Slow File access by Win 98 PC viewing Win XP PC

I am running a small network with 4 Win 98 pcs 2 Win 95 pcs and a Win XP pc. Until recently it was set up as peer-to-peer but recently we are using our Linux/Mitel firewall to authenticate users (no email or file sharing on the Linux pc).

I am experiencing problems with 2 of the Win 98 pcs reading files on the Win XP machine. Normally there is no problem, but just now and again (just frequent enough to be really annoying) the Win 98 take a very long time to open files on the Win XP pc. When I restart the Win 98 pcs the problem seems to temporarily rectify itself, but this is getting really annoying for all the users.
Muz1Asked:
Who is Participating?
I wear a lot of hats...

"The solutions and answers provided on Experts Exchange have been extremely helpful to me over the last few years. I wear a lot of hats - Developer, Database Administrator, Help Desk, etc., so I know a lot of things but not a lot about one thing. Experts Exchange gives me answers from people who do know a lot about one thing, in a easy to use platform." -Todd S.

cooleditCommented:
is there any WINS server in the network (Win98) requires WINS wheremore the XP does not run effectively under WINS / Netbios, you could make an entry in the Win98 lmhostfile where u set in a "record" for the XP mashine.

does the Mittel server hands out DHCP + DNS entries ???
0
mav7469Commented:
Are you running any virus checking software on the XP machine?  If so, try setting it to scan Incomming files only.

Good Luck

Mav7469
0
ViRoyCommented:

try installing IPX/SPX on all the windows pc's
it is a much more effecient carrier of netbios in a LAN environment
0
Ultimate Tool Kit for Technology Solution Provider

Broken down into practical pointers and step-by-step instructions, the IT Service Excellence Tool Kit delivers expert advice for technology solution providers. Get your free copy now.

cooleditCommented:
not to make u feel sad but IPX/SPX is for Novell

would still required to be setup on all machines

If you look at the old way you used to run peer-to-peer when you are using it as your "name resolver" then Win98 writes own entries in the lmhost file

if you made your Mittels Server do the DNS either handed out by DHCP or static enter them in all the connected maschines then when running DHCP u get more dynamic if you wanna change some things.

If you wanna go for the thing with the static IP addressing in the Network Neighbourhood you will need the maschine to use DNS
0
ViRoyCommented:

im sorry cooledit, but your wrong and missing a big part here.
dont focus on IPX/SPX DNS or DHCP- we are working with NETBIOS here and nothing but.

TCP/IP is a very poor carrier of netbios and OFTEN has trouble with communication in a LAN environment and wont work at all if computers are segmented on different subnets. now here we have a case of authentication server coming into play. DHCP does not have anything to do with filesharing in a windows environment... and neither does DNS.

now we have only 2 things to take into account, one of these 2 (if not both) will be the problem.
-First for a windows pc to "see" another in network neighborhood or my network places, the "master browser" must be contacted and provide the list of computer names and the corresponding address. the "master browser" in a peer-to-peer environment will always be the computer that has the longest "uptime" (unless manually changed within the registry). in a server environment, the server will always dominate as the master browser. now i dont know linux well enough to know how its needed to be configured... im shure theres something pertaining to this however i would work on reconfiguring the server as a last resort.

-Second...
NETBIOS is the only protocol used. NETBIOS unfortunatley is more of a sub-protocol, it will carry over numerous other protocols however. the reason for that is because netbios does not have its own addressing method, it has ID's which rely on discovery (broadcasts).
the following standard protocols can be used to carry netbios:
  TCP/IP
  IPX/SPX
  NETBEUI

the vast majority of others cannot.

-now TCP/IP is a segmentable, routable protocol with parity... that means its SUPER SLOW in a LAN environment as it was designed for a wide area network- in particular it was designed to keep military systems connected in a "WEB" (research "ARPA net" if you want to know more).
-IPX/SPX is Novell's protocol which can easily be installed on Windows... IPX/SPX was designed for a LAN environment and each pc contains a unique 8 digit identifier, this is highly effecient and quite fast.
-NetBEUI is Microsoft's protocol designed especially for peer-to-peer LAN environments to allow for simple communication without all the overhead of the TCP/IP protocol. however microsoft cant program very well and i have had several problems with NETBEUI so i try to avoid this.

now IPX/SPX has in recent years been expanded on by many proprietary software companies, ESPECIALLY the pc gaming market. it has become widely used and recognized as a viable solution to networking needs.
so as a overall result, IPX/SPX should give MUZ the functionality he needs, it might or might not be whats causing the slowness he reports... however we wont know until he tries which shouldnt take more than 10 minutes and a restart.


if that does not solve the problem, then my best guess would be that theres confusion on the master browser.
when a windows client gets turned on its sends out a broadcast, the broadcast contains the computer "name" and a way to contact it, ie.. IP address or IPX identifier
the master browser then adds that computer to a index list.
now when your working on a windows computer and open network neighborhood.. that computer then asks the master browser for that list... once the list is gathered and you "open" one of the computers to view the shares, the computer you just "opened" will get cached in the ARP (address resolution protocol - can be viewed in DOS with the "ARP" command)
active connections will show with the use of the "NBTSTAT" command

so far we have covered the methods NETBIOS uses for communication, how the MASTER BROWSER is determined and discovery methods.
*IF IPX/SPX does not resolve the problem - then i know a trick to force any specific computer to be the master browser.
if we force one computer, and just make sure that computer is on whenever filesharing is being done, there should be nearly no latency.


http://www.winguides.com/registry/display.php/54/
          Registry Settings
          System Key: [HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SYSTEM\CurrentControlSet\Services\Browser\Parameters]
          Value Name: IsDomainMaster, MaintainServerList
          Data Type: REG_SZ (String Value)



so if you add ipx/spx and configure a master browser... these conputers will use tcp/ip and the linux server to go through the internet, however when viewing local network shares they will use ipx/spx... both tcp/ip and ipx can be used at the same time.
this means we increased functionality on all computers which results in faster lan viewing and faster web browsing


0

Experts Exchange Solution brought to you by

Your issues matter to us.

Facing a tech roadblock? Get the help and guidance you need from experienced professionals who care. Ask your question anytime, anywhere, with no hassle.

Start your 7-day free trial
Muz1Author Commented:
Thanks - I set up ipx as you suggested and both machines have now gone 1.5 days without the problems recurring - so (fingers crossed) it looks like it has worked.

Many Thanks
0
ViRoyCommented:

great!
that means the computers were trying to route through the server using TCP/IP instead of going right to each other.

so now your internet traffic and LAN traffic are seperated and your performance should increase on both ends! (not by much but its there)
0
It's more than this solution.Get answers and train to solve all your tech problems - anytime, anywhere.Try it for free Edge Out The Competitionfor your dream job with proven skills and certifications.Get started today Stand Outas the employee with proven skills.Start learning today for free Move Your Career Forwardwith certification training in the latest technologies.Start your trial today
Networking Protocols

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.

Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.