router linux question

Hi,
I have 3 computers: Winxp, Linux9.0, Win2000
I am using DSL from Qwest and I would like to use Linux as a webserver.

Case 1
DSL Modem
  |
  |
Linux9.0 (eth0, eth1)- Router
  |
  |
Switch
  |    \
 winxp  Win2000


Case 2
     DSL Modem
        |
        |
Router(LinkSys, or Dlink)
  |          |         |
  |          |         |
Linux       WinXp     Win2000
Server9.0


I have 2 questions:
1) case 1 : should I build the Linux as the router? ( I see a lot of people have problem with this)
2) case 2 : Can I buy the router still host web, ftp? and using Winxp the same time?

Please help  
don04Asked:
Who is Participating?
 
tapkepConnect With a Mentor Commented:
case 1: formally - yes, you can. Although it is bad idea to run additional services (such as web, ftp) on *router*. Of course, if you don't care about your network security, you can run everything on one computer :)

case 2: if you need just web server - build just a web server. In that case, you will need your router to forward ports (at least 80 tcp) from outside to your linux box. You will be able to use internet from other computers.
0
 
kidomanConnect With a Mentor Commented:
Hi,

Both the solutions were suite your setup just fine. By forwarding ports 21 and 80 to the IP address (internal) of the Linux server in case 2, you would be able to host the website as well as use WINDOWS XP. THis would be a hassle free solution because configuring the LINUX router in this configuration can be a bit involved (but nothing that EE experts (like me) cant solve....?)

I would suggest to get a Router which allows for port forwarding and then setup the actual forwarding. However, if u r on a steep budget, then Linux router will not cause you any problems at all.....

Cheers,

karan
0
 
don04Author Commented:
i like both ans
Thanks!
0
Free Tool: Subnet Calculator

The subnet calculator helps you design networks by taking an IP address and network mask and returning information such as network, broadcast address, and host range.

One of a set of tools we're offering as a way of saying thank you for being a part of the community.

 
kidomanCommented:
Hi,

If you like both answer, then consider splitting the points between the two of us. See, some of us are "hungry" for points....

Cheers,

Karan
0
 
don04Author Commented:
Admin
Please slit the points for tapkep and kidoman.
I was trying to spitting the points but i didn't know how :(. I am so new with this.
thanks
0
 
kidomanCommented:
Thanks man, really appreciate it.....just crossed 10k points ;) hurray!!!
0
All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.