 MHz. (66 MHz clock x 2 freq jumper settings)

Would I be better off upgrading to a 233 or 333 MHz (or other) AT motherboard?

The machine currently has about 10 gig of disk space w/48 meg SIMM RAM.

I don't want to spend a lot of money on it since it's getting pretty old. It also sounds like I'd need to replace the RAM if I replace the motherboard.

Recommendations? Run it until it dies?
Avatar of heliopaixao
heliopaixao

The most economical solution to you is only add more memory to your system (maybe your slots are full and perhaps you will change the existent ones with anothers).


Which type of application do you run normally?


(excuse my english)
ASKER CERTIFIED SOLUTION
Avatar of jhance
jhance

Link to home
membership
This solution is only available to members.
To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.
Start Free Trial
Avatar of jpas

ASKER

One of the reasons I wanted to upgrade to a faster cpu is because a lot of newer software and hardware is requiring at least a 133 MHz. If I can get a new motherboard w/64+ meg RAM for approx. $300, I might be willing to spring for that, if I can do it without messing up my hard drives. I currently don't have any way of restoring them if replacing the motherboard messes them up. RAM seems kind of expensive right now.

I'd like to stick with AMI or Phoenix BIOS. What is the difference between a Super-7 and AT style motherboard? The cpu socket?
If you want to keep your hard drives intact (i.e. no re-install of Windows) then don't get a new MB.  Stick with the CPU only upgrade.
Avatar of jpas

ASKER

Why does Windows need to be installed if you upgrade to a new motherboard?
Because the hardware that was detected in your motherboard will not match up with that on a new motherboard.  It's almost impossible to get a stable Windows environment after changing the motherboard without a clean Windows install.  I've tried it many times and have always ended up with a fresh install.