Go Premium for a chance to win a PS4. Enter to Win

x
  • Status: Solved
  • Priority: Medium
  • Security: Public
  • Views: 513
  • Last Modified:

Switch or Hub

I have two ip add's from my isp and three comp's, one notebook logs onto work, the other two are home use, will one of those small switch's from best buy seperate the two ip add's, i want one ip add. and cable straight to the notebook, the other line  will go to router for the two desktop's, or will a small hub do the same thing. out from the hub to the laptop, the other line to the router, switch or hub?
0
ezy2
Asked:
ezy2
3 Solutions
 
ttist25Commented:
Hey ezy.

Either a hub or a switch should do what you are talking asking.
0
 
b0lsc0ttCommented:
ezy2,

The switch will work better.  It will act as the hub would but manages traffic while a hub won't.  The flow would go modem -> switch -> switch port one to notebook, switch port two to router.  The routers ports would have cables to the other computers.  The notebook will be assigned one of the static IP's and the router's WAN settings will have one of the other static IP's.

Let me know if you have any questions or need more information.

b0lsc0tt
0
 
ECNSSMTCommented:
in my neck of the woods, they don't sell hubs any more so its a real easy choice for me.  But irregardless, SWITCH

But overall switches are cheap these days and they provide greater port to port throughput than a hub.  Remember that a 10mb HUB shares the 10mb between all of the ports.  A 10mb switch provides 10mb of bandwidth between the source and destination ports.  So a 8 port hub shares the 10mb bandwidth between all 8 ports; and collision between any of the devices can slow down the rate of successful transmissions.  A 8 port 10mb switch assuming that the devices were paired off and communication were strictly between the pairs (i.e. device on port 1 talkes to device on port 2, device on port 3 talks to device on port 4, etc) there can be a theoretical maximum of 40mb of bandwidth being utilized; 80mb if everything was communicating in full duplex.  

Also each port on a switch is its own collision domain; so you have 8 collision domains on a 8 port switch; on a 8 port hub its one big collision domain.

Regards
0
Veeam Disaster Recovery in Microsoft Azure

Veeam PN for Microsoft Azure is a FREE solution designed to simplify and automate the setup of a DR site in Microsoft Azure using lightweight software-defined networking. It reduces the complexity of VPN deployments and is designed for businesses of ALL sizes.

 
Titanium_SniperCommented:
a hub is worse and finding one will be difficult, if you can find a cheap one let me know because I need a hub for an experiment
0
 
Erik BjersPrincipal Systems AdministratorCommented:
A hub??? what's that??? I think it went the way of the 8-track...

As the others have said a switch would be best.

eb
0
 
snerkelCommented:
In this application a switch or a hub will give similar throughput (both the router and laptop end up going out of the same port to the Internet). If you intend exchanging data from router network to/from laptop then a switch is best.

Hubs are great for packet sniffing, I predict the cost of hubs going up as they become harder to get hold of. So if you can get a hub cheap or free then hang on to it for a couple of years then sell it on ebay for a lot more than you would get for a switch.
0
 
ezy2Author Commented:
Thanks to all who responded, will get the switch.
0
 
ECNSSMTCommented:
first thanks for the points,

second, I was thinking the exact same thing snerkel was thinking about 5 years ago and somewhere at home is a 4 port netgear hub; I haven't had the need to do so since I retired the hub as a "mini-lan party" device.  Just as a FYI, most of the managed switches come with a port mirroring feature that will send duplicate traffic to a port you specify; so you can place a sniffer or monitoring device there.

Also we seem to be in a transition point from 10/100mb to 10/100/1000mb switches; while the 10 mb hubs may possibly have a use at the lower end of the spectrum; it may become a point of bottle neck, per the traffic.

But yeah, I may be holding on to my 10mb hub for a little while longer too...

Regards,
0

Featured Post

 [eBook] Windows Nano Server

Download this FREE eBook and learn all you need to get started with Windows Nano Server, including deployment options, remote management
and troubleshooting tips and tricks

Tackle projects and never again get stuck behind a technical roadblock.
Join Now