Link to home
Start Free TrialLog in
Avatar of Prog_
Prog_

asked on

reinterpret_cast

I was wondering why this casting does'nt work ...
Is there an other way to cast this... in C++
I know that it's working with
char ** p1 = (char **) elem1;    but this is C casting...

Help me


int compare(const void* elem1, const void* elem2)
{
      

      
      const char **p1 = reinterpret_cast< const char**>(elem1);

...

Avatar of Member_2_1001466
Member_2_1001466

static_cast should work in almost any case. Not completly sure whether the const specifier doesn't allow for reinterpret_cast. If so you can remove the const'ness with const_cast.
ASKER CERTIFIED SOLUTION
Avatar of rstaveley
rstaveley
Flag of United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland image

Link to home
membership
This solution is only available to members.
To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.
Start Free Trial
By trying the cast from <const void *> to <const char **> you are trying to cast away the constness since it is the value pointed to be the first dereference of elem1 that is const.  Instead you should be casting to <char * const *>.  Also you should probably use static_cast, since the semantics of this cast are more well defined and guaranteed to be portable (although in this case reinterpret_cast is probably equivalent).

const char * const *p1 = static_cast< char * const * >(elem1);

Try that.

reinterpret_cast - internally interpret the pointers ( source pointer and target pointer ) and while compile time it embeds extra code if neccessary.

Here your treatment on pointers is converting from void* to char **. Which are not compatable

You are trying to copy only the 4 bytes of pointer data ( ex. 0x023FD2F) to the target pointer.

 const char **p1 = reinterpret_cast< const char**>(elem1);  - this casting should not be used here

reinterpret_cast is used when some situations like virtual pointer hirerchy casting
For only pointer copy it is not neccessary an extra interpretation is neccessary by the compiler then this casting is supportable

void* is a strange beast. It is a pointer to something unspecified. There is nothing wrong with saying that the unspecified thing is a char**, in fact we'd be lost if we weren't able to typecast void* in thread code.

You can do the following with a static_cast per the standard. I was surprised that the standard does not guarantee reinterpret_cast to work for void* too, but it does indeed say that it is implementation specific. Neither static nor reinterpret casts cast off constness though.

---------8<--------
#include <cstdio>
#include <memory>

int main()
{
      // malloc() - more comfortable in C code, but
      // what the hell. It is a simple example of
      // something that returns a void*, when you
      // really mean it to return a pointer to something
      // different
      void *ptr = malloc(sizeof(char*) * 2);

      // However, we were allocating an array of 2 char* s
      char **arr = static_cast<char**>(ptr);

      // Just to show it works
      arr[0] = "one";
      arr[1] = "two";
      for (int i = 0;i < 2;i++)
            printf("String %d is \"%s\"\n",i+1,arr[i]);

      free(ptr);
}
---------8<--------

NB: it looks odd written like this, because you are more used to seeing a C cast in C-ish C++.

      char** arr = (char**)malloc(sizeof(char*) * 2);