PC died....again

My wife is currently on her 3rd motherboard in a bit over a year and a half. I recently replaced her fried 2nd motherboard just over a month ago and everything was working fine until tonight. At first her front 2 USB ports wouldn't recognize any devices ( the back ports worked fine ), then the computer just blinked out completely. If I turn off the power switch in the back and then turn it on, I can power up the PC for a split second before it crashes again. I thought maybe the PSU was the culprit ( much as I thought the same thing when her last motherboard died ), but after trying it with my PSU tester, everything spun right up so I'm ruiling out the PSU...again. My best guess is there's something about her case which is causing these mobos to short out, we've had 3 different brand mobos ( Epoch, Giga-Byte and Asus ) and all have died. I can't believe it's just bad luck...any ideas or suggestions would be greatly appreciated.

Who is Participating?
I wear a lot of hats...

"The solutions and answers provided on Experts Exchange have been extremely helpful to me over the last few years. I wear a lot of hats - Developer, Database Administrator, Help Desk, etc., so I know a lot of things but not a lot about one thing. Experts Exchange gives me answers from people who do know a lot about one thing, in a easy to use platform." -Todd S.

PSU or static problems.
Front USB went first?
Is this system located in a room with carpet?
logan510Author Commented:
Front USB went first, then the PC just died. The room does have carpeting, but the computer is not on it. It's placed on top of her large computer desk. Could a "bad" PSU that passes muster on my PSU tester really cause 3 seperate motherboards to die?

Also, I have 3 PC's of my own located in the same room and I haven't had any of the problems she's been encountering.

are the other pc's on the same AC rail? if not, that can be a cause.
Other than bad luck, it can be due to :
-static discharges
-unstable AC power
-poor grounding
-poor shielding.
-bad power supply
if the cause is coming from AC, i would suggest a good power supply.
check first the power you need here for that PC  :    http://www.jscustompcs.com/power_supply/
to be sure it is not under powered.
Top Threats of Q1 & How to Defend Against Them

WEBINAR: Join WatchGuard CTO and our Threat Research Team on Aug. 2nd to hear the findings from our Q1 Internet Security Report! Learn more about the top threats detected in the first quarter and how you can defend your business against them!

The computer doesn't have to be ON the carpet.
I once killed a PS/2 port by sitting in a chair on a carpet wearing only socks. (On my feet okay....)
I felt a shock when I touched the mouse then no more PS/2.

USB went first. Get shocked plugging something in?

The I see things in common across your 3 motherboards.
PSU (Testers won't show you problems like random voltage spikes or an overload condition when connected to the system.)
AC power socket. (Anything on that circuit that might cause surges?)
Location (On carpet. (Static?), Does it get hot or moist there? AC blow on it? (Condensation?), Sun hit it there?)
Case (Only a problem if the boards were mounted incorrectly and grounded somehow.)

What else was in common with your builds?


Experts Exchange Solution brought to you by

Your issues matter to us.

Facing a tech roadblock? Get the help and guidance you need from experienced professionals who care. Ask your question anytime, anywhere, with no hassle.

Start your 7-day free trial
I have to ask - did the other mobo's die in a similar manner (eg front usb ports first)?

Try disconnecting these first - could be your case is shorting them out! Also check all the usb devices you have been using - one of them may be susceptible to spikes, or even draw a high current which is killing the regulators on the mobo.

Hope this helps

You have only replaced the motherboard and none of the periphereals?
Maybe one is defective and causes these blowups. Check for any odd markings or colorations on the cards and mainboard.

also check how the mainboard is mounted,
are all cables thorougly connected, is there a ground-connection, no loose cables. Is there enough space underneath the mainboard in the casing.

If the pc is on a different power-outlet, you might consider an adapter with a small surge-protector. They're generally cheaper than (a) new computer(s). To know the current and if everything is in right sync you'd need a logging on power for longer time. This however cannot be done very cheap, I don't know exactlt to how many motherboards the costs can be compared.
>>everything spun right up so I'm ruiling out the PSU
Just because it spins up doesn't mean it isn't faulty. A bad supply can fry a motherboard and it's components, as well. That's the first thing I would replace if three motherboards in a row died.
Is your motherboard grounding out against the case? Are screwing it directly to the case? Are you using the proper mounts (brass or plastic)?

During the 2 seconds that it does turn on, check to make sure that your CPU heatsink fan is spinning. Nearly all motherboards will cut the power if the fan isn't spinning to prevent damage to the CPU.

See if you can check your CPU and motherboard temperatures.


logan510Author Commented:
She's on a pretty decent UPS so I don't think it's power spikes coming from the AC. I'm coming around to the realization that it is more than likely the PSU shorting out these boards. Tho I still think we might get a new case for her as well, the current one is very cramped and difficult to work with and with only 2 system fans it runs on the hot side of warm. I'll update later tonight as we plan on going to get the new parts after work. I'll split the points up appropiately.

Thanks for all the suggestions and info
I once had to test a power supply over a 24 hour period. it looked fine on the tester until one cap overloaded and spiked at 27V on the 5V connector. Best bet is for you to test the suply longer or replace it. It is possible that a perhiperal or a ground could have caused this but if you have replaced 3 mobos you must be good to ground all of them the same way...... ( take that as a complement please. )
Have you checked the case for a short to the reset or power switch, either could effect the life of your mobo.
As silly as this sounds are you plugging everything to the mobo in the correct position. that could cause a short if for instance USB was 1/2 on speaker or reset.. ( Yes once I did that- wrong mobo book and asian characters on mobo....I know it was stupid)

Good Luck
If you are familiar with the bad cap issue commonly found in motherboad discussions....

Those bad caps ended up in everything else too, tv's, radios, video cards, sound cards, POWER SUPPLIES...

Suggest this in agreement with case/power supply issues:
Select a new case with large volume and 120mm fan ports. (quieter and easier to cool). The structure must be rigid to stabilize the mainboard...flexing is bad, rigid is goooood.
Special attention to a good quality power supply that has the specifications to meet your needs now and some additional reserve for future expansion.
Evaluate your power supply needs at above.
There have been some good suggestions here! I agree with PlatinumStylz, the fans might be sticking or spinning slow due to dust, Making certain components overheat and therefor forcing your system to shutdown to prevent further damage!

When buying a new case, be sure to get one designed for ultimate cooling like an Aluminium Case>>>

Aimed at the high-end section of the case market, Aluminium cases are designed for the ultimate cooling as they help dissipate heat much better than SECC. These cases come in a variety of sizes, shapes and designs and are ideal for people who want the best cooling system and also a lightweight system without Compromising on looks and features.
The Overview I found here>>>

Are you using a new hdd or are you still using the old one?
If your still using the old hdd then maybe some of it's components are starting to burnout, if you have the same problem with the new MB, check how hot the hdd is. If you could fry an egg on it then the hdd overheating could possibly force the shutdown!

Are you sure that your motherboard's are dead? Maybe you can revive them! Please read my last comment posted here>>>

When you've opened the above link, to save time while searching for my last post, Press Control-F keys together and search for "Thanks Mark" without the quotes!

Hope this helps!
PS: I've just tried the Control-F search but could'nt find the words Thanks Mark!
If you have the same problem then Highlight some other text before searching again!
It's more than this solution.Get answers and train to solve all your tech problems - anytime, anywhere.Try it for free Edge Out The Competitionfor your dream job with proven skills and certifications.Get started today Stand Outas the employee with proven skills.Start learning today for free Move Your Career Forwardwith certification training in the latest technologies.Start your trial today

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.

Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.