CRON Appears to Start Itself!

Background:
The system is an HP 715 running under HP-UX 10.20. The CRON in question is run via an account created specially for this purpose. In other words, I don't run, or have access to, it under root.

Several times now, I have found crontabs running that I had disabled via crontab -r and verified were down with crontab -l. This is odd, to say the least.

Question:
Is there some kind of bug/glitch in the OS that would cause/allow this to happen, or should I start suspecting that someone is hacking in for a bit of fun?
pdouglasAsked:
Who is Participating?
 
elfieConnect With a Mentor Commented:
When you execute  crontab -r, is the crontab file emptied, or completely removed from the system?
If it is completely removed from the system, you should monitor it when it re-appears.

I have never heard before of crontab's reappearing. When executing crontab -r, the files are removed. So crontab can only be re-enabled by recreating the files. Once the files are in crontabs directory they will get executed on the time include in the file.

So if crontab were re-executed, someone must have put them back on the original place. If you suspect no hackers, then mostlikely it will be a restore from backup. (my guess)
0
 
elfieCommented:
Is it possible that the crontab entries are being re-created?

You must verify the crontab files in the crontab directory. Check for the modification time of this file (and directory).

Also take a look a possible schedules 'at' jobs.
0
 
cjwongCommented:
Confirm if other accounts have no similiar cron running?

If you suspect that there are "hackers" in, check on the modification date of the files, sulog files,etc to see if there is any unexpected intruders.
0
Upgrade your Question Security!

Your question, your audience. Choose who sees your identity—and your question—with question security.

 
pdouglasAuthor Commented:
Other accounts do have access to CRON, but not the particular crontab in question.

The modification date of the crontab is as it should be.
0
 
elfieCommented:
did you check the file also for 'latest access and creation' time?

check with "ls -lc", "ls -lu', and normal "ls -l".

If you delete the crontab file, then you can verify when the file was last read/accessed/created-modified.

This way you can see of the file has been restored from backup, recreated, and at which time.

How often is the file being 're-created'? Does this occur every day/week/months?

0
 
pdouglasAuthor Commented:
If by "created" you mean activated with the crontab <filename> command, then this is done once every several months. I'm not seeing from ls commands where the crontab was accessed on the days that I found it running after having deactivated it, so I guess this rules out hacking.
0
 
pdouglasAuthor Commented:
When I issue a crontab -r command, this does not remove it from the system, but rather stops it from being executed.
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.