• Status: Solved
  • Priority: Medium
  • Security: Public
  • Views: 229
  • Last Modified:

Routing table

Hi All,

I am a new learner to configure a router. The rotuer I am using is 3Com NetbuilderII.

I have configured the 3 network interface cards as follows:

Port 1: 10.12.4.126 255.255.255.128
Port 2: 10.12.4.190 255.255.255.192
Port 3: 10.12.4.254 255.255.255.192

I have also disabled RIP & OSPF service.
Port 3 will be connected to a firewall with IP address 10.11.2.10.
Any problem with my configuration like this?

Further, I would like to know whether the rotuer can learn routes by itself or do I need to enable any service/traffic?

Thanks.


0
ee_lcpaa
Asked:
ee_lcpaa
  • 2
  • 2
1 Solution
 
ee_lcpaaAuthor Commented:
Sorry, supplementary information.

My firewall has 2 ports with IP address 10.11.2.10 & 10.12.4.253 (same subnet as port 3)

I also have a question like this. If I have another PC with IP 10.11.2.11 connected directly to the FW port with IP 10.11.2.10. Then I start a ping service to 10.12.4.126.

Under my configuration, will the ping succeed?
I wonder the router will learn a route that src IP 10.11.2.10 will route through port 3(10.12.4.254). Am I right? Please advise. Thanks a lot.

Please note the FW will not discard the ping service.
0
 
calvinetterCommented:
 Disclaimer: I'm not familiar with 3Com Netbuilder, but standard routing principles & IP behavior still apply here.

>If I have another PC with IP 10.11.2.11 connected directly to the FW port with IP 10.11.2.10. Then I start a ping service to 10.12.4.126 ...will the ping succeed?
  It should succeed IF: A) 10.12.4.126 is assigned to one of the router's interfaces, B) the default gateway for the PC is 10.11.2.10,  C) there aren't any rules blocking ping traffic between the hosts,  D) no software firewall on the 10.12.4.126 is blocking ping traffic, & E) you've got a crossover cable between the PC & the router interface (if it's a typical router interface).

>...would like to know whether the rotuer can learn routes by itself or do I need to enable any service/traffic?
  A router can't learn routes automatically if all dynamic routing protocols (ie, RIP or OSPF "services") are disabled.  If RIP & OSPF are disabled, the only way it's going to learn a new route is if you manually configure a static route.

>Port 3: 10.12.4.254 255.255.255.192
>My firewall has 2 ports with IP address 10.11.2.10 & 10.12.4.253 (same subnet as port 3)
  I hope the router didn't allow you to set another port to 10.12.4.253 w/ the same subnet mask as port 3?!  If so, then I'd expect your router to be confused when trying to route traffic to/from IPs in this subnet, since 10.12.4.253 overlaps the range of valid IPs for the subnet on port 3.

cheers
0
 
ee_lcpaaAuthor Commented:
Dear calvinetter,

You said the ping service will be succeeded. I would like to give you a clear picture. The configuration is as follows:

PC (10.11.2.11)--> (10.11.2.10) F/W with 2 ports (10.12.4.253) --> Router (Port 3 10.12.4.254, one of the ports with this IP)

Please note the testing PC will not be connected directly to the router. There is a FW between them. Under this configure, Will the ping service be suceeded from PC (10.11.2.11) to 10.12.4.126 (port 1 of router)?

From you second point, after disabling the RIP & OSPF service, the router will not learn anything. I have a question that how can the router know that the returning path to 10.11.2.11 is through Port 3 -- 10.12.4.254?

Please advise.
Thanks a lot.
0
 
calvinetterCommented:
Ok, thanks for the clarification & the diagram.  To answer both your questions in your latest post - Based on your latest post above, you should be able to ping port 1 of the router IF the default gateway for the firewall is the port it's connected to (10.12.4.254), & IF either of the following conditions are met:  
either A) the FW is NAT'ing the 10.11.2.x subnet to the 10.12.4.x subnet,
or B) you configure a static route on the 3Com, to point a route for the 10.11.2.x network to the FW's IP of 10.12.4.253.
  (And of course, as long as the firewall or the router isn't blocking ping traffic through it.)

cheers
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

Join & Write a Comment

Featured Post

Free Tool: ZipGrep

ZipGrep is a utility that can list and search zip (.war, .ear, .jar, etc) archives for text patterns, without the need to extract the archive's contents.

One of a set of tools we're offering as a way to say thank you for being a part of the community.

  • 2
  • 2
Tackle projects and never again get stuck behind a technical roadblock.
Join Now