Server.CreateObject parameters problem

Why does this work:
Set DBObj = Server.CreateObject("BuyersFund.SimpleTest.ClassTest")

but this doesn't work:
Set DBObj = Server.CreateObject("BuyersFund.SimpleTest","ClassTest")


Here is the C# DLL source code:

using System;

namespace BuyersFund
      namespace SimpleTest
            /// <summary>
            /// Summary description for Class1.
            /// </summary>
            public class ClassTest
                  public ClassTest()
                        // TODO: Add constructor logic here

                  public string Speak()
                        return "Buyers Fund Simple Test";
Tom KnowltonWeb developerAsked:
Who is Participating?
I wear a lot of hats...

"The solutions and answers provided on Experts Exchange have been extremely helpful to me over the last few years. I wear a lot of hats - Developer, Database Administrator, Help Desk, etc., so I know a lot of things but not a lot about one thing. Experts Exchange gives me answers from people who do know a lot about one thing, in a easy to use platform." -Todd S.

because ClassTest is a method of SimpleTest,
in Object Oriented language you invoke the method by "Object.Method", you cannot invoke by "Object, method".  If you sepereate the ClassTest method from SimpleTest, the system wouldn't know where to look for method ClassTest().  in a word, object and sub-object and their functions are link by a dot "."

hope i'm making some sense   :-)
Tom KnowltonWeb developerAuthor Commented:


Set DBObj = Server.CreateObject("BuyersFund.SimpleTest.ClassTest")


Set DBObj = Server.CreateObject("BuyersFund.SimpleTest","ClassTest")

are not two ways to say the same thing?
Tom KnowltonWeb developerAuthor Commented:
How many different versions of CreateObject(  )  are there?  It seems to accept either one param or two params?
CompTIA Cloud+

The CompTIA Cloud+ Basic training course will teach you about cloud concepts and models, data storage, networking, and network infrastructure.

actually that's an interesting question.  I don't think how many version there are, I know there's "Server.CreateObject()" and "CreateObject()", they are slightly different.  but i don't think that is relavent here.

Here's some interesting things i found.
This is what is described in MSDN:

Server.CreateObject( progID)
Specifies the type of object to create. The format for progID is [Vendor.]Component[. Version].

From another source:

Server.CreateObject (ProgID [,ProgID Constructor parameter list])

so it seems you can use more than one params, but the other params must be constructor parameter list.  In your case, "ClassTest" is not a constructor parameter, it's an instance.

For example, if you "ClassTest" takes parameter,
for instance, something like this   ClassTest(String inStr) { .....}
then you might be able to use

Server.CreateObject ("BuyersFund.SimpleTest.ClassTest","something")

in this case, the string "something" will pass into the ClassTest() as constructor parameter for the method.
But then I haven't tested these codes, so I can't be sure this is how it works.  but hope it helps.
here's the reference web site:

the example in there is a java object.  But I don't think the language matters with DLLs.  Assuming that they are correct, with your code:

Set DBObj = Server.CreateObject("BuyersFund.SimpleTest","ClassTest")

"ClassTest" will be treated as a string input for .SimpleTest, but .SimpleTest does not have any input params, so it throws an exception.

Experts Exchange Solution brought to you by

Your issues matter to us.

Facing a tech roadblock? Get the help and guidance you need from experienced professionals who care. Ask your question anytime, anywhere, with no hassle.

Start your 7-day free trial
>> How many different versions of CreateObject(  )  are there?  It seems to accept either one param or two params?

The second parameter of Server.CreateObject is optional and is being used to indicate on which server the component is registered.

Set MyObject = Server.CreateObject("myobjectreference", "servername")

Of course the server should be accessible from the machine on which the script is running, and there should be sufficient rights on the server to create the object.

"servername" can also be an ip-number
From the Help file:

Visual Basic Scripting Edition  
CreateObject Function
Creates and returns a reference to an Automation object.

CreateObject(servername.typename [, location])
Required. The name of the application providing the object.
Required. The type or class of the object to create.
Optional. The name of the network server where the object is to be created.
FUNCTION:  CreateObject( )

CreateObject(ServerName.TypeName, RemoteServerName)
The CreateObject function is used to create an object of the type specified in the argument.
The Set statement assigns the object reference to a variable or property. The keyword Nothing is used to unassign the object reference from the variable or property. Good programming techniques require that you unassign all objects before you exit the program.
There one mandatory and one optional argument.
ServerName is the name of the application that provides the object. TypeName is the type (class) of object to be created.
The optional RemoteServerName argument was added in verson 5.0 and is used to create an object on a remote server. It is the name of the remote server. To use this argument, the internet security must be turned off.
In this first example, we create an instance of Microsoft Word.
Set objWrd = CreateObject("Word.Application")
' Place any code you desire here
Set objWrd = Nothing
In this second example, we create an object on a remote site.
Set objFarAway = CreateObject("Word.Application", "FarAwayServerName")
' Place any code you desire here
Set objFarAway = Nothing

Creating an object on a remote server can only be accomplished when Internet security is turned off. You can create an object on a remote networked computer by passing the name of the computer to the servername argument of CreateObject. That name is the same as the machine name portion of a sharename. For a network share named "\\myserver\public", the servername is "myserver". In addition, you can specify servername using DNS format or an IP address.
The following code returns the version number of an instance of Excel running on a remote network computer named "myserver":

Function GetVersion
Dim XLApp
Set XLApp = CreateObject("Excel.Application", "MyServer")
GetVersion = XLApp.Version
End Function
An error occurs if the specified remote server does not exist or cannot be found.

Basically, the syntax differs for Inprocess components and  DCOM components..

DCOM : Set object = Server.CreateObject("ProgId", "computername")
In-process : Set object = Server.CreateObject("ProgId")

Again, For Remote Data Services, the create object syntax could be like...

HTTP : Set object = DataSpace.CreateObject("ProgId", "http://awebsrvr")
HTTPS : Set object = DataSpace.CreateObject("ProgId", "https://awebsrvr")
DCOM : Set object = DataSpace.CreateObject("ProgId", "computername")
In-process : Set object = DataSpace.CreateObject("ProgId", "")

I know i'm repeating some of the things what the other guys mentioned.. how ever, i feel that this is a much more detailed description than those provided..

It's more than this solution.Get answers and train to solve all your tech problems - anytime, anywhere.Try it for free Edge Out The Competitionfor your dream job with proven skills and certifications.Get started today Stand Outas the employee with proven skills.Start learning today for free Move Your Career Forwardwith certification training in the latest technologies.Start your trial today

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.