• Status: Solved
  • Priority: Medium
  • Security: Public
  • Views: 341
  • Last Modified:

compaq hard drive substitute

Does anyone have any experience substituting other manufacturers scsi drives instead of buying compaqs specific drives?  I know it is supposed to void the warranty, but do they work ok?

I have an extra compaq 532 array controller and I want to mirror a couple of 72 gig or larger non hot plug drives and use it for data.  However I don't want to pay the money for the compaq drives.  The only 72 gig non hot plug compaq drive I can find is in excess of $400. The part # is 332751-B21.  Also I don't care if the drives operate at Ultra320, Wide Ultra3 or Wide Ultra2.

Anyone have any experience doing this?
0
donnatronious
Asked:
donnatronious
1 Solution
 
cyrnelCommented:
I would have no reservations about using a non-Compaq packaged drive in that situation unless it were a company system (not mine) or one under a Compaq support contract. Nothing is going to blow up unless you do something very wrong.

-SCSI is mature and good with regard to inter-vendor compatibility.

-Compaq sources their drives & controllers from other companies who make their money selling standards compliant products. In general, a company will specify house-brand drives to reduce the variables for support commitments (warranty and contract), and of course to improve profitability. While the  policy seems ethically shakey, knowing you have house-brand drives does shrink their testing matrices.

If it's your sytem have at it. If the company's, I'd be sure a larger IT authority doesn't have an existing solution/policy. If there's a warranty or contract it would come down to whether saving a X dollars is worth the remaining coverage.

Dave
0
 
donnatroniousAuthor Commented:
cyrnel-

Thanks for the response.  That is what I believe as well.  However I am really looking for a response from someone who has actual experience using third party drives with compaq array controllers.  I have a response from someone in a forum other than EE who claims that "All compaq SA controllers require HDDs with HP/Compaq firmware".  I think he is full of it however I wanted to ask someone here with experience.
0
 
InvalidloginCommented:
Yes I have used wd scsi drives with a compaq 532 array controller and had no problems compaq just wants you to buy there drives.

Good Luck
0

Featured Post

Microsoft Certification Exam 74-409

VeeamĀ® is happy to provide the Microsoft community with a study guide prepared by MVP and MCT, Orin Thomas. This guide will take you through each of the exam objectives, helping you to prepare for and pass the examination.

Tackle projects and never again get stuck behind a technical roadblock.
Join Now