SBS 2003 security group permissions not working for folder

Posted on 2006-06-15
Last Modified: 2008-01-09
Inherited SBS 2003.
Created own OU's not using 'My Business'.... ones created by default.
Have one folder with a couple of excel files in it. I want to restrict the folder so only 5 users can read/write and all other users read-only.
Folder name:   ABC
Group 1:   Global Read Only Group
Group 2;  Global Write Group
5 users in Group2 and all other users  in Group1
Security Permissions:  Administrators -  full,   Group1 - Read, Deny Write ,   Group 2 - Read/write

Any user I add to either Group does absolutely nothing. Example, I add User1 to Group1 and I can still open, write, delete, create, everything. If I remove all groups from security permissions and only leave Administrators, anyone can access the folder and open/read/write/delete.
If add User1 explicitly to the security permissions, it works.
I have removed setting Inherite Permissions from parent folder. I have tried 4 different user accounts. Owner of file is administrator.
Question by:dguillen
Welcome to Experts Exchange

Add your voice to the tech community where 5M+ people just like you are talking about what matters.

  • Help others & share knowledge
  • Earn cash & points
  • Learn & ask questions
  • 3
  • 2
  • 2
LVL 96

Expert Comment

by:Lee W, MVP
ID: 16917974
OUs do NOTHING for file security - you need to create Security Groups and add users to the SECURITY groups.  Also, put the users back in the My Business OU - Do NOT do things without the wizards if you can do them with the wizards.  SBS EXPECTS to be managed a certain way and if you don't manage it appropriately, you'll create problems now and later.  
LVL 74

Accepted Solution

Jeffrey Kane - TechSoEasy earned 250 total points
ID: 16919132
I'll second that!  See for an overview of this.

Also, all users should be created using the Add-User wizard and the SBS user templates.  There are too many functions that need to be configured simulataneoulsly to do this manually.  Because SBS is a preconfigured server that has numerous services running together on the same machine that would never be running together on a standard server, you need to use the wizards in order to not break anything.

So, first move all users back into MyBusiness\Users\SBSUsers

There are wizards for Security Groups as well. I would suggest that you create a new User Template for those that you want in Group 1 and another for those that you want in Group 2 (actually you should COPY the default USER template to start with).  

Then, create two Security Groups (1 & 2) and add it to each new template accordingly.  

Next, add those Security Groups to your NTFS permissions for the folders you are looking to protect.

Finally, if you've already created these users, run the Change User Permissions wizard to apply the appropriate template to whichever users you like.    If you haven't created a user yet, then use the add-user wizard and select the appropriate template to create your user.

Obviously this is quite a different procedure than what you would do on a standard Server 2003... but by following this method, you will not only get the permissions set the way you want, but you will also be able to keep the assigned quotas in place, the appropriate SharePoint user accounts, etc.

I might mention however, that what you are doing is handled by SharePoint quite well... and you may want to look into using SharePoint instead of standard NTFS files/folders.  There are preconfigured SharePoint roles which address what you are seeking to do... by default standard users are granted the "Contributor" role appropriate for your Group 2, but you could certainly make a separate User Template for Group 1 that would grant them the "reader" role.

Files stored in SharePoint are actually in SQL server (MSDE if you have SBS Standard, SQL Server if SBS Premium -- which allows for full text search).  Document libraries in SharePoint are accessed easily via http://companyweb.


Author Comment

ID: 16921562
thanks guys
I will try. SBS blows.
How our DevOps Teams Maximize Uptime

Our Dev teams are like yours. They’re continually cranking out code for new features/bugs fixes, testing, deploying, responding to production monitoring events and more. It’s complex. So, we thought you’d like to see what’s working for us. Read the use case whitepaper.

LVL 96

Expert Comment

by:Lee W, MVP
ID: 16921669
Why does SBS blow?  You think you could do this with Standard server?  You can't you know.

Author Comment

ID: 16921839
I know. I like using Standard 10 times better. I like having control over what I do. I don't like wizards. Although the template feature seems ok.
SBS is not horrible, I just don't like it. Haven't used it enough to appreciate it I guess.
LVL 96

Expert Comment

by:Lee W, MVP
ID: 16921902
Exactly.  That I can understand.  I prefer the control as well - I prefer KNOWING HOW the system does things then the "sit back and relax, I'll take care of it" attitude - if I wanted that kind of computer, I'd have switched to a Mac LONG ago.  I've come to accept that for it's purpose, SBS is well done - it's introduction to the IT specialist was quite poor because, as near as I can tell, unless you specifically looked for training in it, you would unintentially screw it up.  And when you work in an enterprise environment, I don't think its unreasonable for an admin to think they know how it should work.  Problem is, that's what screws SBS up.

Microsoft really needs to make the wizards smarter so that admins with enterprise experience can't screw things up if they want to manage it like an enterprise system.  With luck, it will be one soon, afterall.
LVL 74

Expert Comment

by:Jeffrey Kane - TechSoEasy
ID: 16924669
If you want to know what the wizards do (and they are just GUI scripts by the way) all you have to do is look at the very last screen of each one and it will detail you what's what.  You can also look at the logs.  Feel free to explore C:\Program Files\Microsoft Windows Small Business Server\Support and other directories in C:\Program Files\Microsoft Windows Small Business Server.

The main issue is this though... with a standard server you would NEVER put all of those services and components into one box.  But, by doing so you can save a TON of money for the company.  The wizards allow you to manage the server by helping to ensure that you don't break one service while fixing another.  Of course they aren't perfect... but they are certainly better than NOT using them.

leew summed it up fairly well... and the problems I encounter are generally created by very experienced, well intentioned MCSE's who just weren't given the heads up on what NOT to do with SBS.  Since my consulting practice is exclusively SBS based, the tools that SBS has allows me to handle MANY MORE clients than if I were having to do this stuff manually... so there are adavantages for IT Professionals as well.


Featured Post

Free Tool: Path Explorer

An intuitive utility to help find the CSS path to UI elements on a webpage. These paths are used frequently in a variety of front-end development and QA automation tasks.

One of a set of tools we're offering as a way of saying thank you for being a part of the community.

Question has a verified solution.

If you are experiencing a similar issue, please ask a related question

Introduction At 19:33 (UST) on Tuesday 21st September the long awaited email arrived with the subject title of “ANNOUNCING THE AVAILABILITY OF WINDOWS SBS 7 PREVIEW”.  It was time to drop whatever I was doing and dedicate as much bandwidth as possi…
You may have discovered the 'Compatibility View Settings' workaround for making your SBS 2008 Remote Web Workplace 'connect to a computer' section stops 'working around' after a Windows 10 client upgrade.  That can be fixed so it 'works around' agai…
The Email Laundry PDF encryption service allows companies to send confidential encrypted  emails to anybody. The PDF document can also contain attachments that are embedded in the encrypted PDF. The password is randomly generated by The Email Laundr…
Finding and deleting duplicate (picture) files can be a time consuming task. My wife and I, our three kids and their families all share one dilemma: Managing our pictures. Between desktops, laptops, phones, tablets, and cameras; over the last decade…
Suggested Courses

752 members asked questions and received personalized solutions in the past 7 days.

Join the community of 500,000 technology professionals and ask your questions.

Join & Ask a Question