Puzzles to Puzzle you

I have 3 square boards, the surface of the first contains 5 sq feet more than the second, and the second containing 5 sq feet more than the third

what are the exact measurements of the sides of the boards?

I have the answers I need to know how to solve it.
Who is Participating?

Commented:
Either the question or the answer has to be wrong then!!
0

Commented:
0

Commented:
I'm getting 4, 9, and root of 14 as the sides.
0

Commented:
sorry, that can't be right..
0

Commented:
I meant 2, 3, and root of 14.
0

Commented:
Root of 14 is irrational so there has to be a rule that you want the sides to be only rational nos right?
0

Commented:
Also could you tell us the answers?
0

Author Commented:
No Adam,  This is not Homework !! where on earth does schools  have puzzles as acadamic subject ?

I am Trying to prepare for Infosys ...A big IT company in India which asks puzzles in interview to check the thinking ability.

Well the answer to this question is 31,41 and 49 inch. The book however does not have give any solution.
0

Author Commented:
what is bugging me is that
And (41^2) - 31^2 is NOT = 5

which is the condition of the question
0

Commented:
I knowe that even Infosys won't ask these type of questions!
0

Commented:
Not another shilpi84, surely there is a ruling that cheating exams isn't allowed at EE.
0

Commented:
It's not cheating exams!
0

Commented:
My cousin lives in India and when I called her up she told me that this question was too high level even for infosys!
Thats all!
0

Commented:
Whether it's cheating or not it's still ruined the P&R TA.
0

Commented:
Why do you say that?
0

Commented:
Because you're meant to know the solution and how it is derived to post a puzzle/riddle.
0

Commented:
In any case, this riddle is either incomplete or unsolvable :

1) (ir)rational numbers are allowed : there's infinite solutions :

x^2 + 10 = y^2 + 5 = z^2

which is two equations with 3 unknowns.

2) only integers are allowed : there is no solution, which can easily be seen from this array of squares :

0 1 4 9 16 25 36 49 64 81 100

there's only 1 pair of squares that satisfies the requirement that the difference is 5 (4 and 9), and for the puzzle, we need 2.
0

Author Commented:
>>>Whether it's cheating or not it's still ruined the P&R TA.

andyalder According to you all the 100 Billion population of the world should have the IQ of Albert Einstine...Right?
And there should be no need of BOOKs Or Teachers because If I am smart why would I need teachers or books, then what is the need to go to collge or school...After all I am smart right ?

And what are books written for To help student to be Intelligent  or Ruin there thinking powers !!!

Even you might have studied in school...college
Even you might have learn any thing from the books or anything new from others
0

Author Commented:
0

Commented:
@sinha_anshul26 : what andyalder means is that these kind of questions are better put in the Math&Science section. The Puzzles&Riddles section is intended for those puzzles and riddles the author of the question knows the solution to. If the author doesn't know the solution, it's not seen as a puzzle or riddle, it's seen as a question for help about a mathematical subject, which goes in the Math&Science section.

The reason this might be perceived as cheating is just because of the fact that people responding to a puzzle or riddle assume that the author of the question knows the solution, and thus will not go in tutor mode, as is the normal conduct for a question like this in the Math&Science section.

I don't know if this makes the point clearer or not, but please re-read it if not, because the truth is hidden in this post somewhere :)
0

Author Commented:
Thank you for clarification
0

Commented:
Infinity08,

I said the same thing you said only in a different way:

You said 4, 9 is the only pair of squares that satisfy this 5 rule.
I said I got the answer as 2(root of 4), 3(root of 9), root of 14(root of  9+5).

So our answers were eventually the same except you explained it!
0

Commented:
@bk_jreinstein : I just wanted to make it more clear what exactly the problem with the question was. You gave one possible answer, but there are a lot more than that. And in case the answer space of the question is integers, then the answer you gave doesn't apply. So, I felt it was incomplete and wanted to fill in the blanks ...

And apparently, sinha_anshul26 felt the same way as he accepted your answer, and put mine in as assisted.
0

Commented:
Infinity08,

I wasn't blaming you or anything!!!!
You're talking as if I accused you for stealing my points!!
I'm just here to help, not for expert certifications or fame!!

Regards,
bk
0

Commented:
My apologies for the misunderstanding then, bk_jreinstein ... :) I wanted to make sure you didn't feel cheated in some way, and if that would have been the case, I'd have apologised for that :) Isn't the world nice if we all understand each other in the end ? :)

Just noticed I put three smilies in this post ... must be in a good mood lol
0

Commented:
>>Isn't the world nice if we all understand each other in the end ? :)

Yup!
0

Author Commented:
This wrong question has created 2 misunderstandings between(Infinity and  bk_jreinstein) and (me and andyalder)

That's the power of INFOSYS

0

Commented:
:) The power to create misunderstandings ... sounds like one I can do without lol ... if only I could heh
0

Commented:
lol
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.