Which machine is better from these two:

From these two machine, which would be best for desktop publishing, web design, and graphics programs such as photoshop. - They are around the same price.

Thanks

1) Intel Pentium 4 Processor, 2.8GHz, 512K / 800 Front Side Bus - 4x512 PC333 Non-ECC DDR Memory - 146GB (10,000 rpm) U320/M SCSI Hard Drive - nVidia QuadroFX 500 (Dual-Monitor VGA - VGA/DVI) 128MB Graphics Card

2) Intel Xeon Processor, 2.4GHz, 512K Cache, 533MHz FSB - 1GB (2X512MB DIMM) 266MHz DDR Non-ECC SDRAM Memory - 73GB (15,000 rpm) U320/M SCSI Hard Drive - nVidia, Quadro4 280NVS, 2 VGA

Thanks
semmesAsked:
Who is Participating?
 
CallandorCommented:
Go for system 1, then, it will have a 166 FSB to go with the 333 memory, as opposed to 133 for the 266 memory.  In addition to more RAM, you can upgrade in the future to DDR400 if you want to get a speed increase, as well as dropping in a faster cpu.  The Xeon system will be constrained to Xeon processors, and although the 15000 rpm drive is the fastest available, the 10000 rpm drive is not bad and offers more capacity.
0
 
CallandorCommented:
If you had a pair of Xeons, I would say system 2, but for a single cpu, system 1 should be better.  What I don't get is the memory in it - why not DDR400, to match the 800 FSB?  What speed is the bus going to run at, if you're using 333 memory?  The 800 FSB is the edge, as well as the extra RAM, but make sure it can run at 800.
0
 
semmesAuthor Commented:
In short, I have been offered a deal on either of these two machines.  They were ordered by customers and then cancelled, so the shop will not change the spec, otherwise, I would have asked for DDR400
0
Ultimate Tool Kit for Technology Solution Provider

Broken down into practical pointers and step-by-step instructions, the IT Service Excellence Tool Kit delivers expert advice for technology solution providers. Get your free copy now.

 
compfixer101Commented:
i would say # 1 due to speed and a slower rpm on the hdd the higher rpm the shorter the life and well tell you the truth i have never seen a 15,000 rpm drive before      
0
 
semmesAuthor Commented:
Incidently, I have just spoken to them and they have offered me:

Intel Pentium 4 Processor, 3.0GHz, 512K / 800 Front Side Bus - 1GB (2x512) Dual-Channel DDR400 ECC RAM - 120GB(7200rpm) SATA/100 SATA Hard Drive - nVidia QuadroFX 500 (Dual-Monitor VGA - VGA/DVI) 128MB Graphics Card

it is slightly more than I wanted to spend, but may be worth it with the DDR400, however, it only has 7200 RPM HDD.  What do you recon?
0
 
semmesAuthor Commented:
..........Also, regarding system 2, it is cheaper than system 1, so I may be able to buy a second processor in the future.  Given this, would you still recommend system 1?
0
 
buckeyes33Commented:
this is a toss up between system 3 and 1.  They both have there pluses and minuses.  

I will say 1 because of the faster hard drive speed and more RAM.  This will make your picutures and stuff of that sort open and save quicker.
0
 
semmesAuthor Commented:
I have excluded system three, because it really is over my budget.  However, a point to note, although I do not think it will make a difference to your recommendations, System 1 has Intel 875P chipset and the Xeon has E7505 chipset
0
 
buckeyes33Commented:
>>System 1 has Intel 875P chipset and the Xeon has E7505 chipset
that is like compairing apples and oranges, because they have two different uses


so i will still stick with 1.
0
 
CallandorCommented:
A 2.4 Xeon will cost at least $202, according to pricewatch, so unless system 2 is cheaper by that amount AND has an empty socket, it would not be worth it.  The same dollars will buy you a much faster cpu in the future, so why be constrained to get a 2.4 Xeon in the future?
0
 
semmesAuthor Commented:
Your feedback was really good, would be grateful for help with this question:

http://www.experts-exchange.com/Hardware/Microchips/Q_21051714.html

thanks
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.