PPPoE over Ethernet over L2TP

Hi all,

Is the following configuration can work ?
1. End user with PPPoE clietn and Ethernet connection to HUb
2. Multiple PPPoE session connected to a Router via a shared Ethernet
3. Router connected to Remote BRAS via a IP Network (either a multi-hop network or IP VPN/L2TP)

Who is Participating?
ahoffmannConnect With a Mentor Commented:
l2tpd just supports multiple dial-in connections, but what you need is multiple dial-out connections.
There is a patch for l2tpd 0.63 at http://sourceforge.net/projects/l2tpd/  which is a quick hack (using PPPTP), but has been tested succesfully on Linux against 3Com's HiPER ARC and win2k.

Probably you need to patch l2tpd once more, you're welcome ;-)
If you're interested in the history of this patch, have a look at (which in fact does not answer you question)
I don't see any problem, but it might depend on the router and / or the PPoet implementation.
I have 2 computers , both using PPoet connected to a dumb hub, connected to my DSL modem/router.

I hope this helps !
tomyu99Author Commented:
Hi Sysexpert,

Many thanks for your reply, but the things that i am not sure is the connection from the router to the BRAS.
The normal broadband implementation is a DSL router then a PVC all the way to the BRAS. i.e. it is a point to point layer two connection between the BRAS and the router.
What I want to know is whether a IP routed network, or more precisely... a IP/VPN L2TP tunnel will serve instead of the ATM layer 2 network.


Improve Your Query Performance Tuning

In this FREE six-day email course, you'll learn from Janis Griffin, Database Performance Evangelist. She'll teach 12 steps that you can use to optimize your queries as much as possible and see measurable results in your work. Get started today!

does this mean that each PPPoE has its own endpoint on BRAS?
By which side is the PPPoE initiated, PC or BRAS?
Could you please describe a bit more detailed the BRAS side.
tomyu99Author Commented:
Hi Ahoffmann,

Thanks for the reply. Yes, each PPPoE  has its own endpoint on BRAS. The PPPoE session is initiated from the PC side just like the normal PPPoE/DSL connection.

Actually, what I would like to confirm is whether it is possible to build a broadband network by a IP/VPN instead of the normal ATM layer 2 network.


Asta CuTechnical consultant & graphic designCommented:
Hopefully you've already been helped with this question, but thought you'd appreciate knowing this.  It would be great if you could bring this question to a conclusion, awarding the experts above who helped you with points or a comment to them on your status today.

WindowsUpdate has new updates for .NET users; Details follow - Microsoft .NET Framework
The .NET Framework is a new feature of Windows. Applications built using the .NET Framework are more reliable and secure. You need to install the .NET Framework only if you have software that requires it.

For more information about the .NET Framework, see http://www.microsoft.com/net. (This site is in English.)

System Requirements
The .NET Framework can be installed on the following operating systems:
Windows 98
Windows 98 Second Edition (SE)
Windows Millennium Edition (Windows Me)
Windows NT 4.0® (Workstation or Server) with Service Pack 6.0a
Windows 2000 with the latest service pack installed (Professional, Server, Datacenter Server, or Advanced Server)
Windows XP (Home Edition and Professional)
You must be running Internet Explorer version 5.01 or later for all installations of the .NET Framework.

To install the .NET Framework, your computer must meet or exceed the following software and hardware requirements:

Software requirements for server operating systems:
MDAC 2.6
Hardware requirements:
For computers running only a .NET Framework application, Pentium 90 mHz CPU with 32 MB memory or the minimum CPU and RAM required by the operating system, whichever is higher.
For server operating systems, Pentium 133 mHz CPU with 128 MB memory or the minimum CPU and RAM required by the operating system, whichever is higher.
Recomended software:
MDAC 2.7 is recommended.
Recommended hardware: For computers running only a .NET Framework application, Pentium 90 MHz CPU with 96 MB memory or the minimum CPU and RAM required by the operating system, whichever is higher.
For server operating systems, Pentium 133 MHz CPU with 256 MB memory or the minimum CPU and RAM required by the operating system, whichever is higher.

How to use -> Restart your computer to complete the installation. No other action is required to run .NET Framework applications. If you are developing applications using the .NET Framework, you can use the command-line compilers or you can use a development environment, such as Visual Studio .NET, that supports using the .NET Framework.

How to uninstall
To uninstall the .NET Framework: Click Start, point to Settings, and then click Control Panel (In Windows XP, click Start and then click Control Panel.).
Click Add/Remove Programs.
Click Microsoft .NET Framework (English) v1.0.3705 and then click Change/Remove.
More here  http://www.microsoft.com/net/

The .NET topic is being considered for addition to our All Topics link soon, so this may interest you as well:

EXPERTS POINTS are waiting to be claimed here:  http://www.experts-exchange.com/commspt/Q.20277028.html


astaec, and what has this to do with l2tp?
Hi, ahoffmann, astaec pointed this to me and it was explained here:
It was her way of helping bring old and forgotten questions back to the attention of the Asker in the hopes it would be a trigger to close old items, while adding some value for all participants.  The Power Search query she used to get the source listing fell short of expectations.

tomyu99 -->  Please update and finalize this question, as well as the same one you posted in another topic area which is this:


If tommyu99 does not respond in the next 7 days, please guide me with recommendations on closing this question.

Thanks everyone,
Moondancer - EE Moderator
This was finalized today.  If Asker returns with clarification needs on your solution, please respond.
Moondancer - EE Moderator
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.