exchange 2003 hosting multiple domains

My exchange 2003 server is working fine. I now have to host another domain on this server. The MX record for this second domain points to a different IP. i.e = = We own the IP's I have setup my firewall to for 1 to 1 NAT for the and configured my exchange server with another private ip address of I have also created a recipient policy with the new domain name and applied the policy to the users who need it, and i checked the box "this organization is responsible for" I then went to my default SMTP server, clicked the advanced tab, and added in the private ip so it would listen on it.

When i try and send an email to from an outside account I get a return message that says

Final-Recipient: RFC822; < >
Action: failed
Status: 5.1.1
Diagnostic-Code: smtp; 550 5.7.1 Unable to relay for

Am I on the right track here or way off?

Who is Participating?
timianoConnect With a Mentor Commented:
Its almost certainly the recipient update service not adding the policy....I'm confused!, but then I suppose you are too :-)

Go into AD users and computers and check that the user you are sending to has that domain listed as one of its proxy addresses.  If not, go back into the policy and make sure the tick is in the box, and make sure you haven't got some funky ldap filter on it.

Make sure that once you have created the policy, you right click on it and choose to apply this policy now, and hit yes, to apply now.

Might be one thing

kjmanAuthor Commented:
Yea I did that, but still no luck. Am i on the right track here?
you should point your MX record for DomainB to the same IP address as DomainA.

i.e DomainA-->  MX record= and
     DomainB---> MX record =

Since your exchange server is having 1 to 1 NAT with firewall. the mail for is arriving to the IP address and then passed on to your exchange server (NAT rule). But the mail for is arriving at IP address and ending up nowhere as your exchange is having 1 to 1 mapping with IP address
test your DNS report and MAIL test at
So change the MX record for domainB to IP address to allow the the e-mail flow.
change of MX record will take 48 hours to propogate to all the public DNS servers.

Hope this solves your problem .

Also check;EN-US;318635 for server configuration
kjmanAuthor Commented:
But the mail for is arriving at IP address and ending up nowhere as your exchange is having 1 to 1 mapping with IP address

Well I created a separate 1 to 1 NAT rule for to map to so this would mean that I have two 1 to 1 NAT rules configured. one for maping to and one for maping to With this in place I can send emails to no sweat, and i know that the second 1 to 1 NAT rule on the firewall is setup correctly because when i send an email to I get a unable to realy message bounced back to me. This tells me that the port 25 is open on the firewall for but its exchagne that doesnt like

You are right though about making both domains MX records point to the same IP address, and i have done that. I think this will make things a bit less complicted, and easy to understand.

Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.