• Status: Solved
  • Priority: Medium
  • Security: Public
  • Views: 211
  • Last Modified:

Computer shuts down w/HD plugged in

Moved a big (120gig) IDE hd from one computer to another. Second computer dies (or won't start) as soon as it's plugged in - display disappears if running, no display at all if starting up, other HD makes 'clunking' noises(!), etc. Problem also appears if new HD is the ONLY thing plugged in. RMA'ed the HD; new one does the same thing - plugging it in turns it into a boat anchor. 'Puter runs fine without it.

Computer is a PIII / 600 MHz and thus old. But older computer runs HD fine.

Suggestions?

0
awacs0
Asked:
awacs0
  • 9
  • 5
  • 4
1 Solution
 
awacs0Author Commented:
Oh, just to emphasize: above happens (even) w/o data cable attached.
0
 
CallandorCommented:
Do mean attaching the hard drive causes problems, or booting from the hard drive causes problems?

If you are trying to boot from a hard drive from another computer and are using WinXP, you need to do a repair install, because the hardware abstraction layer has changed.  

WinXP: http://www.dougknox.com/xp/tips/xp_repair_install.htm 
Win2K: http://www.windowsreinstall.com/install/other/motherboard/win2k.htm
0
 
awacs0Author Commented:
Attaching the hd causes problems. It never gets even to the first BIOS screen (when restarting). Clearly not an OS thing.

Using Linux Mandrake 9.1.
0
VIDEO: THE CONCERTO CLOUD FOR HEALTHCARE

Modern healthcare requires a modern cloud. View this brief video to understand how the Concerto Cloud for Healthcare can help your organization.

 
CallandorCommented:
Would this be a Western Digital drive?  It has a different jumper setting for Single (no other drive) versus master (assumes a slave is attached).

If the problem is not the drive, then I would try a different IDE controller on this system - the one you tried may be defective.
0
 
awacs0Author Commented:
Yes, it's a WD - believe I played already with the jumpers on the first hd, but (anyway) that shouldn't matter if HD is the only thing plugged in, right?

Only two IDE controllers on the MB - tried 'em both. Darn.
0
 
eccs19Commented:
I wonder if your power supply is causing trouble.  Perhaps the new harddrive is just drawing enough power to put the PS over it's limits.  I think unlikely, but not impossible.
0
 
CallandorCommented:
If the only HD is the Western Digital, then it HAS to be set to Single.  However, that should not cause the computer to shut down.  Have you tried a different cable?
0
 
awacs0Author Commented:
to Eccs19: I've thought of this. But a 250w P/S having trouble powering the MB and ONE hard disk? You think?

to Callador: Yup, two cables on the MB, tried 'em both.
0
 
awacs0Author Commented:
... and, if the P/S were bad, wouldn't it blow a fuse? This one DOESN'T work with the drive plugged in (oh - another detail - if left plugged in long enough, it shuts down and won't restart right away - could be overheating? - but doesn't seem like it) - but does work when the drive is removed.

?
0
 
CallandorCommented:
Bad power supplies can cause the behavior you describe, without blowing a fuse.  They need the most current on startup, and if the power supply can't deliver, the system doesn't start up.  The 12v rail is the crucial one.
0
 
awacs0Author Commented:
And plugging in running HD would shut everything down? Hmmmm.

Really weird when I do that: the screen display disappears, the keyboard goes dead (lights on, but numlock etc. don't shut them off) and the other HD makes a clunking noise.

Very well, I'll swap P/S's Sunday and report back.

Thanks to both of you,
0
 
eccs19Commented:
Yes, even a 250 Watt PS sounds low for a P3.  I usually don't put anything less than a 350W myself.  

Power supplies can be very troublesome from issues like strange crashes to worse.  I've had a PS take out a hard drive, CD drive & MB.  CPU, sound & ram was about all that survived.
0
 
eccs19Commented:
"And plugging in running HD would shut everything down? Hmmmm.

Really weird when I do that: the screen display disappears, the keyboard goes dead (lights on, but numlock etc. don't shut them off) and the other HD makes a clunking noise."

This may sound like a strange question, but from what I'm reading above, are you plugging in the hard drive while the computer is powered on???  If you are doing this, this is a VERY BIG no no.  Perhaps clairify.

Best Regards
0
 
awacs0Author Commented:
Yes - just the power cable, not the data cable
"A very big no-no?" Is it really that unsafe? I never had a problem before ...
0
 
eccs19Commented:
My opinion is the data cable, definately not.  Power cable, not as bad, but when you do this, you are suddenly putting an unexpected load into the system that is currently running.  This could cause a crash definatly.  I guess the best way to explain it would be like having a brownout.  Suddenly your power is getting drained from somewhere and the lights go dim.  Usually electronic items don't like losing power like that.
0
 
awacs0Author Commented:
Ok, maybe that's true (and can the effect be worse than a laser printer starting up - although this is inside the box, where things are more sensitive), but that's NOT what's happening here.

"There are old technicians, and there are bold technicians, but there are NO old, bold technicians." - author unknown.
0
 
eccs19Commented:
The power from your lazer printer is not loaded on your PS, whereas the HD is.    If you've been doing this for a bit, could be that it's just had it's toll on the PS.
0
 
awacs0Author Commented:
Swapped for identical P/S. That fixed it.

But I still wonder what was wrong.
0

Featured Post

Concerto's Cloud Advisory Services

Want to avoid the missteps to gaining all the benefits of the cloud? Learn more about the different assessment options from our Cloud Advisory team.

  • 9
  • 5
  • 4
Tackle projects and never again get stuck behind a technical roadblock.
Join Now