Want to protect your cyber security and still get fast solutions? Ask a secure question today.Go Premium

x
  • Status: Solved
  • Priority: Medium
  • Security: Public
  • Views: 2401
  • Last Modified:

WPA or WPA2 or Both?

I see the following on my router's setup page, and I don't know if I should enable WPA, WPA2 or both?  Will this slow my wireless network down due to having to encrypt decrypt the data it sends?

http://www.davidgareau.com/expertExchange/WPA%20&%20WPA2.JPG

0
davidgareau
Asked:
davidgareau
  • 4
  • 4
  • 2
  • +2
3 Solutions
 
davidgareauAuthor Commented:
Also, TKIP is stronger than AES, right? But is TKIP+AES (a third option) even better?
And what about the group key renewal? Is 3600 second one good?
0
 
Mad_JasperCommented:
I have noticed no slow down in my wireless network since implementation of WPA/TKIP. I would have used WPA 2, but had some compliancy issues that will be addressed in the upcoming budget year.

In my network, we have 80 wireless laptops and 6 wireless printers, and 11 Cisco 1200 APs. Each laptop is configured by Group Policy to be auto rolled by our Certificate Authority. The CA is also our Radius server which authenticates the APs. All WLAN settings are distributed to the laptops via Group Policy so I never have to touch a laptop once it is imaged.

In order to access our network, the laptop must have certificate, the laptop must be a member of the domain, and the user that logs on to the laptop must be a member of the domain. It would VERY difficult to hack into our network via the WLAN.
0
 
Mad_JasperCommented:
AES is stronger, but not all client hardware is compatible. Using AES may require hardware/firmware upgrades.
0
VIDEO: THE CONCERTO CLOUD FOR HEALTHCARE

Modern healthcare requires a modern cloud. View this brief video to understand how the Concerto Cloud for Healthcare can help your organization.

 
hiteshgupta1Commented:
how many nodes do u have in ur network??
0
 
amanzoorNetwork infrastructure AdminCommented:
0
 
davidgareauAuthor Commented:
I have 3 nodes in the network.
0
 
davidgareauAuthor Commented:
What I'm most confused by is that I have the option of using WPA, WPA2 or both.
And I also have the options of using TKIP, AES or a combo TKIP+AES

0
 
Mad_JasperCommented:
Either way, WPA or WPA 2 is more secure than WEP. WPA/TKIP has worked very well for us.
0
 
Blue_RishiCommented:
Hi,

The way it works on my linksys wrt54g v.3.1; combo settings will allow clients to use either WPA or WPA2.
I use WPA2 myself with TKIP+AES, so I can use AES encryption on cards that support it and use TKIP otherwise.

Grz Blue Rishi

0
 
davidgareauAuthor Commented:
Thanks, so, I have 3 wireless USB adapters, all the same that support WPA2 and AES, so I should just set my router to allow only those two?  Is there any benefit to allowing the others if I don't plan on adding any other clients?
And you have experienced speed with WPA2 + AES that is about the same as without any security in place?

thanks
david
0
 
Mad_JasperCommented:
I would use the strongest encryption that you network supports. I can't speak for WPA2 + AES for speed, but I have WPA + TKIP and 80 wireless clients, migrated from WEP and I have seen no difference when roaming to other access points.
0
 
Blue_RishiCommented:
> Is there any benefit to allowing the others if I don't plan on adding any other clients?

Nope, unless you need to swap hardware that might not support WPA2/AES or get visitors without support on a regular basis.

> And you have experienced speed with WPA2 + AES that is about the same as without any security in place?

I notice no difference when coping large amounts of data. It should not affect transmit rates, only tax the wifi-adapter or take a few cpu cycles depending on hardware/driver. So, under heavy load it could up the latency which could affect performance during gaming. However, I have had no problems with this so far.

Blue Rishi
0

Featured Post

VIDEO: THE CONCERTO CLOUD FOR HEALTHCARE

Modern healthcare requires a modern cloud. View this brief video to understand how the Concerto Cloud for Healthcare can help your organization.

  • 4
  • 4
  • 2
  • +2
Tackle projects and never again get stuck behind a technical roadblock.
Join Now