Solved

OO PHP: Class seems to vanish after calling a method in a parent class

Posted on 2004-09-21
11
205 Views
Last Modified: 2012-05-05
Hello,

I have this problem I just can find a solution for. I made a couple of card-game classes, and everything works fine until I attempt to call the method returnCardToDeck() in the class Game, from the class Hand. The way I did it is, as you can see below, by using parent::returnCardToDeck($oldcard) twice, working my way up from Hand->Player->Game and from there going into Deck.

The weird thing is that when I reach Game, and attempt to call a method in Deck (near ((((MARK)))) ), the class Deck seems to have vanished from Game! I keep getting an error that I attempt to call a function of a non-object...
Near ((((MARK2)))) Deck is still in existance.

Now i have 2 questions:

-What am I doing wrong here?
-Is there a faster way to call the function returnCardToDeck() in the class Deck, while in the class Hand? Why doesnt something like this work: parent->parent->deck->returnCardToDeck() ?

Here is some of the classes code (i left out parts that had nothing to do with the problem):

class Game
{
      var $deck;
      var $amountofplayers;
      var $players;

      function Game($amountofplayers)
      {
            $this->amountofplayers = $amountofplayers;
            $this->players = array();
            $this->deck = new Deck();
            for ($x=1;$x<=$amountofplayers;$x++)
            {
                  $pid = "P".$x;
                  array_push($this->players, new Player($pid));
            }
      }

      function swap1card($player_id,$card_id)
      {
            foreach ($this->players as $player)
            {
                  if ($player->getId() == $player_id)
                  {
                        $card = $this->deck->drawCards(1);
((((MARK2))))
                        print_r($this->deck);
                        $player->swapCard($card_id,$card[1]);
                  }
            }
      }

      function returnCardToDeck($oldcard)
      {
            // ((((MARK))))
            //$this->deck seems to no longer be an object here!!!! Its just empty!
            $this->deck->returnCardToDeck($oldcard);
      }
}

class Deck extends Game
{
      var $cards;
      function Deck()
      {
            // ***
            //Code that is generating cards is here....
            // ***
      }

      // Returns $card (which should be a valid card object) to the back of the deck
      function returnCardToDeck($oldcard)
      {
            array_push($this->cards, $oldcard);
      }
}

class Player extends Game
{
      var $player_id;
      var $hand;
      
      function Player($player_id)
      {
            $this->player_id = $player_id;
            $this->hand = new Hand;
      }
      
      // Draw 1 card from the deck and add it on top of the pile of cards player is holidng
      function getCard($card)
      {
            $this->hand->addCard($card);
      }
      
      function swapCard($card_id, $card)
      {
            $this->hand->swapCard($card_id, $card);
      }
      
      function returnCardToDeck($oldcard)
      {
            parent::returnCardToDeck($oldcard);
      }
            
}

class Hand extends Player
{
      var $cards;
      var $colors;
      var $values;
      var $vector;
      var $c_flush;
      
      function Hand()
      {
            $this->cards = array();
      }
      
      function addCard($card)
      {
            array_push($this->cards, $card);
      }
      
      function returnCardToDeck($oldcard)
      {
            parent::returnCardToDeck($oldcard);
      }
      
      function swapCard($card_id, $newcard)
      {
            $card_id = $card_id - 1;
            //Return old card to deck
            $this->returnCardToDeck($this->cards[$card_id]);
            //Replace part from $this->cards, starting from position $card_id, length 1, by $newcard
            array_splice($this->cards, ($card_id-0), 1, array($newcard));
      }
}

Thanks for considering. If required, I can post the entire class code here.
0
Comment
Question by:Ildefonse
  • 6
  • 4
11 Comments
 
LVL 48

Expert Comment

by:hernst42
ID: 12120143
Yes that correct that that error occurs.
Hand extends Player extends Game
but you never call the constructor of the parent class
e.g:
     function Hand()
     {
          $this->cards = array();
     }

should be:
     function Hand()
     {
          $this->Player();
          $this->cards = array();
     }
same should apply to Player. So the Deck gets initialized. But I think what you wanted to do and what you programmed is wrong.

Why need the class Hand to be extended from the class Player? I think class Player uses a Class Hand and the Hand belongs to a player. The same applies to Player and Game. So you should recheck your design.
So in Hand the function returnCardToDeck($oldcard) should do this:
$this->Player->returnCardToDeck($oldcard);
and in Player the function returnCardToDeck($oldcard) should do this:
$this->Game->returnCardToDeck($oldcard);

Hope this gets you on the right way.
0
 
LVL 4

Expert Comment

by:aratani
ID: 12123328
Can you post your whole class code so that I can look at it?

Thanks

AJ
0
 
LVL 1

Author Comment

by:Ildefonse
ID: 12125123
Okay i have tried this:

So in Hand the function returnCardToDeck($oldcard) should do this:
$this->Player->returnCardToDeck($oldcard);
and in Player the function returnCardToDeck($oldcard) should do this:
$this->Game->returnCardToDeck($oldcard);

But that does not work. It generates the error "Call to a member function foo() on a non-object". When I am located inside a method of Hand, the code does not recognize $this->Player as an object apparently, regardless of whether I extend Hand from Player or not.

I do have managed to let my function work, but I did this in a different way:

In class Hand the old card is returned by means of a funtion return:

function swapCard($card_id, $newcard)
      {
            $card_id = $card_id - 1;
            //Return old card to deck
            $oldcard = $this->cards[$card_id];
            //Replace part from $this->cards, starting from position $card_id, length 1, by $newcard
            array_splice($this->cards, ($card_id-0), 1, array($newcard));
            return $oldcard;
      }

And after using this function I inject the $oldcard back into the pile using a method from the Game->Deck classes. Here is my entire class code:

//***
//* Class Game
//****************************************************************************************************
class Game
{
      var $deck;
      var $amountofplayers;
      var $players;

      function Game($amountofplayers)
      {
            $this->amountofplayers = $amountofplayers;
            $this->players = array();
            $this->deck = new Deck();
            for ($x=1;$x<=$amountofplayers;$x++)
            {
                  $pid = "P".$x;
                  array_push($this->players, new Player($pid));
            }
      }

      function makeNewDeck()
      {
            $this->deck = new Deck();
      }
      
      function getDeck()
      {
            return $this->deck;
      }
      
      function getAmountOfPlayers()
      {
            return $this->amountofplayers;
      }
      
      function getPlayers()
      {
            return $this->players;
      }
      
      function deal5Cards()
      {
            //Make a loop 5 times and each time deal a card to each player
            for($x=1;$x<=5;$x++)
            {
                  foreach ($this->players as $player)
                  {
                        $card = $this->deck->drawCards(1);
                        $player->getCard($card[1]);
                  }
            }
      }
      
      function swap1card($player_id,$card_id)
      {
            foreach ($this->players as $player)
            {
                  if ($player->getId() == $player_id)
                  {
                        $card = $this->deck->drawCards(1);
                        return $player->hand->swapCard($card_id,$card[1]);
                  }
            }
      }

      function returnCardToDeck($oldcard)
      {
            $this->deck->returnCardToDeck($oldcard);
      }
      
}

//***
//* Class Deck
//****************************************************************************************************
class Deck
{
      var $cards;
      
      function Deck()
      {
            // Define $cards as an array
            $this->cards = array();
            
            // Upon creation of a new cardpack add 52 cards with values 2 to 14 and colors H/C/D/S to $cards.
            for ($color_count=1;$color_count<=4;$color_count++)
            {
                  // First define the colors
                  switch ($color_count)
                  {
                        case 1:
                        $color = "H";
                        break;
                        
                        case 2:
                        $color = "C";
                        break;
                        
                        case 3:
                        $color = "D";
                        break;
                        
                        case 4:
                        $color = "S";
                        break;
                  }
                  
                  // Now define the values
                  for ($value=2;$value<=14;$value++)
                  {
                        // Make a new card
                        array_push($this->cards, new Card($value, $color));
                  }
                  
            }
            
            $this->shuffleDeck();
      }
      
      //Shuffle the deck
      function shuffleDeck()
      {
            shuffle($this->cards);
      }
      
      //Get the amount of cards in this deck
      function getAmountOfCards()
      {
            return count($this->cards);
      }
      
       // Returns an array with all cards in deck
      function getCards()
      {
                   return $this->cards;
      }
      
      // Draw the card at the beginning of the pile
      function drawCards($amount)
      {
            $cardsdrawn = array();
            for($x=1;$x<=$amount;$x++)
            {
                  $cardsdrawn[$x] = array_shift($this->cards);
            }
            return $cardsdrawn;
      }
      
      // Returns $card (which should be a valid card object) to the back of the deck
      function returnCardToDeck($oldcard)
      {
            array_push($this->cards, $oldcard);
      }
      
}
//***
//* Class Card
//****************************************************************************************************
class Card
{
      var $value;
      var $color;
      
      function Card($value,$color)
      {
            $this->value = $value;
            $this->color = $color;
      }

      function getValue()
      {
                  return $this->value;
      }

      function getColor()
      {
            return $this->color;
      }
      
}
//***
//* Class Player
//****************************************************************************************************
class Player
{
      var $player_id;
      var $hand;
      
      function Player($player_id)
      {
            $this->player_id = $player_id;
            $this->hand = new Hand;
      }
      
      // Draw 1 card from the deck and add it on top of the pile of cards player is holidng
      function getCard($card)
      {
            $this->hand->addCard($card);
      }
      
      function getId()
      {
            return $this->player_id;
      }

      function getHand()
      {
            return $this->hand->getCards();
      }
            
}
//***
//* Class Hand
//****************************************************************************************************
class Hand
{
      var $cards;
      
      function Hand()
      {
            $this->cards = array();
      }
      
      function addCard($card)
      {
            array_push($this->cards, $card);
      }
      
      function swapCard($card_id, $newcard)
      {
            $card_id = $card_id - 1;
            //Return old card to deck
            $oldcard = $this->cards[$card_id];

            //Replace part from $this->cards, starting from position $card_id, length 1, by $newcard
            array_splice($this->cards, ($card_id-0), 1, array($newcard));

            return $oldcard;
      }
      
      function getCards()
      {
            return $this->cards;
      }
}

===============================================================================
I have one additional question; is there a faster way than..

foreach ($this->players as $player)
            {
                  if ($player->getId() == $player_id)
                  {
                        $card = $this->deck->drawCards(1);
                        return $player->hand->swapCard($card_id,$card[1]);
                  }
            }

..to pick the proper $player from $this->players based on the player_id?

Thanks.
0
 
LVL 48

Expert Comment

by:hernst42
ID: 12125495
Index the array you are creating with the pid.
function Game($amountofplayers)
{
          $this->amountofplayers = $amountofplayers;
          $this->players = array();
          $this->deck = new Deck();
          for ($x=1;$x<=$amountofplayers;$x++)
          {
               $pid = "P".$x;
               $p = new Player($pid);
               $this->players[$p->getID()] = &$p;
          }
}

Then you can access a specific player by
$this->player[$player_id]->hand ...
0
 
LVL 1

Author Comment

by:Ildefonse
ID: 12126987
Thanks hernst42! That's indeed a simple but elegant solution. I'll split some points up for you :)
0
Why You Should Analyze Threat Actor TTPs

After years of analyzing threat actor behavior, it’s become clear that at any given time there are specific tactics, techniques, and procedures (TTPs) that are particularly prevalent. By analyzing and understanding these TTPs, you can dramatically enhance your security program.

 
LVL 1

Author Comment

by:Ildefonse
ID: 12127019
On a side note, why would $p need to be assigned by reference here?
0
 
LVL 48

Expert Comment

by:hernst42
ID: 12127128
If you are using PHP4 = makes a copy of objects. So it can happen that you modify a copy of an object instead of the real object. If you loop with foreach over objects the result may not the one you are expecting. Should also work if you don't use the as you are not referencing other objects in Player (like the game-object)
0
 
LVL 1

Author Comment

by:Ildefonse
ID: 12127153
I am using php5, and adding the & messed up the code (dealing all cards 25 times).

Does = still make copies of objects in php5?
0
 
LVL 1

Author Comment

by:Ildefonse
ID: 12127199
I changed the code to:

            for ($x=1;$x<=$amountofplayers;$x++)
            {
                  $pid = "P".$x;
                  $this->players[$pid] = new Player($pid);
            }

removing $p from the code.
0
 
LVL 48

Accepted Solution

by:
hernst42 earned 300 total points
ID: 12127257
no with php5 you don't need that. There objects are passed by reference and not coppied anymore. Will make a lot things more easy when working with objects.
0
 
LVL 1

Author Comment

by:Ildefonse
ID: 12127733
great thanks :)
0

Featured Post

Top 6 Sources for Identifying Threat Actor TTPs

Understanding your enemy is essential. These six sources will help you identify the most popular threat actor tactics, techniques, and procedures (TTPs).

Join & Write a Comment

Things That Drive Us Nuts Have you noticed the use of the reCaptcha feature at EE and other web sites?  It wants you to read and retype something that looks like this.Insanity!  It's not EE's fault - that's just the way reCaptcha works.  But it is …
Password hashing is better than message digests or encryption, and you should be using it instead of message digests or encryption.  Find out why and how in this article, which supplements the original article on PHP Client Registration, Login, Logo…
Learn how to match and substitute tagged data using PHP regular expressions. Demonstrated on Windows 7, but also applies to other operating systems. Demonstrated technique applies to PHP (all versions) and Firefox, but very similar techniques will w…
The viewer will learn how to dynamically set the form action using jQuery.

758 members asked questions and received personalized solutions in the past 7 days.

Join the community of 500,000 technology professionals and ask your questions.

Join & Ask a Question

Need Help in Real-Time?

Connect with top rated Experts

17 Experts available now in Live!

Get 1:1 Help Now