Subquery doesn't work, syntax is correct???

I just installed Mysql 4.0.18

I tried to run ths sql statement

Select a.price, a.name
from rooms
where a.price = (Select max(price) from rooms);


I don't believe the syntax is wrong.  Can anyone help me?  I checked the data in the [Rooms] table which are all valid.

When I run:
Select max(price) from rooms;

It works, but when its in a subquery it doesn't.

Any help is greatly appreciated
phake123Asked:
Who is Participating?
 
DossyConnect With a Mentor Commented:
What you want is this:

SELECT   a.price, a.name
FROM     rooms AS a
WHERE   a.price IN (
    SELECT   MAX(price)
    FROM     rooms
);

However, from this particular query I have a feeling what you REALLY want is this:

SELECT   price, name
FROM      rooms
HAVING   price = MAX(price);

The first query using the subquery will do two scans of the table -- once for the outer query, and once for the inner subquery.  The second query (with the HAVING clause) should only scan the table once, which should be somewhat faster.

-- Dossy
0
 
phake123Author Commented:
I get this error:
Error 1064:  You have an error in your SQL syntax.  Check the manual that correspond to your MYSQL server version for the right syntax to use near 'Select max(price) from rooms' at line 3
0
 
mquirozCommented:
unless you use mysql 4.1, mysql doesn't support subqueries...
0
Keep up with what's happening at Experts Exchange!

Sign up to receive Decoded, a new monthly digest with product updates, feature release info, continuing education opportunities, and more.

 
SqueebeeCommented:
An alternative is this:

Select @max := max(price) from rooms;

Select a.price, a.name
from rooms
where a.price = @max;

Execute the two in series within the same database connection.
0
 
SqueebeeCommented:
Dossy: We have already established that the user cannot use subqueries, so the first example os out.  As for the second one: did you try this? You are combining an aggregate function with non-aggregate functions, which will cause MySQL to error out on illegal syntax.
0
 
DossyCommented:
Squeebee:  You're right, phake123 did say MySQL 4.0 -- oops.  And yes, the second query doesn't do what I thought.

Creating a simple test:

mysql> create table rooms (price int, name varchar(100));
mysql> insert into rooms values (10, "ten");
mysql> insert into rooms values (11, "eleven");        
mysql> insert into rooms values (15, "fifteen");        
mysql> insert into rooms values (5, "five");

This isn't optimal (as the ORDER BY still causes MySQL to do a full table scan and a filesort) but it works:

SELECT   price, name
FROM     rooms
ORDER   BY price DESC
LIMIT     1;

Returns the "15, fifteen" row.

However, your suggestion of using a variable to store MAX(price) and using that in a subsequent WHERE clause is definitely the most optimal solution since it CAN take advantage of indexes, etc.

0
 
SqueebeeCommented:
Hi Dossy;

Sorry to nit-pick but there is one scenario you need to consider: What happens when more than one product exists at the highest price? In such a situation you will only return one of the highest priced items, but if you had two items that each cost $15 only one would be returned. I'm not criticizing, just giving your something else to think about.
0
 
DossyCommented:
Yup, you're right.
0
 
phake123Author Commented:
Thanks everyone.  All your inputs were great!
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.