We help IT Professionals succeed at work.

Earth's Gravity

R_Rajesh
R_Rajesh asked
on
Medium Priority
1,640 Views
Last Modified: 2008-02-01
Say i have this Super heat resistant metal pipe, now i bore a hole in the ground with it that goes all the way to the other end of the earth (right through the center of the earth). now i have the two ends of the pipe sticking one feet above the ground on either side of the earth.
Now two apples are dropped into this pipe, one from either end. so whats gonna happen to these apples once they reach the center, will they just float around in mid air???

R
Comment
Watch Question

Commented:
Unlock this solution and get a sample of our free trial.
(No credit card required)
UNLOCK SOLUTION
Unlock this solution and get a sample of our free trial.
(No credit card required)
UNLOCK SOLUTION
Commented:
Unlock this solution and get a sample of our free trial.
(No credit card required)
UNLOCK SOLUTION
ozo
CERTIFIED EXPERT
Most Valuable Expert 2014
Top Expert 2015
Commented:
Unlock this solution and get a sample of our free trial.
(No credit card required)
UNLOCK SOLUTION
Enabbar OcapEmbalsamador
CERTIFIED EXPERT
Commented:
Unlock this solution and get a sample of our free trial.
(No credit card required)
UNLOCK SOLUTION
Just for the sake of argument....

RobinD

The 'Up/Down' is only for reference to either end of the tube, likewise sideways requires an up/down to reference itself.

Why will they rest against one side of the tube? Surely if the tube is central then all sides will exert an equal pull?

As the Earth is denser at its core I would disagree with the halfway resting place.

I'll leave the 'rolling' concept alone ....for now :-)

Peace
Enabbar OcapEmbalsamador
CERTIFIED EXPERT

Commented:
HippyWarlock,

I was using up/down as you stated and sideways to be in a plane at right angles to this.
Even the apples are not an 'equal' shape, and the world is only nearly round, there are mountains and seas and other sticky-out bits with different densities.
Even with all things being equal it is probably impossible to drop something straight through the hole.
Try passing a round magnet through a section of slightly larger steel tube, or re-inserting the armature of a starter motor between the magnets - it always pulls to one side. You only need to be a fraction off for the attraction to one side to be greater than the other.
Assuming a symmetrical Earth along the axis of the tube
Enabbar OcapEmbalsamador
CERTIFIED EXPERT

Commented:
Still don't think you could do it - see my magnet example above. The sideways pull is equal on all sides, but the slightest movement away from dead centre and the magnet quickly finds it's way to one side of the tube.
OK - Let's be totally pragmatic about this then.

You cannot drill a hole through the centre of the Earth for the following reasons-

1) The material you make the drill out of will melt.
2) If you attempt to cool the drill it will melt
3) If you drill from both sides at once - both drills will melt
4) any system that would enable you to do it would be cost-prohibitive
5) Tectonic movements and huge lava tidal forces would soon bend your tube
6) Your tube would melt
7) Your apples would melt
8) Your funding would dry up

This is my puerile way of saying 'OK your right'

Peace

Author

Commented:
:)
Enabbar OcapEmbalsamador
CERTIFIED EXPERT

Commented:
Who's right, me ? - don't really know unless it's tested.

It has just occurred to me that most people have tried to dig their way to the other side of the world at least once (when they were young), and that all these holes have probably gone to waste and been filled in (by Dad who didn't want a hole in the lawn). What it needs is for someone to co-ordinate all these kids efforts and get them to dig in the same place. This way, over the course of say a couple of hundred years or so they could communally achieve quite a sizeable hole - maybe even deep enough to test the apple theory...
ozo
CERTIFIED EXPERT
Most Valuable Expert 2014
Top Expert 2015

Commented:
> Why will they rest against one side of the tube? Surely if the tube is central then all sides will exert an equal pull?
Unless the tube is allpng the north-south axis the Coriolis effect will cause the path of a falling apple to curve relative to the tube. (because the tube would actually be rotating)
Once they come to rest they will rest against the side of the tube only if the tube or the distribution of mass around it is not central.
Enabbar OcapEmbalsamador
CERTIFIED EXPERT

Commented:
I'm unconvinced about the rest position ozo,

If the apples are laying against one side of the tube, and all the distribution of mass is equal around a point in the centre of the tube (the apples are away from this point by an amount equal to the radius of the tube). Why should the apples drift away from their rest-point? They are closer to the mass on their near side and so this pull should overcome a slightly weaker attraction from the opposite side of the tube.
ozo
CERTIFIED EXPERT
Most Valuable Expert 2014
Top Expert 2015

Commented:
This difference will be infinitesimal unless the tube diameter is large
Commented:
Unlock this solution and get a sample of our free trial.
(No credit card required)
UNLOCK SOLUTION
The coriolis effect will be negligable unless the apples are large.

The earth is pear shaped and wobbles in its orbit, what does that do to the apples sense of identity?

Peace
Unlock this solution and get a sample of our free trial.
(No credit card required)
UNLOCK SOLUTION
Unlock this solution and get a sample of our free trial.
(No credit card required)
UNLOCK SOLUTION
Urgh! Mole people!

Enabbar OcapEmbalsamador
CERTIFIED EXPERT

Commented:
>the apple wouldn't explode since gravity will be pulling it from all sides

no more than they are torn in half whilst hanging from the tree, the full force of earths gravity is trying to pull it off it's stalk, whereas when it's bobbing about in the centre of the tube (or lying against one side of it) there is half this force acting in each direction so the net result is about the same.
ozo
CERTIFIED EXPERT
Most Valuable Expert 2014
Top Expert 2015

Commented:
much less than whilst hanging from tree
Yggrdrssly What is that tree?

The aplle couldn't rip apart as the force is equal - it will simply get bigger, as will the mole ppl.


Dear R Rajesh - please choose mathematically and geometrically pure and simple objects next time

:-)

Peace
Unlock this solution and get a sample of our free trial.
(No credit card required)
UNLOCK SOLUTION
>You cannot drill a hole through a black hole, as there is no space to drill through.  A >black hole is a hole in space-time: it has no actual inside, the universe stopping at its >surface.

What? surely with a really powerfull Black n Decker?

If the UniV stops at its surface, how come the stuff falling into it doesnt? Only the light stops at its surface

>  how come the stuff falling into it doesnt?

   But it does.  For a distant observer (i.e. in our reference frame), anything that falls toward the horizon takes infinite time to reach it.  So, in that sense, nothing has yet fallen in or ever will.  In the frame of the falling object, it does take only a finite time to reach and cross the horizon, but what of the rest of the Universe in the mean time?  Either it'll have collapsed back into a primeval fireball --so everything catches up to the infalling stuff before it crosses the horizon-- or it'll have stretched out to heat death --in which case the black hole will have evaporated through Hawking radiation before the infalling stuff can cross the horizon.  You just can't do it!

Commented:
HippyWarlock, Urhixidur

You're right. I should have put more thought into it. An exploding apple was such an interesting thought when it popped into my head.
Unlock this solution and get a sample of our free trial.
(No credit card required)
UNLOCK SOLUTION
> Apples would certainly osclilate always if there was no air in pipe. but the gravity of the earth is also related to its
> mass. while apple is moving in pipe , it will happen to pass throught the parts of pipe where the mass of earth will
> vary , so it is a strong possiblity for the apple to be dragged in resistence with the pipe, or its vibration may not be
> uniform.

   I'm not sure I understand your comment completely, so here goes anyway.   ;-)

   If you grant that the Earth's oblateness is going to be a rather small disturbation factor (you can treat the Earth as a sphere plus a toroidal "equatorial ring" for an excellent approximation), and take also for granted that the Earth's density, at any point within its interior, is a pure function of radius (also an excellent approximation, as pockets of lighter or denser matter are going to be weak disturbances), then:
   At any point within our polar-axis vacuum pipe, gravity will be strictly towards the centre, and vary smoothly with radius.  This follows from the well-known effects that a) spherical shells of mass exert no gravity inside them, and b) spherically symmetrical masses behave as point masses on their outsides (as far as gravity is concerned).  The basic curve will be g = ((4/3) G pi rho r), where G is the universal constant of gravitation, pi is the ratio of a circle's circumference to its radius, rho is the average density of the Earth, and r is our radius variable.  Now, Earth is actually denser towards its centre than near its surface, so the actual plot of g will start off (at r zero) with a steeper slope (because rho will be larger for that value of r) that will progressively weaken (bend down) until it crosses the original straight line at r = R, the Earth's average surface radius.
ozo
CERTIFIED EXPERT
Most Valuable Expert 2014
Top Expert 2015

Commented:
Also, lunar tides will exert a gentle pull on the apple away from the moon.

Author

Commented:
Sorry for the delay guys, was caught up in negotiations with the mole people (to make them stay away from my apples :)

Thanks,
Rajesh
Hello,

In my theory Gravity is largely miss interpreted, the idea action at a distance is paranormal and ghostish. You can not pull or push something with your thoughs unless telekinetics is real. Even if it is real :) it would still need some rope or stick to connect the two items together.

Now although ether theory was found not to be true 100 years ago or so, the experiment was wrong not the theory. Ether exists in all space, it is a moving particle like water air, light or em radiation travels in this substance, thats why it has wave pattern, again ether clears the rubbish that light travels in vacum, as a wave, but also as a particle, come on everyone wants to make physics look so difficult no kid will fall for it with all this unexplained phonomenas being tried to explained with a zillion teories that even common logic can not resist questioning. Why speed of light is constat? a particle with constant speed, but differen wave length I mean its like kid asks why earth is round and you answer God only had round shapes to fill in with mud left, he had used all the rest for the astroids.. ok bad analogy :)

Back to gravity, ether is everywhere, it flows and it can pass through matter, matter is like a fishingnet in the water, or air, air and water molecules hit it but since the hit ration is so small its obviously hard to detect. Also they come from all sides i mean like in water, you are aware of the pressure only if you compare it with air, but we can not compare ether presure with anything else.

But when masses get bigger the obvous happens ether particles entring from the left side slows down somewhat during their voyage through the earth. The ether particles coming in oposite direction on the other hand wont be slowed down. Think of ether particles comes from the sky push you down, ether from the earth that have sloved down on the other hand push you up, the result is downward push is stronger. Gravity is a pushing force not a pulling force, and this makes sense even to a 7 year old kid.

Science is the reflection of the mind maxwell said, and our minds are smooth and clear, until Freud its all his fault that physics went this way.. not to mention art and music :)

The ether theory also can easliy tell you why tidal waves occure, the area belove the moon gets less ether pressure as the ether particles now have traveled through the moon and sloved down somewhat, this creates an inbalance with the rest of the globe, the matter on the surface bellow the moon gets an upwards push equal to the rest of the globe, but the downward push has weakened somewhat due to the moon, and the result is material seems to be pulled by the moon, but it is only the forces pushing at both sides that changed.

I've created software simulation to simulate the whole solar system based on Ether theory, and it gives the exact same numbers as real life, it also helps us understand light much better, i'm working on magnetic theory now, they really are the only thing i fear could injur the theory, but again ether is obviously being pushed faster, and low/high pressure points are occuring.

Anyway back to apple question :P the apples would both stand still, actually the air on both sides of this tunel would quickly vanish to be filled in by more air, but what you have done would be pasically creating a hole in earths atmosfer all air could disapear from the surface of the earth. The apples would stand still like they do in space, maybe the angular momentum would let them go sideways as they are no longer influenced by gravity.

Actually except the problem with air rushing out/upwards you would have the perfect anti-gravity launching pad, in this area where gravitational weight would be ZERO! but the air would actually lift your space ship, letting you in space without the burden of engines.

Glad you read all of this, hopes this answer your original question

Kunfu Faresi
Unlock the solution to this question.
Thanks for using Experts Exchange.

Please provide your email to receive a sample view!

*This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

OR

Please enter a first name

Please enter a last name

8+ characters (letters, numbers, and a symbol)

By clicking, you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.