right click .m3u file... Save Target As...

Hey when you right click on an .m3u link and select 'Save Target As' in to your computer, you can actually read the file and where the mp3's are located. Is there any way around this?
vinny45Asked:
Who is Participating?
 
arantiusConnect With a Mentor Commented:
"Is there any way around this?"

No.  It's been said many times.  If you want to give it to people, they can get it.

The only thing you can do is make it difficult for them to really "save" it.  Other files with more DRM and using transfer protocols besides HTTP make it harder, but if you give it to them at all, they can always keep it somehow.
0
 
mrielfCommented:
What is your problem? You want to hide the mp3 files real location?

It's impossible because M3U file is simply text file storing the local or remote location of the actual audio file. Example:

Local directory (a MP3 file on your computer) - C:\temp\mysong.mp3, or Remote directory/Hyperlink (a MP3 file on the Internet) - http://www.mp3.com/mysong.mp3

The media players finds the audio through this file. You can deny download file, but then the file will be unusable for players.
0
 
davidlars99Commented:
0
The new generation of project management tools

With monday.com’s project management tool, you can see what everyone on your team is working in a single glance. Its intuitive dashboards are customizable, so you can create systems that work for you.

 
liadsCommented:
Amazon uses a streaming server.
This is actually the only way to allow listening and deny download of a media file.
However, mp3 is not a streaming format, and has no streaming server to support it.

If you really want to hide the location of your mp3s, either convert them to wma format (or another streaming format) and stream it, or make a web page with a limited activex player embedded in it, that doesn't show the media location.
0
 
frugleCommented:
> mp3 is not a streaming format, and has no streaming server to support it.

Wrong and Wrong.

http://www.google.com/search?q=streaming+mp3

Results 1 - 10 of about 1,830,000 for streaming mp3

####################################################

http://www.shoutcast.com/

Shoutcast is Nullsoft's Free Winamp-based distributed streaming audio system (MPEG Layer3 Audio Streaming Technology)

####################################################

http://www.linuxlookup.com/html/guides/streaming-mp3.html

The purpose of this document is to describe the process of using Linux based tools to setup a server used for streaming MP3 data.

####################################################

http://www.developingwebs.net/html/mp3.php

"The MP3 will stream as it loads on the page"

####################################################


To get back to the point and answer the question, yes - a m3u file CAN be opened in a text editor and is humanly readable. You can add a layer of complication to the "download" by saving a playlist which contains the m3u. The .pls would open winamp and begin streaming. The user would then have to edit the playlist to find the m3u then edit the m3u to find the mp3. nothing is perfect.

There are several tools available to save streams to disk, so you're not protecting anything by hiding the location.

Mike
0
 
davidlars99Commented:
vaa ha ha ha ha

:)
0
 
davidlars99Commented:
and I'd say that .mp3 on linux or mac server is lot faster then .wma
0
 
frugleCommented:
> I think you can too if amazon.com does...

since you're laughing... Amazon streams wma files either for windows media player streaming or through a windows media embedded ocx. They also use RealAudio which has limited compatibility for non-microsofties.

no offence :-)

Mike
0
 
davidlars99Commented:
I'm still laughing and saying: It doesn't make diference since you can do it too...
0
 
frugleCommented:
true, but if all your files are in mp3 format anyway, why risk corrupting them further transforming them into any other format?

Otherwise I'd say go for .ogg and IceCast. [http://www.icecast.org/]



0
 
davidlars99Commented:
i didn't say that
0
 
davidlars99Commented:
it was a one armed man
0
 
vinny45Author Commented:
Doesn't Windows Server 2003 have a thing called Media Services that handle streaming mp3s?  Isn't there a way to stream it and deny download using the service?  I don't have server 2003, so does anyone have any info on that?
0
 
frugleCommented:
> Isn't there a way to stream it and deny download

no.  Think about what the word "download" means. If you deny download the user will not be able to listen to the file.

You can set up all manner of copyright protection and media licensing, but at the end of the day if a user decides to record the music there are at least 10 ways to achieve this whilst circumventing the protection you have put in place.

From a cost issue alone, Media Services is going to set you back a fair sum for the server, licensing and additional training.

Mike
0
 
davidlars99Commented:
yes vinny45, you are right Windows 2003 comes with Windows Media Player 9 and you can stream variety of audio/video files like ASF, WAV, AVI, MOV, MPEG, MIDI, IVF, AIF, VOD, AU, MP3, ID3 and even DVDs
0
 
vinny45Author Commented:
cool davidlars99, thats good to know, will be searching info on that.
0
All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.