• Status: Solved
  • Priority: Medium
  • Security: Public
  • Views: 190
  • Last Modified:

general cd-rw question

I'm thinking of getting a cd-rw drive, and I noticed that some requie a SCSI interface, while others have a EIDE interface.  So which is better?  And how do I know if my computer has SCSI or EIDE interface?
0
roca
Asked:
roca
  • 2
1 Solution
 
crojasCommented:
If you don't know if your computer is IDE or SCSI i think there is a probability of 99% is IDE.
Why, because people that really know about, and really want to have an SCSI system have one of them, because it's more expensive.

For normal users you won't need to have an SCSI system, it won't give you more speed or power at same price.

I recomend you to buy an IDE CDRW, because in nowadays systems there is no difference between them. IDE CDR's are cheaper.

Which one, buy a Plextor 32x8x4, most people says it's the best one.
0
 
dbruntonCommented:
Generally as per Crojas

You will probably have the EIDE (or ATAPI) interface.  Open box up and look at the cables that run from hard disk and CDROM to motherboard.  If both cables finish plugged next to each other on the motherboard then it's 99.9% certain you have EIDE.

The biggest advantage of EIDE - it's cheap.  EIDE supports 4 devices, it uses two cables with 2 devices on each cable, and in most modern machines these are the Hard Disk and the CDROM.  These are normally placed on separate cables.

SCSI supports seven (I think more for the later SCSI) devices for each SCSI card or connection on the machine.  SCSI takes the load of the CPU and does much of the data transfer work that the CPU does on EIDE machines.  Hence the CPU is freed up to do other chores.

So SCSI is preferable but more expensive.  Devices generally cost more than comparable EIDE devices as well as the SCSI card.

0
 
soj_1Commented:
SCSI provides more reliable burning of CD's since they take less CPU resources to actually do the burn.  So in the case of SCSI, you will get less buffer overruns, thus less cost in getting new CD's to burn the same amount of stuff.

If you go with EIDE, you won't need to buy a SCSI card, which will free up a slot in your computer as well as some IRQ and IO resources.  You slightly increase the chance of buffer overruns when burning but I think the chance is small enough to take the risk (especially if you buy blank CD's in bulk).

Also, chances are, unless you spent exorbinant amounts of money on your PC, you will have EIDE and not SCSI standard in your computer.  If you bought a standard PC from Dell/Gateway/etc.... you will definitely have EIDE.

-soj_1
0
 
crojasCommented:
i think buffer underrun is a thing of the past, in my last 2 CDR (Mitsumi 4x and Plextor 8x) i have never had a buffer underrun. I have a Pentium III 550 with 128Mb.
I burn CD while i'm in Internet with 5 to 10 IE windows opened.
0

Featured Post

 The Evil-ution of Network Security Threats

What are the hacks that forever changed the security industry? To answer that question, we created an exciting new eBook that takes you on a trip through hacking history. It explores the top hacks from the 80s to 2010s, why they mattered, and how the security industry responded.

  • 2
Tackle projects and never again get stuck behind a technical roadblock.
Join Now