VB Question

Hello Everyone,

I feel quite awkward asking this question but I need to start somewhere!

I have now been in the Networking field for approx 2 years and enjoy it! From my experiences I can tell that I need to have some programming background to get ahead in my career. I have always had an interest in VB and Java.

My question to you is - What recommendation would you seasoned experts give me. Jump in to VB.NET or learn VB?
Do I need to know VB to get into VB.NET?

I know this is not the right forum for this so you don’t have to answer the following question if you don’t want to!
What is the difference between Java and JavaScript and how closely is it related to VB. Basically if you know VB can one understand JAVA code?

I have no experience what so ever in programming so if my question doesn’t make senses, please ask for more details.

Thanks in advance.


PS – I will grant 500 points at the end of this question. So please brainstorm.

Who is Participating?
I wear a lot of hats...

"The solutions and answers provided on Experts Exchange have been extremely helpful to me over the last few years. I wear a lot of hats - Developer, Database Administrator, Help Desk, etc., so I know a lot of things but not a lot about one thing. Experts Exchange gives me answers from people who do know a lot about one thing, in a easy to use platform." -Todd S.

What recommendation would you seasoned experts give me. Jump in to VB.NET or learn VB?

Depends, for example where I work many machines still use NT 4, therefore vb6 is my only option. If you are working with more up to date Windows operating systems, then I would probably just start learning vb.net.

Do I need to know VB to get into VB.NET?


What is the difference between Java and JavaScript and how closely is it related to VB?

Java is the full langauge, Javascript is a smaller library of Java used on the web. Meaning w/ Java you can create full applications with all the bells and whistles, and Javascript you use on the web primarliy and you dont get all the features of the full Langauage. As for how closely they are related, they really arnt other than they are both programming languages. Java has Javascript for web scripting, and vb has vbscript. Although client side vbscript can only be used on IE. So most web programmers, choose to use javascript for client-side scripting.

Basically if you know VB can one understand JAVA code?

For the most part, once you know one language you can start to desipher another. Although you wont have a full understanding till you acutally sit down and take the time to learn the other language.

Experts Exchange Solution brought to you by

Your issues matter to us.

Facing a tech roadblock? Get the help and guidance you need from experienced professionals who care. Ask your question anytime, anywhere, with no hassle.

Start your 7-day free trial
I would definitely go the .Net route and to be more specific the web application development and security route. MS plans before the bubble busted was to have all of their office products run from over the Internet. You would log into a web site to use Word and Excel literally. Now when the bubble busted and the IT budgets vaporized in a flash boil nobody was ready financially to keep up with MS development. There are still thousands of networks that still haven't upgraded from NT4 yet. The future is in the Internet and Wireless Communications develop for one of these fields in any language you want IMO.

I would say that if you haven't studied VB at all to just learn .Net from the beginning. They have simplified a lot of small and tasky things in .Net that will force you to learn the basics of both languages if you started in VB6. Besides class object orientated programming is where the future for windows development is headed. If you want a decent primer into .Net play around with some scripting from the .Net WMI library for a little while.

Java is a rip from C and it's slow as hell IMO. It has its purposes but it wont last in a market where speedy application and services via the Internet become high in demand. I guess it depends on how long it is until we all have fiber connections into the Internet from the house. JavaScript is a Java flavored scripting language just like VBScript is a Visual Basic flavored scripting language. In a windows environment I would go with the VBScript, in a web environment I would use a mix of both.

Just my $.02
I've been using vb since version 5, and i started with  vb .net 1 month ago,and my experience with vb6 gave me more questions that anwers :) becouse many things are diferent and i was about 1/2 time thinking "how can i do that in .net?", my experience with "true" Object oriented languajes as C++ helped me more. the facts agais vb6 are that is ans old languaje, you have to call the windows apis many times for "advanced things", every vb6 exe depends on MSVBVM60.DLL, and many more things. The only fact agains vb .net is that to run an .net app you must have to install the framework, the good thins are: future windows systems will all have the framework installed, there are versions for the framework even for linux!! (yes that means that your apps will be able to run in linux, windows.. etc , the same .exe!!!), and that once you get comfortable using vb .net it is simply better that vb6.
You dont have to know vb6 to learn vb.net, yes it helps, but it is not necesary. In my opinion learning VB .NET  is the best option now if you are going to do "profesional" apps, and learn vb6 if you want to do "home" apps for your friends.. etc, but later you will have to learn vb.net..
thats my opinion...

and about the other question, i dont know JAVA, but i've been java code aome times and i can 80% understand it :), not just becouse i know vb, it is just becouse all high-level programming leanguajes are very very similar
Big Business Goals? Which KPIs Will Help You

The most successful MSPs rely on metrics – known as key performance indicators (KPIs) – for making informed decisions that help their businesses thrive, rather than just survive. This eBook provides an overview of the most important KPIs used by top MSPs.

Mike TomlinsonHigh School Computer Science, Computer Applications, and Mathematics TeachersCommented:
I would just go straight to .NET.

Although VB6 is technically an Object Oriented Language, it falls short in many areas such as Polymorphism, Inheritance, Interfaces and the like.  It also has a Single Apartment Model which means it does not have true Multi Threading Capabilities.

I do believe that it would be easier overall to learn VB6 but as the others have mentioned, it is a dying dinosaur.  You would just be learning bad habits that would raise more question than answers when you move on to other languages.

One major plus to learning VB.NET is that theoretically, you would be able to jump over to the other .NET languages without as much learning curve.  Supposedly, and I haven't heard much feedback on this yet, any .NET language can do anything any other .NET language can do because they are all based upon the same framework.

If you learn VB6, it probably wouldn't help you understand any Java code that well.  VB.NET, however, uses many of the same style of adding message handlers and the like.

There are plenty of resources to help you along on either path you choose.  Good luck in your programming endeavors.


NabsdarAuthor Commented:
Thank you for all your Reponses. Although everyone had different ideas, I believe the direction you all suggested was .NET.

Could you please elaborate on the Web application and especially security route with .NET. Secondly, I thought Java was the master according to everyone on web applications, I guess you have a different viewpoint?

Please explain.

Anthony PerkinsCommented:
Please let me know if you need help maintaining your old open questions:

1 09/03/2003 500 browsedui.dll error on win 98 strartup!  Open Windows 98
2 10/17/2003 500 GROUP POILCY  Open Microsoft Network
3 08/25/2003 250 DHCP will not assign automatic IP addres...  Open Microsoft Network
4 09/30/2003 500 Terminal Services  Open Windows 2000
5 10/08/2003 500 TERMINAL SERVICES AND PRINTER  Open Windows 2000

NabsdarAuthor Commented:
I guess you could maintain them for me. Better yet let me know how to close them and I will do it myself!

Thanks for your concern


TooKool probably meant that .net makes it extremely easy to make dynamic asp.net webpages. You can actually design your pages just as you would a normal program (im talking in a general sense) inside the IDE (Intergrated Development Enviroment).
I have a different opinion.  I believe that VB6 is much easier to learn than .Net.  Nabsdar already said he was just getting into programming.  I learnt everything about Vb from VBA, because I was designing databases, which is what someone in networking is usually involved with.

.Net is definitly more powerfull and lower level than VB, but unless you're completely comfortable with classes, it remains a larger amount of information to absorb!
Just adding my comments...

* I'd go straight to .NET. I loved VB6, but it will die eventually. VB6 to VB.NET isn't a syntactically large leap, but conceptually they differ immensly.  You have to re-learn the controls, the GUI, and forget all the things in VB6 you had to do to magically get them to work (anybody else remember having to enter "-4" as an additional attribute on a function through the object browser GUI to get "for each" loops to work?).  Besides, they redesigned VB entirely when they made VB.NET... more or less because it was on it's last legs with VB6, held together with duck tape.
* Javascript is a language used by webpages on the client side (for those annoying page transitions or mouse trailers). Jscript is for server-side scripting for web servers. And Java is a language used to make actual applications and EXEs much like C++ (or VB) does.
Anthony PerkinsCommented:
>>I guess you could maintain them for me.<<
I am not a EE Moderator, so I can do that.

>>Better yet let me know how to close them and I will do it myself!<<
In order to find your open questions:
1. Go to your profile
2. Click on Question History View
3. Click on Type to sort your questions abd bring your Open questions to the top.

From the EE Guidelines:

What are my choices?  
You have five choices when it comes to closing your open questions:
Accept an Expert's Comment as the Answer http://www.experts-exchange.com/help/closing.jsp#2
Accept Comments from more than one Expert (a Split) http://www.experts-exchange.com/help/closing.jsp#3
Request a refund because you answered your own question (Refund/PAQ) http://www.experts-exchange.com/help/closing.jsp#4
Request a refund because no one answered your question (Delete) http://www.experts-exchange.com/help/closing.jsp#5
Abandon your question and leave the mess for someone else to clean up http://www.experts-exchange.com/help/closing.jsp#12

NabsdarAuthor Commented:
Thank you again for all your responses. Although it is difficult to judge who the points should be rewarded to since everyone answered my question. I believe it would be only fair to spilt the points to between:


Since the all responded on the day I requested information. First come first server!!

Thanks everyone,


What I meant about Web App Development & Security is that they were hot topics and top priorities for Microsoft right now. .Net makes building Web Apps with true controls much easier the normal ASP page.

The learning curve is obviously there, however if you haven't learned VB yet then you’re going to have a learning curve anyways. If you start with VB6 you’re going to have 2 learning curves. Once you understand how to build classes and subclasses you'll wonder why it was ever being done another way. Once you become fluent with it you'll be surprised how quickly you can code as well because every time you hit the "." button the IDE wants to type for you. VB6 does the same but it's not truly full blown object oriented so you don't type the "." all the time. In .Net everything is an object with properties so you are always hitting the "." key.

My advice is to buy you a decent beginning VB.Net book and dive in. Or give yourself a project to do and use the book as a reference. What I would do first is an address book that saves its info in an access database. Learn how to populate as many different controls as possible from the database. Learn how to make any change and search based on any field in the database. Once you have actually completed a decent address book look for way of adding things to it to make it better or make it easier for the user to save and retrieve their information. Then build it so it can be a server/client app. So that you can access it from the network from any pc and update and retrieve data from the clients.

Then when your done with that Web enable it so you can access it from anywhere with a Internet connection.

By the time you have successfully completed these projects you'll be in here helping others to do the same.
It's more than this solution.Get answers and train to solve all your tech problems - anytime, anywhere.Try it for free Edge Out The Competitionfor your dream job with proven skills and certifications.Get started today Stand Outas the employee with proven skills.Start learning today for free Move Your Career Forwardwith certification training in the latest technologies.Start your trial today
Visual Basic Classic

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.