IP Ping works one way but not the other.  Cableing question.

knightforce777
knightforce777 used Ask the Experts™
on
I have a couple of computers on my network which cannot be reached by a simple 'ping' command.
(All firewalls are off.)

They are able to ping everything on the network, and recieve their DHCP from the DC with no problem.  In fact, they are in use constantly and function without any problems.

However, I can not get any ping response from them.

I have narrowed down the 'problem' computers to this:  They are all connected to recent cable drops, and I must confess that I ran the cables myself.

My question is this:

Is it possible for an incorrect wiring to cause this?  I assumed that bad wiring would either fail completely, or cause packet storms.

I consitantly used T568B wiring conventions.  If anyone can give me some pointers on what I may have done wrong, I would appreciate it.

Thanks!!

Comment
Watch Question

Do more with

Expert Office
EXPERT OFFICE® is a registered trademark of EXPERTS EXCHANGE®
It's probably not likely that bad wiring is causing this problem.

-Check for an IP address conflict.
-Check the default gateway and SNM settings to make sure they are correct.

Let me know what you find there, and I'll try and help further.

Ira @ KVR

Author

Commented:
Thanks for the quick response.

I have already checked for IP conflicts, and all gateway, mask, and other DHCP settings.

In fact, I watched as the DHCP server handed out the new addresses for these machines.

This is all in one (remote) office, and, as i mentioned, this issue is not causing any user problems at all.

It is acting just as if the XP firewall was turned on -- but it's not.  And since it seems to be workstations that are located at new drops,...

Oh well... if you have any further ideas, I look forward to them.  Stumped.....

Thanks!!!!

I guess it could be cabling related. I do remember a professor in college constantly saying "80% of networking issues are cable related" ... but it doesn't seem like that would be the problem, since you're clearly aware of the T568B protocol.. and you mentioned that the nodes work perfectly except for ping.

Can you ping by computer name? Do they have anything like Norton Security installed? Does the data path go through any Cisco devices?
Exploring ASP.NET Core: Fundamentals

Learn to build web apps and services, IoT apps, and mobile backends by covering the fundamentals of ASP.NET Core and  exploring the core foundations for app libraries.

Commented:
If a PING works one way then there is two way comms, there HAS to be a firewall involved unless there are two hosts on the same IP (very unlikely as they would detect each other quickly).  a PING reaponse requires machineA to talk to machine B and a packet to get back to machine A again.  If that is working then ip, subnet mask, gateways and everything else which it passes through can be seen to be right.

Do they by any chance have something like Norton installed which has firewall built in?

Author

Commented:
I will check to see if there is some other, unknown firewall present.

Two of the boxed are straight from Dell, and who knows what crap they may have installed in them (norton, mcafee???)

There are not Cisco products or anything else between them.  They are using a simple unmanaged Linsys switch.

Thanks!!
Yeah, I'd try a random laptop that you know functions correctly.. that way you could rule out the cables.

I'd bet something is blocking ICMP.

Let me know, now I'm curious.

Ira @ KVR

Commented:
It simply can't be cables as there is two way comms as PING works already one way.  It will be a software firewall, 99:1.

Author

Commented:
I have confirmed with another computer that the wiring is fine.

I'm going to try 9tommorow) and uninstall or disable any of the security programs that came bundled with them and see if that helps.

Thanks all.

Do more with

Expert Office
Submit tech questions to Ask the Experts™ at any time to receive solutions, advice, and new ideas from leading industry professionals.

Start 7-Day Free Trial