Hub AND Switch!?

I have a network with 6 computers now. My current hardware is a small 5 port hub. I just bought a new 5 port switch and a couple of cables (one to uplink, one for the sixth computer).

I moved the 4 computers used most to the switch, and the other two to the hub.

There is an uplink cable between the two devices and the link light is on.

The problem is, computers on the switch cannot talk to computers on the hub and vice-versa. However, computers on the same device can speak to each other just fine.

What is the problem here? Can you not put a switch and a hub in the same network together?

Please help.
LVL 3
TYoungAsked:
Who is Participating?
 
WifoCommented:
If the "uplink" port on the switch is 100/full and the hub is 10/half is what I think Steve is saying. Best to have a common speed across the board. Some uplink ports are actually shared ports. If you have a cable in the "uplink" port and a cable in port #1 (for example) it won't work. I know Gigafast makes a switch that can do "uplink" on any open port, but you didn't specify mod#.
0
 
WifoCommented:
That sounds like a cross-over issue. Either the uplink port isn't configured for cross-over or you need a cross-over cable. Some switches have an uplink port that allows you to use a standard Cat-5 cable by simple pressing a button. The switch then figures out the wiring and you are set. In other cases you need a Cat-5 cross-over cable that does the conversion. You can usually pick one up at a CompUSA or other computer store for a few bucks.
0
 
TYoungAuthor Commented:
Thats not the problem. It is a a straight thru cable, and the switch is auto sensing MDI/MDI-X. The link light is on.
0
Improve Your Query Performance Tuning

In this FREE six-day email course, you'll learn from Janis Griffin, Database Performance Evangelist. She'll teach 12 steps that you can use to optimize your queries as much as possible and see measurable results in your work. Get started today!

 
WifoCommented:
What make/mod are the switch and hub?
0
 
mikecrCommented:
There wouldn't happen to be a DLink hub or switch involved, would there?
0
 
alisdair010799Commented:
Are the switch ports set to full duplex. If so set them to half-duplex.
0
 
Steve JenningsIT ManagerCommented:
10 or 100 mbit switch?

10 or 100 mbit hub?

10 or 100 mbit NICs?

NEVER use autonegotiate or autosense.

It could be that the switch has autonegotiated full duplex which wont work with the hub OR the switch has autosensed 100 mbit and the PCs on the hub are at 10 mbit.

Give more detail.

Good luck.
Steve
0
 
mikecrCommented:
I would have to agree with Steve's comment also. I'm still wondering if there's a Dlink involved here. I've had lot's of problems in the past connecting them to switches with a crossover. They are alright if they hook to each other, but if you hook them to something different they have problems.
0
 
TYoungAuthor Commented:
I havent tryed anything yet because I'm still at work, but to answer a few of your questions: Nothing is D-Link. The Hub is a Kingston and the switch is a Gigafast.

Some of the pc's on the switch are only 10/half and even they cannot communicate w/ the ones on the hub...


...
0
 
kiranghagCommented:
instead of using uplink port, try plugging the uplink cable in one of the free port of switch using direct cable
0
 
CyberStretchCommented:
Ok, here are the setups and whether they should work:

Switch  Cable  Hub      Work (Yes/No)?
------  -----  ---      -------------
Uplink  Cat 5  Uplink   NO
Uplink  XOver  Uplink   Yes
Uplink  Cat 5  Port     Yes
Uplink  XOver  Port     NO
Port    Cat 5  Uplink   Yes
Port    XOver  Uplink   NO
Port    Cat 5  Port     NO
Port    XOver  Port     Yes

The reasoning is that the Uplink ports physically crossover the TX/RX wires, the same way a XOver (Crossover) cable would by the pin positions. So, for the first scenario:

TX to RX, RX to RX, RX to TX = TX to TX (Transmit to Transmit will not work). Follow through the same type of logic for all connections. You basically want the TX on one side to match up with the RX on the other when connecting two devices, except for NIC to device.

Changes in Ethernet speed should not really affect things if using 10 & 10/100 NICs and devices, unless you need 100 speeds across the board:

Switch   Hub     Speed
------   ---     -----
10      10       10
10/100  10       10
10      10/100   10
10/100  10/100   10/100

I have never had any issues using Auto-Sensing or Auto-Negotiation with either NICs or Devices.
0
 
CyberStretchCommented:
Sorry that the formatting got messed during the post.
0
 
CleanupPingCommented:
TYoung:
This old question needs to be finalized -- accept an answer, split points, or get a refund.  For information on your options, please click here-> http:/help/closing.jsp#1 
EXPERTS:
Post your closing recommendations!  No comment means you don't care.
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.