We help IT Professionals succeed at work.

We've partnered with Certified Experts, Carl Webster and Richard Faulkner, to bring you two Citrix podcasts. Learn about 2020 trends and get answers to your biggest Citrix questions!Listen Now

x

Database normalization problem

bufalobk
bufalobk asked
on
Medium Priority
287 Views
Last Modified: 2012-05-05
Hi all experts,
I have one question about normalization

I have a Initial Database as follow:
(Please copy and patse to Notepad, choose Courier Font)

================================================================
CLUB_CODE | CLUB NAME | ST# | ST_NAME | SUBJ# | SUBJ_NAME | MARK
================================================================
          |           |     |         | P1    | PHYSICAL  |  6
   EN     |  ENGLISH  |     |         | M1    | MATH 1    |  5
          |           | ST1 | JOHN    | C1    | CHEMICHY  |  8
----------|-----------|     |         | M1    | MUSIC     |  7
   CP     | COMPUTER  |     |         | D1    | DRAW      |  5
          |           |     |         | D2    |DATA STRUCT|  8  
=================================================================
          |           |     |         | P1    | PHYSICAL  |  4
   EN     |  ENGLISH  |     |         | M1    | MATH 1    |  7
          |           | ST2 | SMITH   | C1    | CHEMICHY  |  5
----------|-----------|     |         | M1    | MUSIC     |  7
   CP     | COMPUTER  |     |         | D1    | DRAW      |  8
          |           |     |         | D2    |DATA STRUCT|  9  
=================================================================
          |           |     |         | P2    | PHYSICALII|  5
   CP     | COMPUTER  |     |         | M3    | MATH II   |  7
----------|-----------| ST3 | MARK    | C2    | CHEMICHYII|  3
          |           |     |         | M2    | MUSICII   |  9
   FR     |   FRENCH  |     |         | D2    | DRAW II   |  5
=================================================================

   
Can you help me to move it into the 1st normal form (1NF) in 2 ways :
- flatterning
- split into attributes groups

Thank you in advance.

Comment
Watch Question

hi

you are already in the 1nf form
the 1nf form says that you should take out groups of data, but you don't have those in your design
if you wish i can help you get it in 3nf form,
but i will need you to tell me what is the meaning of each column


momi sabag

Not the solution you were looking for? Getting a personalized solution is easy.

Ask the Experts
You need to add three new tables, Club, Student and Subject

Club
-----------------
Club_Code
Club_Name

Student
-----------------
St#
St_Name

Subject
---------------
Subj#
Subj_Name


then your main table becomes

MainTable
-------------------------
Club_Code   PK
St#             PK
SubJ#         PK
Mark

yes, that is a Composite PrimaryKey, made up of the three fields Club_Code, St#, SubJ#

AW

Your table in 1NF would be like this :

(CLUB_CODE, ST#, SUBJ#, CLUB NAME, ST_NAME, SUBJ_NAME, MARK) where CLUB_CODE, ST#, SUBJ# are the tree members of your primary key.

Your data would looks like this :

================================================================
CLUB_CODE | CLUB NAME | ST# | ST_NAME | SUBJ# | SUBJ_NAME | MARK
================================================================
   EN     |  ENGLISH  | ST1 | JOHN    | P1    | PHYSICAL  |  6
   EN     |  ENGLISH  | ST1 | JOHN    | M1    | MATH 1    |  5
   EN     |  ENGLISH  | ST1 | JOHN    | C1    | CHEMICHY  |  8
   CP     | COMPUTER  | ST1 | JOHN    | M1    | MUSIC     |  7
   CP     | COMPUTER  | ST1 | JOHN    | D1    | DRAW      |  5
   CP     | COMPUTER  | ST1 | JOHN    | D2    |DATA STRUCT|  8  
   EN     |  ENGLISH  | ST2 | SMITH   | P1    | PHYSICAL  |  4
   EN     |  ENGLISH  | ST2 | SMITH   | M1    | MATH 1    |  7
   EN     |  ENGLISH  | ST2 | SMITH   | C1    | CHEMICHY  |  5
   CP     | COMPUTER  | ST2 | SMITH   | M1    | MUSIC     |  7
   CP     | COMPUTER  | ST2 | SMITH   | D1    | DRAW      |  8
   CP     | COMPUTER  | ST2 | SMITH   | D2    |DATA STRUCT|  9  
   CP     | COMPUTER  | ST3 | MARK    | P2    | PHYSICALII|  5
   CP     | COMPUTER  | ST3 | MARK    | M3    | MATH II   |  7
   FR     |   FRENCH  | ST3 | MARK    | C2    | CHEMICHYII|  3
   FR     |   FRENCH  | ST3 | MARK    | M2    | MUSICII   |  9
   FR     |   FRENCH  | ST3 | MARK    | D2    | DRAW II   |  5

your groups would be the following : {CLUB_CODE, CLUB_NAME}, {ST#, ST_NAME}, {SUBJ#, SUBJ_NAME}, {MARK}

Eventually, when your data will be very normalized, it will appear in tables like this :

Students : ST#, ST_NAME (pk --> ST#)
Clubs : CLUB_CODE, CLUB_NAME (pk --> CLUB_CODE)
Subjects : SUBJ#, SUBJ_NAME (pk --> SUBJ#)
StudentsMarks : ST#, CLUB_CODE, SUBJ#, MARK (pk --> ST#, CLUB_CODE, SUBJ#)

Hope this helps.

That very nice example authur......See if groups then split them to a new table.
Great
Access more of Experts Exchange with a free account
Thanks for using Experts Exchange.

Create a free account to continue.

Limited access with a free account allows you to:

  • View three pieces of content (articles, solutions, posts, and videos)
  • Ask the experts questions (counted toward content limit)
  • Customize your dashboard and profile

*This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

OR

Please enter a first name

Please enter a last name

8+ characters (letters, numbers, and a symbol)

By clicking, you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.