One way ping

I am connecting a server (win 2003) to a desktop (win XP) via a crossover cable.

the problem is that the server can ping the client machine ok, but the client cant ping the server.

if i do try a ping from the client, i can follow it up with an arp -a and see that it did find the ip address i wanted against the MAC address of the network card in the server, but the ping just does not work.

server details:
ip: 10.1.143.55
subnet: 255.255.255.0
gateway: 10.1.143.55
DNS: 10.1.143.55

client details:
ip: 10.1.143.200
subnet: 255.255.255.0
gateway: 10.1.143.55
DNS: 10.1.143.55

please help :-)
mwoolgerAsked:
Who is Participating?
 
scampgbConnect With a Mentor Commented:
Very odd indeed.  It could be a problem with the TCP/IP stack.
Try running WinsockXPFix - www.spychecker.com/program/winsockxpfix.html

It does sound like a firewall-type issue.  Are there any other applications on the machines that could be providing firewalling capabilities?
0
 
georgecooldudeCommented:
I suspect your crossover cable has been wired badly? Did you make it yourself? Try testing it with a cable tester or replace with a new cable and try.

Thats all i can think of
0
 
scampgbCommented:
Hi mwoolger,
I think it more likely to be something in software that's stopping the pings.

Do you have any firewall software set up on either of the machines (including the in-built Windows firewall)?
Are you running ISA server on the Server?

Are you able to make any other type of network connection from the server to the PC - putting \\clientpc\c$ in the Run command for example?
0
Improve Your Query Performance Tuning

In this FREE six-day email course, you'll learn from Janis Griffin, Database Performance Evangelist. She'll teach 12 steps that you can use to optimize your queries as much as possible and see measurable results in your work. Get started today!

 
Welltech-ITCommented:
Make sure a firewall isnt causing a connection problem.
Try turning off any firewall protection to test if its the problem, if it is then depending on the firewall you have you need to allow traffic on the local area network (LAN). Either setup an allowed IP address or range of IP addresses to pass through the firewall.
0
 
ArlCommented:
Hi,

Just in case, are you sure about your subnet ?
with an ip: 10.1.143.55 your subnet should be more 255.0.0.0....

Just in case. (sorry if I mistake)

Hope that can help.
0
 
scampgbCommented:
Arl:  mwoolger's existing subnet mask (255.255.255.0) is absolutely fine for their environment.  Changing it could well stop things working :-)
0
 
ArlCommented:
ok, fair enough... sorry :-)
0
 
georgecooldudeCommented:
11111111.11111111.11111111.00000000 -binary

255.255.255.0 - decimal form

Wouldn't have have borrow all the bits on the subnet mask leaving no usable bits for host addresses?

Or maybe my subnetting has got a bit rusty and I need to practise some more.
0
 
AutoSpongeCommented:
Both devices should be broadcasting, therefore their IP address should be the same as the gateway.  Change the second machine's gateway to match its IP address.  Aslo make sure you don't have the windows FW turned on with the LAN connection of the server.
0
 
yvsupportCommented:
you dont need a gateway as both adresses are on the same subnet. remove and retest.
0
 
TRobertsonCommented:
If the Windows firewall or any other is enabled it will block ping request therefore you will get no response.  Depending on what you want to do with these two devices you will have to open the proper ports.
0
 
kapesCommented:
Specifically, IS Firewall is enabled on Windows 2003 server?

If yes, go to specific network connection's properties > advanced> firewall settings>
enable "ICMP ECHO" responses

0
 
mwoolgerAuthor Commented:
Thankyou all for your posts. Here are the results:

1) Checked network connection on both systems and neither has the firewall option checked under the advanced tab.

2)Have tried with a different cable - to no avail.

3) Put \\10.1.143.200\c$ in the Run command (of server) and it prompted for a password - i assume this means some connection is being made between the server and client.

so no further forward. (yet)
0
 
PennGwynCommented:
For ping to work, ICMP Echo Request packets have to flow in one direction, and ICMP Echo Reply packets in the other.  If ping from either side works, then the cable is fine, and the routing is probably fine.

I've seen ping work from one side, but not the other, in two scenarios:

(90+%)  1. A firewall somewhere was allowing one of the above ICMP types in only one direction.  I know, you think you've eliminated this possibility....

(<10%)  2. One of the IP addresses was duplicated, or being proxy arped by some third device, such that the "successful" pings were actually being answered by the third device and the unsuccessful pings failed because their responses were sent to the third device.

0
 
scampgbCommented:
PennGwyn: I've never encountered (2) - but I'll bear that one in mind for the future :-)
0
 
JammyPakCommented:
did you try removing the Default Gateway from both systems?
0
 
mwoolgerAuthor Commented:
Thankyou all very much.
the location of the "extra" firewall was
on the server in Administrative tools->routing (and access?). right clicked on the domain and saw that it reckoned the domain was one to be connected to the internet rather than a private domain. changed this setting to be correct and it all worked instantly
0
 
scampgbCommented:
*grin*

Glad I could help :-)

0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.