Hard Drive Failure - Wont allow pc to POST

A quick overview -

PC (my sisters) with two 40Gb IDE drives, one used as a backup for those crucial digital photos.  PC packs in, wont power on, first instinct was power supply.  Power supply ok, disconnecting the IDE cables, this allowed the PC to boot, albeit without a hard drive.  Connected primary drive, powered on... meltdown!  Chips on the bottom of hard drive smoked, blistered and burned... suggest its bin material.  Plugged in the Slave drive in the hope that the first drive was the issue, nothing happens when the power is turned on except the power led is lit, no POST, no whirring of fans, no visual on the monitor, nothing. (no burning which is better than the primary!).  Removing the IDE cable allows the PC to boot, again without a drive.

I tried to use the slave drive in my own PC but this has the same effect, it does not allow the PC to do anything.  I haven't tried amending the BIOS to stop the 'halt on error' status just yet, thought I'd try this forum first.

My question - Is this drive truly goosed or is their some way of recovering the data without paying a fortune to a recovery company (or removing platters)?

I have awarded 150 points for someone to probably tell me what I suspect, however I'm happy to make that 1000 points for a successful recovery of the data.
Who is Participating?
I wear a lot of hats...

"The solutions and answers provided on Experts Exchange have been extremely helpful to me over the last few years. I wear a lot of hats - Developer, Database Administrator, Help Desk, etc., so I know a lot of things but not a lot about one thing. Experts Exchange gives me answers from people who do know a lot about one thing, in a easy to use platform." -Todd S.

A drive that won't let a system boot up is a drive that you can't do much with.  The problem is likely on the controller board, so if you can get hold of an identical drive, you may be able to replace the board with the one from the new drive and access the problem drive.

Experts Exchange Solution brought to you by

Your issues matter to us.

Facing a tech roadblock? Get the help and guidance you need from experienced professionals who care. Ask your question anytime, anywhere, with no hassle.

Start your 7-day free trial
I do not know of any software that can retrieve data but their are comoanies that specialise in data recovery. Some of them work by courier i.e you courier them the drive and they send it back either repaired or with data recovered. Not sure of costs may be too costly.

Some websites

Just to be clear, when you put the backup hard drive on the IDE line the PC doesn't POST at all?  Like nothing (I ask because sometimes PCs like DELLs take 10 minutes to autodetect)?  Does the HDD light stay on?  Does the backup HD spin up at least?  You tried the other IDE channel and made sure the Jumper settings on the HDD is correct?  I would try all different jumper positions including no jumper.  Also, if you have a BIOS that takes the geometry of the drive you might want to try that.  IF the BIOS will take it, but it still won't boot, try SpinRite.

My first notion from your description would be that both HDDs caught the same surge and the logic boards are toast.  This is a good thing, as the inner workings of the hard drive are probably still ok.  If you can find another hard drive the exact same as the ones who packed it in (including firmware) you can probably buy it, and swap logic boards.  This method doesn't comprimise the integrety of the drive, and it's a heck of a lot cheaper then sending it off to the data recovery guys.  If it's a new drive, you can probably find the drive in the stores, ask for old stock, returns, that sort of thing.  If you're still stuck, google for your drive or look on E-Bay.

Also, you should look at http://www.deadharddrive.com for some inspiration.  I don't personally recommend taking the platters out yourself, especially a 40 gig HD which is sure to be multi-platter drive, you'll never get them lined up properly.

Ultimate Tool Kit for Technology Solution Provider

Broken down into practical pointers and step-by-step instructions, the IT Service Excellence Tool Kit delivers expert advice for technology solution providers. Get your free copy now.

If the second drive is an identical drive you should be able to change the drive's mainboard. I've done that before with my Maxtor diamondmax 40 GB Drives and that worked. I couldn't get a hold of another such board via the web, so I checked the maxtor site and found the drive still was in warranty. After I saved the data on it with a board from another drive I sent it in got a replacement without hassles! Try to save the data on your drives on another PC, it sounds like your IDE channel is fried. Maybe try to get hold of a PCI IDE board (promise make such controllers, some have raid capabilies). If your drives also happen to be maxtor drives of the same type I have, they get pretty HOT and that could have been the reason for the malfunktion, so try to mount them as far appart as possible, maybe an extra Fan could help.
The same exact thing that you are describing happened to my wife's computer.  She had 3 drives in her system.  She was using it one day, and it just shut off.  She turned it back on and it started backup.  It shut down after a few more minutes.  She tried turning it back on and nothing.

It turned out that the powersupply self-destructed and it took out the video card, the flopy drive, the cdrom, and the 3 hard drives.  Only the 3 hard drives actually had physcal damage.  They were all maxtor drives and each one had a chip on it that blistered and popped.  

The only thing salvagable on the comptuer was the motherboard, cpu, and memory.  Everythign else was bad.

Now I did managed to save data on one of the drives.  My data was not worth the 1000 dollars or more it would cost to have repaired so i just recovered it the easy way.

I went on ebay and bought the same EXACT model number drive (working).

When I got that drive, i tested it first.  It wo0rked fine so then I unscrewed the bottom circuit board off.  Removed it and placed the good circuit board onto the bad hard drive (after removing the bad circuit board first).

I then was able to boot the systme with the "bad" drive as a slave and I managed to save data on that drive.

I then replaced the circuirt board back onto the ebay drive and ended up using that drive for whatever and i binned the old drive and circuit board.

It all depends on if your data is worth a grand or more to you.
bobo tech, just get the model numbers and serial numbers of your fried drives visit the maxtor site. With that info you can check if your drives still have warranty (I sent 3 such drives to maxtor only about half an year back, so yours might also still be in warranty and they'll send you replacements). mine probably had the same chip that blew, i think it had three connections and was rather small, maybe about 2x2mm?
ff_axelAuthor Commented:
Thanks everyone for your answers. I think from the info given I should be able to recover the data.  I'm going to split the points though between Callandor and Rindi, Callandor has supplied what I perceive to be a solution to this issue (as did others, thanks, but Callandor was first), but Rindi has supplied a bit more detail and has pointed me in the direction of Maxtors website.  Turns out this drive still has warranty and therefore hopefully will be replaced.

A question for Rindi :-
Does replacing the controller board not invalidate the warranty?

In theory probably yes, but as I mentioned I changed the board on mine and they didn't complain (I changed it back after having saved my data).
It's more than this solution.Get answers and train to solve all your tech problems - anytime, anywhere.Try it for free Edge Out The Competitionfor your dream job with proven skills and certifications.Get started today Stand Outas the employee with proven skills.Start learning today for free Move Your Career Forwardwith certification training in the latest technologies.Start your trial today

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.

Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.