Avatar of oompahii
oompahii asked on

Resolving a routing issue using a local DNS server (windows network)

I am attempting to set up a DNS server on the following network.

cable modem = pt. of entry
   -> Cisco 831 router
      -> Web server (windows 2003 enterprise)
      -> Web server (windows 2003 enterprise)
      -> switch
           -> 4 client machines

I do not have a domain, all servers are just a member of the workgroup "WorkGroup" I am setting up the DNS server on my LAN because while developing web applications on our LAN our Cisco router refuses to let us view web pages via the WAN external IP address (or if we try a domain name - like (www.asitewemade.com) that points to our WAN IP address).  There are workarounds but they are all fairly ugly

example if we want to browse www.some_site_we_made.com - we can not go "out" through the cisco router then come back in, I think it's referred to as a split-horizon problem.

ANyway I just want a DNS server that says to us on the LAN, "hey I see you attempting to access www.some_site_we_made.com and let's not go out the router, but rahter just stay on our LAN

so instead of trying to resolve www.some_site_we_made.com to our external WAN IP, it routes to our local LAN IP, which works fine when we force it to do that.

PROBLEM / QUESTION - I installed DNS server one one of the servers, and I need to know if it will work without an existing windows domain on our network -

when I point a client machine, behind the router on our little LAN, to the DNS sever I set up (make it the primary and only DNS server in TCP/IP) - it does forward the traffic out ot our ISPs DNS server via the forwarder settings.

How do I tell the DNS server to take, for instance, www.internxchange.com (a site we made and host) and not go out of the router to try and resolve it, but rather to forward it to our production web servers LAN address (

I tried to add www.internxchange.com as an entry in a Forward lookup zone I created and tell it to point to, but it doesn't it still tried to go out the router and come back in and it causes the "split horizon" problem - in a nutshell we get either a blank web browser screen or it asks us to log into the router (just as if we typed the routers LAN IP address in a web browser window and attemted to adminster control of the router)

HELP PLEASE - thank you very very much

Avatar of undefined
Last Comment

8/22/2022 - Mon

you can actually do this without a dns server.
lmhosts file is queried for resolution of name/ips before going to a dns server
an entry like this will work on the clients



I entered this on my desktop machine in the lmhosts.sam files


it still doesn't load, I can manually put

into my browser and it finds it,

even if it did work I don't think it will fix my problem...we have an internal / exteranl UBB we use to post solutions to project questions, and it uses hard link (it points to our external WAN IP address when loading threads)

is there a way to tell my PC whenever it sees our externa WAN IP address in a web browser to convert it to our internal lan IP address ?

All of life is about relationships, and EE has made a viirtual community a real community. It lifts everyone's boat
William Peck

also, do you know if DNS will run ok on our network if we don't have any windows doamins setup?

If this is ok to do then at least I know I'm not totally banging my head against the wall

woops sorry our LAN IP is 10.10.10.x now, was 192.168.1.x before - regardless I'm sure you get the point....

DNS is a prerequisite for Active Directory domain, BUT Domain isn't a prerequisit for DNS.

LMHOSTS isn't as good as HOSTS file when you want to use it to resolve IP address to name.  Use the HOSTS file instead.  It's under the same directory as your LMHOSTS file.

Finally, once you setup an Internal DNS, make sure it does query forwarding to an External DNS server so it can resolve for your clients any Domain that isn't listed on your local server.  

One last step to verify:  Make sure your clients point their DNS server entry to the local DNS server.

- Info
Get an unlimited membership to EE for less than $4 a week.
Unlimited question asking, solutions, articles and more.

The step regarding the query forwarding isn't entirely necessary if the DNS server supports recursion (which the Windows DNS server does by default).

In other words, just installing the Windows NT/2000/2003 DNS Server service and starting it is usually enough to make it work for Internet DNS lookups.  It installs as a cache-only server.

After you install DNS, create a Primary Zone called "asitewemade.com" and make sure it is configured to NOT transfer to any other name servers.  Next, create an A (Host) record for "www" that points to your internal address.  

After that, you need to do the final step as infotrader suggested and make sure all your internal clients are pointing only at your new DNS server for name resolution.  When they query the server for www.asitewemade.com, the server will authoritatively return your internal address.  For all other names, such as www.yahoo.com, it will do a recursive lookup out to the Internet to find the answer, cache the answer, and return the answer to your clients.

I hope this helps.

Log in or sign up to see answer
Become an EE member today7-DAY FREE TRIAL
Members can start a 7-Day Free trial then enjoy unlimited access to the platform
Sign up - Free for 7 days
Learn why we charge membership fees
We get it - no one likes a content blocker. Take one extra minute and find out why we block content.
See how we're fighting big data
Not exactly the question you had in mind?
Sign up for an EE membership and get your own personalized solution. With an EE membership, you can ask unlimited troubleshooting, research, or opinion questions.
ask a question

OK guys thanks for the input - I am away from the office until later tonight.  I will try your recommendations and awards points accordingly if I get the problem resolved.

Currently I have DNS running with ip address (windows 2003 enterprise server ed.)

I have my ISPs DNS address set as forwarders - but this doesn't seem necessary as DNS has some universal DNS entries automatically applied as forwarders it seems.

I created a FORWARD LOOKUP ZONE and am working in it, in hopes of telling this zone how to handle www.internxchange.com and other sites we host

my client machines only have one DNS entry in TCP/IP which is

so I believe I am doing what you guys are telling me - if I am not please correct me

I am getting tripped up on creating an A name for www.internxchange.com though, it seems straight forward enough, but I am not getting it to work.

If you could provide me a step by step algorithm to setting it up and it works for me, I will be much obliged, thank you all for the help thus far...

It sounds like you're on the right track.

Here's how you create your A record...

Right-click the zone name, select "New Host..."
In the "Name" field, enter: www
Put in the IP address.
Click "Add Host".

This is the best money I have ever spent. I cannot not tell you how many times these folks have saved my bacon. I learn so much from the contributors.

Firstly you will need to create a new "Forward Lookup Zone" for the domain "internxchange.com". You can simply create it as a Standard Primary Zone.

After the zone is created, create a host record for "www" as per the previous post. Make sure that you create this host within the "internxchange.com" zone.