• Status: Solved
  • Priority: Medium
  • Security: Public
  • Views: 335
  • Last Modified:

Promiscuous mode

Is there any solution for sniffing WITHOUT setting the promiscuous mode ?
0
DanLazar
Asked:
DanLazar
4 Solutions
 
cookreCommented:
No.  
Unless the NIC supports and is placeed in promiscuous mode, it will not report packets not intended for it.
0
 
danielsonchrisCommented:
Promiscuous mode just means to not clear the buffer on the network card. The nature of a un-switched network is to relay packets throughout and the computer with the corresponding MAC address will accept the packet and digest it.  Turning on promiscuous mode basically tells the network card to not disregard the packet even though the MAC address does not match.  Unless you have a software application running to digest the packet it will soon be cleared out of the buffer (in the case of promiscuous mode).  Basically promiscuous mode means to put the packet into a volatile buffer such that an application such as Ethereal could digest it and display it's contents.

So the answer is no, you must have promiscuous mode turned on.  Otherwise the packet is never copied into the buffer.  Some cards have hacks that allow you to enable this if it's not enabled by default.
Regards,
Chris
0
 
grayeCommented:
...and to make things more complicated.   The promiscuous mode has to be set both on the NIC and at the hub/switch.   Almost all hubs are now actually switches... so they too must be configured to pass all traffic to a particular port.   A low-cost hub might not even be configurable to become promiscuous.
0
Concerto's Cloud Advisory Services

Want to avoid the missteps to gaining all the benefits of the cloud? Learn more about the different assessment options from our Cloud Advisory team.

 
DominicCroninCommented:
It all depends what you mean by a "solution for sniffing". If all you want to do is debug some network traffic, it's very common to put some sort of proxy in between the client and the server.
0
 
cookreCommented:
All of us agreed that the answer is 'no'.
0
 
DominicCroninCommented:
Actually cookre, although I *do* agree that if you want to "sniff" then promiscuous mode is necessary, my suggestion was that often the problems you can solve by "sniffing" can be solved by interposing a proxy. The trouble is that word "sniff", isn't it? There's no "official" definition. Maybe we should get together and submit an RFC defining the word :-)

If sniff means "listen to network traffic not intended for your network interface", and "promiscuous mode" means "don't ignore traffic not intended for this network interface", then it's pretty obvious that you can't sniff without promiscuous mode. That still doesn't get us to a "solution" for sniffing.

What I sometimes think would be helpful would be having the option to change the question title to make it more useful to future PAQ hunters. After all, there's some useful knowledge in this thread, so it would be good to have it as a PAQ, but my worry is that the title won't help anyone to find the answers they need here.

As always - the hard part is getting the questioner to state their problem for what it is, rather than jumping in half-way towards their own perception of where the solution lies. It's unlikely that the questioner really wants to "sniff". DanLazar - if you are there - what did you really want to do?
0

Featured Post

Industry Leaders: We Want Your Opinion!

We value your feedback.

Take our survey and automatically be enter to win anyone of the following:
Yeti Cooler, Amazon eGift Card, and Movie eGift Card!

Tackle projects and never again get stuck behind a technical roadblock.
Join Now