Link to home
Start Free TrialLog in
Avatar of thenrich
thenrich

asked on

Visual Baisc vs. Power Builder

Does anybody have a good opinion on Visual Basic vs. Power Builder? When one language maybe better then the other.
Avatar of jrspano
jrspano
Flag of United States of America image

simple vb is always better :)

the only time i could ever see pb being better is in data presentation.  It is very easy to make a datawindow and show data.  With all the 3rd party controls for vb now though, it is just about as easy.  I quit a job about 7 months ago because they tried to make me use Powerbuilder, so that might be some indication...
and don't get the wrong idea, i didn't quit because the said you have to use powerbuilder, I actually gave it a shot and hated it.
also note that the pb section here at ee has 41 open and 68 closed questions compare that to vb's 4000 open and 35000 closed...
Avatar of Microsoft
Microsoft

I would agree with JRS on this 1.  PB has no where near as much flexiblity as VB, VB is extremely versitile with being able to interface with , EXCEL,ACCESS,WORD,C++ with added functions of ACTIVE X.

I don't believe that PB will ever become as large as VB in any shape or form.

I do believe that it will become obsolete in the near future.

Many Thanks

Andy

p.s
give us the points (lol)
:o)
the only thing i would like to have in vb from pb is the sql variable.  I don't remember everthing about it but I would like to have something in vb to do this

dim var as sqlvariable
dim wherevar1 as string
dim wherevar2 as string

wherevar1 = "Hello"
wherevar2 = "Condition"

var = Select * from table1 where field1 = :wherevar1 and field2 = :wherevar2

instead of all the concatination we have to do now in vb to execute a sql statement.  pb has something like this
the only thing i would like to have in vb from pb is the sql variable.  I don't remember everthing about it but I would like to have something in vb to do this

dim var as sqlvariable
dim wherevar1 as string
dim wherevar2 as string

wherevar1 = "Hello"
wherevar2 = "Condition"

var = Select * from table1 where field1 = :wherevar1 and field2 = :wherevar2

instead of all the concatination we have to do now in vb to execute a sql statement.  pb has something like this
Yup. VB. No contest. Really.
...and what did you expect, posting this question on the VB topic?  Next try "what is better, VB or VC++?" :)
Ah, in all fairness now. If you were to ask *that* I would say "You can't compare VC++ to VB. VB is a RAD language, VC++ is a 3G programming language".

But in the case of VB v Powerbuilder, you're comparing two RAD languages. And VB is *much* better than Powerbuilder.

And have you seen .NET yet? That'll be the icing on that cake. :o)
Avatar of thenrich

ASKER

I also posted this same question in the power builder area
what response did you get there?
How much more powerful is the new VB.net compared to VB6. Is it coming a little closer to VC++
How much more powerful is the new VB.net compared to VB6. Is it coming a little closer to VC++
ASKER CERTIFIED SOLUTION
Avatar of caraf_g
caraf_g

Link to home
membership
This solution is only available to members.
To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.
Start Free Trial
when do you expect the new .net framework to be launched??
beta 2 is this month full release is supposed to be end of year
Thanks!