Link to home
Start Free TrialLog in
Avatar of napalm20001
napalm20001

asked on

pci modem

is there any way to get a pci modem to work in linux? the support team for TurboLinux said linux only works with ISA modems.
Avatar of napalm20001
napalm20001

ASKER

Adjusted points from 50 to 75
Any modem that isn't a 'winmodem' (says something like 'especially for WINDOWS' on the box) should work - ISA or PCI. What kind of modem is it?  Examine the output of 'dmesg' and look for  a line about the 'serial driver' and under that, something like 'ttyS00 at 0x03F8 (irq=4) is a 16550A' (you may see ttyS1, too, etc).  Use minicom, set the serial port options to use ttyS0, then type 'at' then hit enter.  If nothing happens (you don't see 'OK' come back) then change the port to  ttyS1, try again.  One of these is your modem.  If you get a response then you have a modem that should work under Linux.  If you get no response from a port where you know there's a modem, then yes, you won't be able to use that modem with linux.
Actually, most PCI modems don't work under Linux, yet. From the Modem-Howto (http://howto.tucows.com/LDP/HOWTO/Modem-HOWTO.html) section 2.5:

"Unfortunately, it seems that most PCI modems will not work under Linux but efforts are underway to support some of them. See PCI Bus Yet Supported."

The reference points to section 6.1, whaich says:

"The kernel 2.2 serial driver contains no support for the PCI bus. But kernels 2.3 and 2.4 will eventually support some PCI serial cards (and modem cards).Most PCI cards need special support in the driver. The driver will read the id number digitally stored on the card to determine  how (or if) to support the card. If you have a PCI card which you are convinced is not a winmodem but it will not work, you can help in attempting to create a driver for it. To do this you'll need to contact the maintainer of the serial driver, Theodore (Ted) Y. Ts'o"

So I'd say the TurboLinux folks are correct.
jlevie is right.  my only excuse here is that I've seen pci modems that had a real uart and processor and assumed that since they weren't host-processor modems, that linux would support them.  I'll be quiet now(!)
well, it's a rockwell pci v90 modem, i don't think it's a winmodem
kiffney, don't take it too seriously. Most people do assume that anything that's not a winmodem is gonna work. And the PCI cards will work later. It's just that the drivers don't yet know how to deal with the PCI bus (or how to ID the card).
so, what your saying is that I have to buy a different modem, external?

ASKER CERTIFIED SOLUTION
Avatar of jlevie
jlevie

Link to home
membership
This solution is only available to members.
To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.
Start Free Trial