• Status: Solved
  • Priority: Medium
  • Security: Public
  • Views: 1737
  • Last Modified:

Shock of 75 G. and 350 G.

All,

It has been pointed out to me that there is a warranty notice on some Seagate drives that says "Varranty void if ... , or if drive experiences shock in excess of 350 Gs.". Could people give me examples of an event that could cause a 350 G shock to a hard drive? Realistic, creative or hilarious would be perfectly acceptable.

http://backbytes.computing.co.uk/2006/07/hard_driving.html

The quote mentions 75 G too so some examples of that would be good. Mine reads 350 G.

Paul
0
PaulCaswell
Asked:
PaulCaswell
1 Solution
 
ozoCommented:
Drop it from 75cm, and stop it in 1cm.
Drom it from 350mm, and stop it in 1mm.
0
 
PaulCaswellAuthor Commented:
Thanks ozo,

Any ideas exactly what I could stop it with to stop it at 1cm and 1mm? I could imagine a 1cm deep dent in a plank of wood but that would not appear as a result of a 75 cm or 350 cm drop.

If it was in my car and I hit a brick wall and the normal crumple process occurs, how fast would I need to be travelling to achieve these two values?

Paul
0
 
PaulCaswellAuthor Commented:
If I drop it into water, say, how high would I have to drop it from? Assume normal salinity seawater and a predictable impact orientation.

Here's the details of the drive:

                    Height (inches/mm):    1.03/26.1
                    Width  (inches/mm):    4.00/101.85
                    Depth  (inches/mm):    5.78/147.0
                    Weight      (lb/g):     1.2/550

I guess it depends on the orientation on impact so a range from 26.1 X 101.85 to 101.85 X 147.0 would be good.

Paul
0
VIDEO: THE CONCERTO CLOUD FOR HEALTHCARE

Modern healthcare requires a modern cloud. View this brief video to understand how the Concerto Cloud for Healthcare can help your organization.

 
grg99Commented:
If you drop it onto a  hard surface, it can end up stopping in considerably less than one millimeter.  Let's assume it stops in .1 millimeter.  that means a 3.5cm drop will accelerate it enough to cause 350G decelleration in 0.1 millimeter.  That's only about 1.3 inches.  

So almost any drop onto a hard surface is a bad thing.

If you drop it into salt water, it's not likely to survive.  Salt water is bad for electronics.  Not to mention the water will contaminate the filter and maybe seep inside the drive.


To have it survive, you need some kind of shock mounting, so no matter how quickly the outer case stops, the drive has a few millimeters of jounce-room over which to spread out the decelleration.  Look up "Lord mounts", that company makes shock mounts to mount all kinds of things-- from nanites to jet engines.  Or mount it hanging from some thick rubber bands.  Or if it's a tiny cool drive, just wrap it in about an inch of bubble wrap.  Doesnt work for PC-sized drivers, they run too hot for this treatment.





0
 
ozoCommented:
38.3m/s or 138km/hr with a 1m crumple would be 75g
but crumpleing .99m to decelerate from 38.3m/s to 8.3m/s then
decelerating from 8.3 to 0 in the last .1m would be over 350g


If the surface does not deform when supporting 192.5kg per 2658 sq mm, it could impart 350g to a drive droped on end.
0
 
ozoCommented:
About 26m/s through water on the small end, or 11m/s on the big end should generate 350g of drag
About 12m/s through water on the small end, or 5m/s on the big end should generate 75g of drag

0
 
JR2003Commented:
A 1200 rpm spin dryer could produce about 350g

http://www.msu.edu/~venkata1/gforce.htm
0
 
infexCommented:
If it drops on a hard material ... (see before)

However if it is packed in some chock absorbing materials thing are quite different. I have actually seen how the transporters throw with boxes of "fragile" materials ...

Hope this helps
0
 
PaulCaswellAuthor Commented:
>>A 1200 rpm spin dryer could produce about 350g
Now THAT's the sort of thing I was looking for! A real-life repeatable situation.

I dont want it to survive, I just want it to experience 350G (and 75 G) in an everyday or at least an uncontrived event such as being dropped from a plane or spun in a spin dryer. :-)

Good work all! Just a couple more fine examples of Seagate Hard-Drive abuse that would void your warranty.

Paul
0
 
ozoCommented:
Vibrating at 40.5KHz (the resonant frequency of a .147m block of steel) with a displacement of 0.0000447 mm would require an acceleration of 75g
and a drive of that size vibrating like that would produce about a 90dB tone
0
 
PaulCaswellAuthor Commented:
Thanks ozo, in what situation might this be made to happen? A very loud rock concert?

Paul
0

Featured Post

Free Tool: Subnet Calculator

The subnet calculator helps you design networks by taking an IP address and network mask and returning information such as network, broadcast address, and host range.

One of a set of tools we're offering as a way of saying thank you for being a part of the community.

Tackle projects and never again get stuck behind a technical roadblock.
Join Now