SMTP Gateway cannot relay email to Exchange 2003 Server

I have a SMTP gateway ( that cannot relay email to my Exchange SMTP Virtual Server (  My Exchange Virtual Server does not allow for anonymous authentication.  I do have my the SMTP gateway listed in the list of computers that are allowed to relay through my Exchange Virtual Server, but I also have "Allow all computers that successful authenticate to relay, regardless of the list above" check marked.  The Exchange Virtual Server allows any computer to connect to it.  

When I allow anonymous authentication, the SMTP gateway can relay messages to the Exchange SMTP Virtual Server just fine.  How do I setup the Exchange SMTP Virtual Server to not allow anonymous authentication but allow the SMTP gateway to relay messages?

Who is Participating?
Unless you have re-iped the servers, can you list
If I am not mistaken, unless you are authenticating with a user account, a group account, or a certificate, anonymous access has to be enabled.
Double-check your Default SMTP Virtual Server Settings.  Access Tab, Relay button
Ensure that the radio button you have setup says "Only the list below" and not "All except the list below"
The "Allow all computers..." checkbox should not make a difference in this instance as the relay is not authenticating.
Personally, I leave the anonymous access checkbox checked on my front-ends so that servers, on the Internet, can send messages to me.
mnmorencyAuthor Commented:
The Relay button is set to "Only the list below".  The specific LAN IP is added to the list "" and the Exchange Virtual Servier still does not want to relay for the SMTP Gateway.
I don't think that I answered the question, but I am interested in the disposition of the question.  Anonymous access has to be on unless the system is authenticating.  However, anonymous access does not mean that the system can be used as a relay unless other conditions are met...conditions that have already been addressed by mnmorency.

Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.