• Status: Solved
  • Priority: Medium
  • Security: Public
  • Views: 288
  • Last Modified:

One solution: DSL Sharing, Firewalls and Filtering?

I have a home network using DSL from Covad and a LinkSys EtherFast DSL Cable Router. The Router comes with a firewall. What I need to add to this picture is a porn filter to protect my kids from the junk out there.

I've searched a bit and not found one solution, so I'm turning to you experts. I'm willing to replace the LinkSys router if necessary with a Firewall/Filtering/Router solution. Anyone have any suggestions?

Thanks.

Brian

0
btphelps
Asked:
btphelps
1 Solution
 
jwalsh88Commented:
Are you talking about URL filtering?  I would keep your Linksys router and get software for your computers.  Like surf control's Cyber patrol for $50
Go here:
http://www.surfcontrol.com/products/cyberpatrol_for_home/product_overview/index.html

0
 
btphelpsAuthor Commented:
These kinds of products--SurgWatch, NetNenny, CyberPatrol--are useful for a single computer. These products typically require installing and maintaining it on each individual computer and legally one copy/one license per computer. A filtering package integrated with the firewall reduces the complexity and administrative overhead.

Brian
0
 
jwalsh88Commented:
well I will tell you that there is no product except for products like this that are good at web content filtering.  And you can get the software that runs on one box and all HTTP traffic runs through that one box.  But, now you are talking business rates since protecting multiple computers are priced differently then protecting just one.  And these products get very expensive in the business pricing.  Compare the products from surfcontrol
Home version
$50 dollars a computer
Business version Only 5 seperate computer license
$1,000 dollars

This is hypothetical but you can get what I am saying.  Unless you have somewhere in the area of 15 or more computers it doesn't make sense to get the business version.

There might be some other products that are cheap and setup a HTTP gateway/proxy, which is what you are looking for, but I would be willing to bet that they aren't any good and wouldn't filter out nearly enough to even be effective.
0
Improve Your Query Performance Tuning

In this FREE six-day email course, you'll learn from Janis Griffin, Database Performance Evangelist. She'll teach 12 steps that you can use to optimize your queries as much as possible and see measurable results in your work. Get started today!

 
asweinsteinCommented:
Take a look at the Watchguard SOHO, they have a WebBlocker option for $49. I have installed this once, and it seemed to work well. The SOHO's are $449, and they include a 4-port hub. www.watchguard.com.
0
 
jwalsh88Commented:
btphelps,

That wouldn't be cost effective, unless you have more then 10 computers.  Not to mention I know that product and it's not that great.  It does not do a very good job of blocking porn, or give you a detailed report of everything every users has done.
0
 
btphelpsAuthor Commented:
asweinstein, jwalsh, thanks for the comments. I looked into the WatchGuard SOHO and it appears to be a good product, and it uses The Learning Companys CyberPatrol product as its filter. But you say it's not that good a product. What gives you that impression?

But the smallest Watchguard unit appears to be a 10 user license, which at $395 might be overkill. You're right, it'd be more cost effective to run an individual copy of one of the porn filters on each machine.

But I haven't given up yet. I've run these porn filters (X-Stop) and I hate how they soak up CPU and I/O. I don't like their foreground presence. So I'm going to hunt a bit more.
0
 
jwalsh88Commented:
Whats bad about it is that the watchgaurd product isn't all that great to begin with, if you put web content filtering on that box it will really slow things down when you have multiple boxes access websites through it.  on top of that it's an okay web filter but not nearly as good as surfcontrol's.  That's why I said it wasn't very good.  because for less money you get better protection.
0
 
btphelpsAuthor Commented:
jwalsh,

You sound like you are familiar with a couple of the porn filters. Why do you like Surfcontrol bette?

B
0
 
jwalsh88Commented:
I have used quite a few and while I haven't used there home version I know there enterprise version is about as good as it gets.  What I have read about the home version I really like.  I don't comment on the other web filtering software packages that I think are comparible but that's because I have never used them.  But I am sure they are good too.  Now, I have to admit, the watchguard product has changed their web blocking software.  The software they are using now is the same software that I am recommending you buy for your desktop.  Sorry, just didn't realize it.  Haven't worked with watchgaurd in awhile.  No real reason to they aren't worth the price you pay.
0
 
anzenCommented:

Have You seen this one ?

http://proxomitron.org

You could install it onto a "gateway" machine and set up client browsers to use it as a "proxy", next all You need is to download (or to create) some set of rules to "cleanup" unwanted pages/sites

Regards
0
 
btphelpsAuthor Commented:
jwalsh, thanks for all your comments. Saw that I hadn't closed this Q out.

FYI, I found a new version of ZoneAlarm Pro that has web content filtering built in. You can buy a 2-license version for around $99, and a single license is $49, if I remember right. That's the solution I finally chose.

Brian
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

Join & Write a Comment

Featured Post

Improve Your Query Performance Tuning

In this FREE six-day email course, you'll learn from Janis Griffin, Database Performance Evangelist. She'll teach 12 steps that you can use to optimize your queries as much as possible and see measurable results in your work. Get started today!

Tackle projects and never again get stuck behind a technical roadblock.
Join Now