N queens algorithm solved with simulated annealing algorithm.

I have to do a program that will solve the N queens problem with the simulated annealing algorthm.I don't know what data structure i must use? I will not do it with backtracking or with recurcive algorithms but with simulated annealing. Do you know how i must represent the problem?
xenoulaAsked:
Who is Participating?
I wear a lot of hats...

"The solutions and answers provided on Experts Exchange have been extremely helpful to me over the last few years. I wear a lot of hats - Developer, Database Administrator, Help Desk, etc., so I know a lot of things but not a lot about one thing. Experts Exchange gives me answers from people who do know a lot about one thing, in a easy to use platform." -Todd S.

InteractiveMindCommented:
boolean grid [][] ;  // ?
0
xenoulaAuthor Commented:
Why i must use that tyoe of array?
0
InteractiveMindCommented:
Well, that's how I've stored the sort of data needed for what you're doing, in order to solve similar(ish) problems before.
It allows easy access to the state of specific cells within the grid.

But I suppose that for the N queens problem, it may be more appropriate to create a data type, which represents the grid as horizontal, vertical and diagonal components.

This approach would require 4 arrays — 1 for vertical, 1 for horizontal, 2 for diagonal (positive and negative directions).

If you bear with me a moment, I'll give you a slightly more in-depth explanation of this idea of mine ...
0
Ultimate Tool Kit for Technology Solution Provider

Broken down into practical pointers and step-by-step instructions, the IT Service Excellence Tool Kit delivers expert advice for technology solution providers. Get your free copy now.

InteractiveMindCommented:
So, you may decide to have something like this:


    int D ; // the width of the grid (this should be equal to the height)
    .
    bool row [D] ;                // rows
    bool col [D] ;                 // columns
    bool diagPos [2*D-1] ;   // positive diagonal strips
    bool diagNeg [2*D-1] ;  // negative diagonal strips


Then, when you wish to check if a particular cell [at (x,y)] is available, you could do this:

    if ( row[y] || col[x] || diagPos[x+y] || diagNeg[x+D-1-y] )
    {
        // it is occupied, look elsewhere
    } else
    {
        // it is available !
    }

And then, of course, if you wanted to place a queen in an available cell (x,y), you'd do something like this:

   row[y] = true ;
   col[x] = true ;
   diagPos[x+y] = true ;
   diagNeg[x+D-1-y] = true ;


This is probably the easiest way to allow you to check the availability of a particular cell, without having to do _any_ iteration !!  :-)


You can then perform your annealing algorithm — for example, you may check all surrounding cells if they're available, and if so, shove a queen there, or perform some other tests to decide whether it's most suitable..


Does that help ?
0
ozoCommented:
there's no particular way that you must represent the problem
you could also use
int queen[N][2];
0
xenoulaAuthor Commented:
InteractiveMind  thank you very much i will give you the points.

 I think you are right in the representation of the problem.The only problem is that i want to solve the problem with simlated annealing  which is not an exact algorithm . This algorithm makes random moves and improves the solution according  to a objective function. That's why i need to know every queen how many conflicts has with others queens. In my algorithm i will place a Queen only in a free cell but randonly everywhere and then i will check how many conflicts i have. The next step is to calculate the objective function and change random position in the queens that are in   conflict.

Thank you.

0
InteractiveMindCommented:
Don't feel that you need to close this thread yet ...

ozo could probably help you more than anyone else on this entire site with this problem... perhaps he can suggest a more suitable structure, now that you've elaborated more on the rest of your algorithm..

:)
0
xenoulaAuthor Commented:
I will Spilt the points if someone else can answer my previous comment.
0
ozoCommented:
If you find that a solution to the 4 queens problem is
row[0]=row[1]=row[2]=row[3]=true;
col[0]=col[1]=col[2]=col[3]=true;
diagPos[1]=diagPos[2]=diagPos[4]=diagPos[5]=true;
diagNeg[1]=diagNegs[2]=diagNeg[4]=diagNeg[5]=true;
how would you print it?
0
InteractiveMindCommented:
...with great difficulty?

<uh oh>


Surely it wouldn't get to that combination though ?
0
xenoulaAuthor Commented:
don't care about the presentation of the problem.
I will do it in VBA . But i don't care about the presentation of the solution right now becuase is easy.
0
nayernaguibCommented:
You can represent the board (a single state of the problem) using an n x n array of booleans.

A queen on column n and row m could be represented by queens[n,m]=true.

Now to calculate the number of conflicts for a queen at column n and row m you can call the following function (I have not compiled this code, so try it at your own risk): :-)

//NumberOfQueens should hold the total number of queens (which is also equal to the number of rows and the number of columns)

int NumberOfConflicts (int n, int m)
{
  int i,j,conflicts=0;

  //To calculate conflicts on the same row

  for (i=n, j=0; j<NumberOfQueens; j++)
  {
    if ((j!=m)&&(queens[i,j]==true))
      conflicts++;
  }

  //To calculate conflicts on the same column

  for (i=0, j=m; i<NumberOfQueens; i++)
  {
    if ((i!=n)&&(queens[i,j]==true))
      conflicts++;
  }

  //To calculate conflicts on \ diagonal
  if (n<m)
  {
    for (i=0, j=m-n; j<NumberOfQueens; i++,j++)
    {
      if ((i!=n)&&(queens[i,j]==true))
        conflicts++;
    }
  }
  else
  {
    for (i=n-m, j=0; i<NumberOfQueens; i++,j++)
    {
      if ((i!=n)&&(queens[i,j]==true))
        conflicts++;
    }
  }

  //To calculate conflicts on / diagonal
  if (n<NumberOfQueens-m)
  {
    for (i=n+m, j=0; i>=0; i--;j++)
    {
      if ((i!=n)&&(queens[i,j]==true))
        conflicts++;
    }
  }
  else
  {
    for (i=NumberOfQueens-1, j=m-n; j<NumberOfQueens; i--,j++)
    {
      if ((i!=n)&&(queens[i,j]==true))
        conflicts++;
    }
  }

  return conflicts;
}

_______________

  Nayer Naguib
0
ozoCommented:
//with
int queen[N][2];
//you can use
int NumberOfConflicts(){
   int conflicts = 0;
   for( int i=0;i<N-1;i++){
      for( int j=i+1;j<N;j++){
         if( queen[i][0] == queen[j][0]
         || queen[i][1] == queen[j][1]
         || abs(queen[i][0] - queen[j][0]) == abs(queen[i][1] - queen[j][1])
         ){
             conflicts++;
         }
      }
   }
   return conflicts;
}
0
nayernaguibCommented:
ozo: Nice algorithm. However, the author is interested in knowing how many conflicts a specific queen has got rather than the total number of conflicts, so perhaps you need to modify the function so that it either calculates the number of conflicts for a given queen, or returns/fills an array of integers representing the number of conflicts that each queen has.

_______________

  Nayer Naguib
0
ozoCommented:
int NumberOfConflicts(int n){
   int conflicts = -1;
   int q0=queen[n][0];
   int q1=queen[n][1];
   for( int i=0;i<N;i++ ){
         if( queen[i][0] == q0
          || queen[i][1] == q1
          || abs(queen[i][0]-q0) == abs(queen[i][1]-q1)
         ){
             conflicts++;
         }
      }
   }
   return conflicts;
}
0

Experts Exchange Solution brought to you by

Your issues matter to us.

Facing a tech roadblock? Get the help and guidance you need from experienced professionals who care. Ask your question anytime, anywhere, with no hassle.

Start your 7-day free trial
xenoulaAuthor Commented:
Thank you very much OZO. You have an excellent approach and i think i will follow your advice. The only thing that worry me is if this king of data structure is suitable for all the program. :)

 Here what i decided to do.
I choose to have the  an array of queens
Queens[n][m];
The n represent the n queens
The  m  if 0 represent the row for the specific Queen
The  m  if 1 represent the column for the specific Queen

Am i right OZO,  is this what you have in mind?
And i will use this code for the evaluate the objective function because i want to find the total number of conflicts
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
//with
int queen[N][2];
//you can use
int NumberOfConflicts(){
   int conflicts = 0;
   for( int i=0;i<N-1;i++){
      for( int j=i+1;j<N;j++){
         if( queen[i][0] == queen[j][0]
         || queen[i][1] == queen[j][1]
         || abs(queen[i][0] - queen[j][0]) == abs(queen[i][1] - queen[j][1])
         ){
             conflicts++;
         }
      }
   }
   return conflicts;
}

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

and this code to know how many conflicts a specific queen has. I need that information becuase i want to move randomly  the queens that are in conflict. more precise if  a queen have more conflicts i will move it more than the others.


int NumberOfConflicts(int n){
   int conflicts = -1;
   int q0=queen[n][0];
   int q1=queen[n][1];
   for( int i=0;i<N;i++ ){
         if( queen[i][0] == q0
          || queen[i][1] == q1
          || abs(queen[i][0]-q0) == abs(queen[i][1]-q1)
         ){
             conflicts++;
         }
      }
   }
   return conflicts;
}
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

i will also add in the queens the something extra

The m if 3 represent the total number of conflicts for the specific Queen.
So  Queens[1][3]=4
Means that the specific queen has four conflicts.
 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Thank  you everybody for your reply it was very helpfull.I will close this to give the points but i will open a new one with the same kind of algorithm in order to give more.  
0
It's more than this solution.Get answers and train to solve all your tech problems - anytime, anywhere.Try it for free Edge Out The Competitionfor your dream job with proven skills and certifications.Get started today Stand Outas the employee with proven skills.Start learning today for free Move Your Career Forwardwith certification training in the latest technologies.Start your trial today
Programming

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.

Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.