building a celeron dual processor system

I have at hand, two separate machines with following hardware

PentiumIII Celeron 266MHz CPU (Slot1 Based)
PentiumIII CeleronA 336MHz CPU (PGA370 Based)
PC100 and PC66 SDRAM sticks of 64MB, 32MB, 128MB
Trident Blade 3790 AGP Display with 4MB VRAM
SiS 6326 AGP Display with 2MB VRAM

(currently they are being run with two via motherboards)

My objectives are
1. building a single, cheap, dual processor machine
2. using as much as possible hardware from above list
3. why? - just for having a dual system on desk

My assumptions
1. system would not be a high performance box
2. its okay if both the cpu can be used together and with lower possible speed

My doubts
1. can either of the above processor be used in a SMP, as IS
2. is it possible to get the motherboards in the market now? (my local market

in india, hardly sells smp boards)

I have seen one link where the person has used above cpu mix using one adaptor

which allows to plug a pga370 celeron into slot 1.

waiting for suggestions/instructions/links

tia
LVL 10
kiranghagAsked:
Who is Participating?

[Product update] Infrastructure Analysis Tool is now available with Business Accounts.Learn More

x
I wear a lot of hats...

"The solutions and answers provided on Experts Exchange have been extremely helpful to me over the last few years. I wear a lot of hats - Developer, Database Administrator, Help Desk, etc., so I know a lot of things but not a lot about one thing. Experts Exchange gives me answers from people who do know a lot about one thing, in a easy to use platform." -Todd S.

philby11Commented:
there are slot 1 riser cards available for the PGA370 chips.
check this out
http://www.golferlinks.com/go/pga-370-to-slot-1-cpu-converter.html
Also if you need any tips on multiprocessor systems try this
http://www.2cpu.com
InteraXCommented:
Unfortunately, I don't think you will be able to do this with your CPU's.

When creating a dual CPU system with intel chips the two CPU's need to be
1. the same speed.
2. the same type.
3. the same bus speed.
4. the same cache size.
5. compatible steppings.

See http://support.intel.com/support/processors/dp1.htm

Slockets are available which will enable you to put your s370 cpu into a slot 1 based board.

That's the first thing.
Secondly, you would have difficulty finding a slot based dual processor board today that works.

If you can sort out the above 2 issiues, then the RAM could all work together if you have enough slots and run the RAM with conservative memory timing. Without testing, it would be impossible to tell. You should check this after building with something like memtest.
http://www.memtest.com/

Either graphics card would work in the system as long as the above requirements have been satified.

Sorry if this isn't the answer you want to hear, but would rather give you an honset opinion than encourage you to spend money on an SMP board to find it doesn't work.

Good luck.
;-)

Experts Exchange Solution brought to you by

Your issues matter to us.

Facing a tech roadblock? Get the help and guidance you need from experienced professionals who care. Ask your question anytime, anywhere, with no hassle.

Start your 7-day free trial
publicCommented:
An SMP is not practical with your hardware. However you can build a multicomputer cluster. Either use linux now, or wait for windows availability.
Off the shelf solution: http://bofh.be/clusterknoppix/
IT Pros Agree: AI and Machine Learning Key

We’d all like to think our company’s data is well protected, but when you ask IT professionals they admit the data probably is not as safe as it could be.

Luc FrankenEMEA Server EngineerCommented:
With the hardware you have there, there's only one answer: Can't be done...

Celerons can't be used for dual systems..
Two processors have to be exacly the same model (doesn't apply here)

Greetings,

LucF
chicagoanCommented:
Celeron's aren't capable of Symmetrical Multi Processing, LucF is correct.
Even if these were P3's the cost of the motherboard would probably be more than the trouble was worth.
Tigerdirect has an entire XP1600 system for about $200, which would be 4 or 5 times faster than a dual 266.
Use your current machines for backup, play with other operating systems, stick a webcam out your window, make a web or DNS serve, stick one in your DMZ as a honeypot or IDS with snort,  or donate them...
shamstarCommented:
LucF is right.  I looked into doing this a while back with some of the hardware I had and some free Celeron processors I was given.  Its just not possible with Celeron CPU based computers.
As for using the Socket370 CPU with a Slot1 adapter, it can be done and has been doing quite a lot in the past.  The main thing to be aware of though is that you should get a high quality adapter and use a good fan.  Remember that there are physical differences between the contacts on the chips, the Slot1 has far less contacts to the motherboard than the socket 370 processors, thus you are likely to have to leave out data/functions or have other negative effects.
InteraXCommented:
Old celerons were able to do SMP. This was discovered by many small OEM's and when intel discovered this they removed the ability to do this from the CPU's. Intel discovered a drmatic drop in the volume of sales for their premium chips and a dramatic increase in sales of their celeron CPU's. Any celeron CPU produced in the past 2 years has had this functionality disabled. The hardware is still there, but the connections to the sockets have been removed/disabled, much like the old 486SX which was a 486DX that had pins controlling the maths coprocessor cut off the CPU.

I remember building plenty of these systems a few years ago.
kiranghagAuthor Commented:
well, i found few links which mentioned the surgery method to make a celeron smp capable.
they used the pga370-slot 1 adaptor and managd to modify it with a solder/dril.
some even mentioned that msi sold adaptor specially made for this. u could just plug in a pga370 in it and it becase smp compatible.
but i just fear that the pga-slot 1 adaptor mentioned in those link will not be available in here.

i was aware that the both processor should be same and celerons could not be directly used in smp
hence i just wanted to know if atleast one of them could be made smp compatible  so that i could save on that money and buy only one additional processor instead of two new identical.

LucF: Celerons can't be used for dual systems..
dont agree, unless u really mean "out of box celerons"
http://www.hardware-one.com/reviews.asp?aid=92&page=1
http://hwupgrade.com/cpu/celeron_biprocessor/
http://www.pcscoop.com/HARDWARE/motherboards/ABIT/AbitBP6/abit_bp6_page1.asp

old computer market in my country is very strong, i can even buy a 486 system today for almost $100
but same cant be said in terms of dual boards, slockets and other stuff.
:(

kiranghagAuthor Commented:
>>Use your current machines for backup, play with other operating systems,
>>stick a webcam out your window, make a web or DNS serve,
>>stick one in your DMZ as a honeypot or IDS with snort,  

thats exactly what i do with them now
;-)

>>or donate them...
i got them in the same way
:-D
Luc FrankenEMEA Server EngineerCommented:
>unless u really mean "out of box celerons"
Yes I meant that, but still those are two different CPU's so it still won't work, the processors should match exactly.
chicagoanCommented:
"should" being the operative word, usually... http://www.intel.com/support/motherboards/server/l440gx/l440gx_TA-178.htm
Though in this case they're so vastly different it seems unlikely it would work.


>i can even buy a 486 system today for almost $100
<starts rummaging through basement....>
I could take a nice vacation with all the boat anchors down there.
kiranghagAuthor Commented:
now if i decide to keep the pga370 (assuming i get a proper slocket), it wont be much useful. pga370 based chip that i have, is a celeron and not a celeronA, thus lacks cache
 but this chip is more easy to use in the smp system

the slot based celeron with me is a celeronA, but i m afraid to do the surgery on it directly..

having two L2 cacheless cpus in a smp system would be much slower than the celeronA based smp system.

i was hoping for a celeron based system because i was positive about getting a dual p3 board.

i still have two classic pentium100 cpus. one of them is known working on my desk, not tested other. but unless i m real lucky, i wont get a mobo for that.
ordering one off the net will be much costly.

chicagoan>>
talking about majority of people (not corporate), average configurations in our country are pretty low-end.
computers are common but they are still not treated as tv sets.
a good p4 system which is considered as barebone, can be infact a server configuration for many.
and even after buying a big-bang system, people spend most of the time surfing net, playing mp3 and wathing movies.

and due to this, cheaper systems are still in use....
chicagoanCommented:
>people spend most of the time surfing net, playing mp3 and wathing movies.
ain't it the truth

broadband has driven a lot of the processor envy in the states, as has gaming
my wife just retired her 333 only because she's doing a lot of photo editing now, but my daughter is happily using it as she spends ALL of her time surfing, playing mp3s, chatting and wathing movies LOL

Micronics and others produced dual processor P5 motherboards, though some were EISA and those that were PCI had early bridge sets. If there's a market I'd still try to unload the old stuff and combine the money on a new system... unless you just like to tinker :-)

It's more than this solution.Get answers and train to solve all your tech problems - anytime, anywhere.Try it for free Edge Out The Competitionfor your dream job with proven skills and certifications.Get started today Stand Outas the employee with proven skills.Start learning today for free Move Your Career Forwardwith certification training in the latest technologies.Start your trial today
Hardware

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.