Link to home
Start Free TrialLog in
Avatar of icysmarty
icysmarty

asked on

Recursive binary search char*

I am trying to implement a recursive binary search function that takes 4 arguments.
void binary_search(char target[], int first, int last, int index);

The target will be the name that is stored in an array of char.
The problem I have is whenever it encounter names with same first char, the problem will go into an infinited loop.
I tried using the algorithm to search for an array of integer, but it doesn't work for my case.

The following is what I did:

midder = first+last/2;
int i=0, k=0;
char *array = //something
while(first <= last){
        if(target[i] == array[k]){
               i++, k++; //compare other characters in the array
         }else if (target[i] < array[k])
                last = middle - (size of name in array);
                middle =( middle/size of name in array/2)*size of the name in array
                k = middle;
                i = 0;
         }else if (target[i] > array[k]){
                first = middle + size of name in array
                middle = (first/size of name in array)+((last - first)/size of name in array/2)*size of name in array)
                k = middle;
                t = 0;
         }
}

I see a lot of redundant steps in this program. So, I am thinking of implementing a recursive binary search which will be more efficient that this.
Any help with explainination will be appreciated.
Avatar of jkr
jkr
Flag of Germany image

>>I am thinking of implementing a recursive binary search which will be more efficient that this

Why reinventing the wheel? Use 'std::binary_search()': http://www.sgi.com/tech/stl/binary_search.html
Avatar of icysmarty
icysmarty

ASKER

That stl binary search returns bool value. Instead, I need to retrieve the index of the item once it is found in the array.
You can use std::lower_bound, which will return a pointer to the array entry where the searched-for term *would be*. You can then check to see if this is indeed the right entry, and get the index from the pointer if it is, or return an error if not.
SOLUTION
Avatar of Hamed Zaghaghi
Hamed Zaghaghi
Flag of Iran, Islamic Republic of image

Link to home
membership
This solution is only available to members.
To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.
Start Free Trial
note :

>>>midder = first+last/2;

must replace with midder = (first+last)/2;

good luck


>>     if(target[mid]<val)
          return binary_search(target, mid, last, val);

what is the val you mean in this if statement?
The index variable in my function will return the index in the array where the target is found.
The target array will be compared with a buffer array which has the data from a file.

target[mid] is a character and val is an integer, how can I compare this two?

array[k] is an array with fixed length data.
Say each field occupies 10 bytes.
In the array, the data will appear to be like this :
'A''L''E''X' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' 'B''E''N''N''Y'' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' 'B''O''B''O'' '' '' '' '' '' '
So say mid will be pointing 'B'(of Benny) then the function needs to move forward to check the other characters.
That's where i stuck.
Hi,

I wrote this function by these rules that target is an int array, val is the valu that i was to find it, and my function return the index of finded valu in target array;

so,
#define NAME_LEN   10

//this function compare target[first]...target[first+NAME_LEN] with
//array[0]...array[NAME_LEN] and return these values:
// if target < array return negetive number
// if target > array return positive number
// if target == array return 0
int check(char target[], int  start)
{
     int i;
     for(i=0; i<NAME_LEN; i++)
     {
          if(target[i]==array[i])
               continue;
          else
               return target[i]-array[i];
     }
     return 0;
}

int binary_search( char target[], int first, int last)
{
     if(last<first)
          return -1;
     int mid = ( first + ( last / NAME_LEN ) ) / 2;
     mid *= NAME_LEN;
     int sw = check(target,  mid);
     if(sw < 0)
          return binary_search(target, mid, last);
     else if(sw > 0 )
          return binary_search(target, first, mid);
     else // sw == 0
          return mid;
}


Have a good programming day.
>> Say each field occupies 10 bytes
that helps a lot.

why "void binary_search(char target[], int first, int last, int index)"? don't you want to pass in the array_to_search_ in and array_to_search_ for? and why pass the index? you should be returning the index.

int binary_search(char *array, char *target, int first, int last){
  if(first > last) return -1;

  int middle = (first+last)/2;
  int comp = strncmp(&array[middle], target, strlen(target);
  if(comp == 0) return middle;
  if(comp < 0) return binary_search(array, target, middle, last);
  else return binary_search(array, target, first, middle-10);
}

note that first, last and middle must be multiples of 10 (or whaterver field length you choose). also note (middle-10) instead of the usual (middle-1).

jaydutt
sorry, zaghaghi got there first.
strcmp do not work with both arrays. I tried. So, I implement the comparrison function, and again, it looks redundant.
The recursion doesn't as I tried. So, this is my binary search. Can you see a way to make it recursive?

if(first <= last){
      while(first <= last && !found ){      //begins binary search
            if(target[t] == IBuffer[k]){      //check for next characters
                  while(IBuffer[k] != 32)
                  {            
                        if(target[t] == IBuffer[k])
                        {
                              found_count= found_count+1;
                              
                        }else if(target[t] < IBuffer[k])
                        {
                              last = middle-22;
                              middle = ((middle)/22/2)*22;
                              k=middle;
                              t=0;
                              break;
                        }else{
                              first = middle+22;
                              middle = ((first/22)+((last-first)/22/2))*22;
                              k=middle;
                              t=0;
                              break;

                        }
                        t++;k++;
                                          
                  }
                  if(found_count == t){
                        found = true;
                        RRN = get_RRN(middle+16);
                        return middle;
                  }
                  found_count = 0;
             }else if(target[t] < IBuffer[k]){      
                  
                  last = middle-22;
                  middle = ((middle)/22/2)*22;
                  k=middle;
                  t=0;
                  
            }else if(target[t] > IBuffer[k]){
                  
                  first = middle+22;
                  middle = ((first/22)+((last-first)/22/2))*22;
                  k=middle;
                  t=0;
            }
      }
      }else{
            return -1;
            found = false;
      }

Thank you.
ASKER CERTIFIED SOLUTION
Link to home
membership
This solution is only available to members.
To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.
Start Free Trial
strncmp causes an access violation to the program
nope. it doesn't. I ran it. here's sample output:

name1
name0     name1     name2     name3     name4     name5
1
Press any key to continue_
Cool.
The problem is with the middle value.
I have changed it according to the size of the data structure.
Also, I changed it to static int instead of int cause only the first middle will be ( first + last)/2
Thank you for all the helps.
I think I should give credit to zaghagi too.

Solving the searching problem here comes the sorting problem. I have posted it in another post. Take a look if you have any clue about that. Here is the link.
https://www.experts-exchange.com/questions/21189206/Linked-list-sorting.html