How to call a function/method in the child class from thr father class?

I request this question again because I have another problem now.

My code look as follow:

public classFather {
...
   protected abstract doNewA();
   protected abstract doNewB();
...
   doNewA();
   doNewB();
...
}

public classChildA extends classFather {
...
   doNewA();
   doNewB();
...
}

public classChildB extends classFather {
...
   doNewB();
   doNewA();
...
}

The problem is: If I call doNewA() in ClassA from father class, the doNewA in ClassB is called. How can I avoid it?
chenweiAsked:
Who is Participating?
 
carljoklConnect With a Mentor Commented:
I think that this may be a potential design issue. If I had a better idea of what you wish to accomplish by calling the specific child's method. I would question whether a problem like this might be an indication that the design of your program might not be appropriate to the task. I am not sure if there is a way to force a specific overidden method in a class hierachy to be run. I think the reason is that it should not be neccecary.

If a subclass has the need to overide methodA() in order to work properly with class ChildA then it was overidden in order to make the method work safely therefore forcing the class to run one of it's parents version of the method (except in the case that the subclass it's self decides that you should do so using the super.methodA()) might cause potential problems.

I must say I don't know if what you are trying to do is possible. I don't know the specific problem you are working on but suspect that there is an alternative way of designing your program to achieve the same results. Sometimes Java does not let you do something because it is not good practice.
0
 
bbkepplerCommented:
I would look closely at which class you are actually instantiating.  Consider the following code:

...
Father a = new ChildA();
a.doNewA();  // This will call the overridden doNewA() method defined by ChildA.
Father b = new ChildB();
b.doNewA();  // This will call the overridden doNewA() method defined by ChildB.
...

Again, make sure that the object you have a reference to is actually of the class you think it is.  ChildA is not aware of ChildB because ChildB is not in its class hierarchy, so it would be impossible for an object whose concrete class is ChildA to exhibit behavior specific to ChildB.
0
 
bbkepplerCommented:
One more point on the above comment.  Consider the following code:

public class Father {
  ...
  public void foo() {
    ...
    doNewA();
    ...
  }
  ...
  public void doNewA() {
    ...
  }
  ...
}
...
Father a = new ChildA();
a.foo();
Father b = new ChildB();
b.foo();
...

Assume that ChildA and ChildB do not override foo().  Now, the a.foo() call will result in the doNewA() method defined by ChildA being called even though the method call is made in the foo() method defined in Father.  Likewise, the b.foo() call will result in the doNewA() method defined by ChildB being called.
   
0
 
chenweiAuthor Commented:
Many thanks to bbkeppler's example codes. But I think carljokl's commment comes near to my points. :-)
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.