Go Premium for a chance to win a PS4. Enter to Win

x
  • Status: Solved
  • Priority: Medium
  • Security: Public
  • Views: 1081
  • Last Modified:

Windows Print Servers vs. HP JetDirect -- Best Methods? Alternatives?

So far as I am aware, I have only three options for sharing printers in my small office / workgroup. (1) I can make a computer act as a print server (which would then send spooled jobs through the HP JetDirect tcp/ip card in the printer, or (2) I can let everyone print to the printer directly through the HP JetDirect card (3) or I can buy a print server box of some sort. As near as I can tell, the advantage to the first method is that it makes it child's play to install the printer on any workstation (just browse to \\server\printername and, Voila!, the printer is installed). You would have to install the print drivers the old fashioned way on workstations if you use either of the other methods.

I have used the first method for years, but since we bought an HP Laserjet 4200tn lately, it seems like print jobs sit in the spooler for a long time. That is, my workstation will show the job has been printed/sent, but the printer does not even show traffic coming its way. When I look on the print queue on the server, it will say something like "opening," which I guess means that the print server/spooler is waking up or something.

Q. -- Is there a better way to manage my printers than what I am doing?

Q. -- Why would a two page print job from Word take 60-90 seconds to get from my workstation to the server to the printer?   What's wrong with this picture?
0
GrayStrickland
Asked:
GrayStrickland
3 Solutions
 
hdhondtCommented:
Try changing the TCP/IP port for the printer (on the server) from Raw to LPR. Go to printer Properties > Ports, click on Configure Port, click the LPR button, and under Queue name type "raw"

That change has fixed similar problems for me on several occasions
0
 
Yorkie0362Commented:
I definatley prefer using a windows box as a print server, because as you said you can share the drivers from them.  I would also definatley try HDHONDT's tip as this should improve throughput.

Just a quick question though, if you print a document from the "master" computer eg. the print server directly to the printer, is it still slow ?
0
 
foocharCommented:
Another thought is that if the computer that is acting as a print server is also doing other things (file serving, office applications, etc.) the load from those other things will have an effect on print times etc.
0
Concerto Cloud for Software Providers & ISVs

Can Concerto Cloud Services help you focus on evolving your application offerings, while delivering the best cloud experience to your customers? From DevOps to revenue models and customer support, the answer is yes!

Learn how Concerto can help you.

 
GrayStricklandAuthor Commented:
Hdhondt:

You write, "Try changing the TCP/IP port for the printer (on the server) from Raw to LPR."

Then you write, "...under Queue name type "raw"

I'm confused. This seems contradictory.
0
 
hdhondtCommented:
Look in the port configuration window, and somewhat below the "raw" and "lpr" buttons, under "LPR Settings", you'll see an entry for Queue Name. That's where you enter "raw".

Note that the 2 occurrences of "raw" have nothing to do with each other. LPR and RAW specify the protocol and the TCP/IP port used to send data to the printer. The queue name "raw" is device dependent. Why HP decided to use raw as (one of the valid) queue name I can't tell you. However, with other suppliers the queue name is usually different, for example PCL or PS to indicate the printer language used.

The benefits of using a PC as a server include the ability to install drivers from the server, as Yorkie0362 explained, and the additional control the administrator has over who can print, who can change printer settings, etc. However, I feel you should use a proper server, not just a PC. You don't want to rely on a PC being turned on, just so that other users can print.

Going direct to the printer gives each user more control. If that is important to you, then that is the better way. Using a printserver box serves no real purpose if your printer already has a network card installed.
0
 
wyliecoyoteukCommented:
As hdhondt says, print server boxes are unecessary, plus in my experience, they are usually unreliable and easily swamped on even a small network.Also, many printers will not work with them.
Your problem may be more to do with spooler settings.
On the server, make sure that the spooler is on a disk with plenty of space.(by default it is on the C: drive)
Also make sure that spooling in the print driver >advanced tab  is set to "start printing after the last page has spooled" This may sound odd, but it ensures  that the transmission time is reduced, as the server receives the whole file before sending it, which means that the printer is not having to wait for the workstation to spool it.
0

Featured Post

Free Tool: Path Explorer

An intuitive utility to help find the CSS path to UI elements on a webpage. These paths are used frequently in a variety of front-end development and QA automation tasks.

One of a set of tools we're offering as a way of saying thank you for being a part of the community.

Tackle projects and never again get stuck behind a technical roadblock.
Join Now