Selecting a random row in an MS Access database

I can't figure out why this SQL statement isn't working - it returns the same value every time.

SELECT Field1 FROM Table1 ORDER BY rnd()

I also tried

SELECT Field1 FROM Table1 ORDER BY rnd(NumericValue)

It returns the same result every time as well (not the same result as the first SQL statement, but the same one everytime the query is run.)

Any help would be appreciated.
filemanagerAsked:
Who is Participating?
 
harfangConnect With a Mentor Commented:
cactus_data,

I beg to differ, but the following query gives me five random suppliers, different every time.

SELECT TOP 5 SupplierID, CompanyName
FROM Suppliers
ORDER BY Rnd(SupplierID);

It is true that Rnd() alone does not work, because the query optimizer will call it only once, but as soon as you provide a positive integer, using a field name in the expression, Rnd(<expr>) will be called for each record, and return the "next" random number at every call.

(°v°)
0
 
puppydogbuddyCommented:
md() appears to be returning only one value

maybe you intended the following:

SELECT Field1 FROM Table1 ORDER BY rnd(Field1)
0
 
Gustav BrockCIOCommented:
Look up my comment here:

http://www.experts-exchange.com/Databases/Q_21713793.html

It explains how and why.

/gustav
0
Introducing Cloud Class® training courses

Tech changes fast. You can learn faster. That’s why we’re bringing professional training courses to Experts Exchange. With a subscription, you can access all the Cloud Class® courses to expand your education, prep for certifications, and get top-notch instructions.

 
aikimarkCommented:
SELECT Field1, rnd() as RandNo FROM Table1 ORDER BY 2
0
 
aikimarkCommented:
Correction:
SELECT Field1, rnd([ID]) as RandNo FROM Table1 ORDER BY 2

Where [ID] is the autonumber column in the table
0
 
filemanagerAuthor Commented:
I've tried all of your suggestions, and all of them return the same value every time :(
0
 
harfangCommented:
Hello filemanager

All of the above solutions worked for me. You need only two things: a) provide a field as parameter to force rnd() to recompute on each row, and b) make sure that the number is positive. That's all. Even Rnd(Val("1" & strJustAnyField)) works if you do not have an autonumber.

(°v°)
0
 
Gustav BrockCIOCommented:
Sorry, but none of the methods using Rnd() "as is" directly in SQL will work.
With Access JET tables you have to use an external function as shown in the link provided above.
With SQL Server you have other options but that's another topic.

The link shows how to pick one (or more) unique random records.
In your case you request all records, thus it can simplified like this:

  SELECT
    Field1
  FROM
    Table1
  ORDER BY
    RandomNumber([ID] Is Null);

where ID is the primary key of your table.

/gustav
0
 
Gustav BrockCIOCommented:
It may appear so, but if you run the query, record the resultset, close Access, then relaunch and run the query again, you will notice that the query returns the exact same resultset as before.

That's because Rnd() is not a function returning random numbers, only pseudo random numbers. To partially overcome this, VBA provides Randomize which you must call to obtain a unique sequence based on the current time which, of course, will be different each time you call Randomize. You might think that you could call Randomize from the query via a wrapping function - and you can do so - but it has no effect as it will be run in another scope than Rnd().

Thus, to obtain a different pseudo random sequence any time you run the query no matter if Access has been relaunched or not, you have to draw the sequence from an external helper function.

/gustav
0
 
harfangCommented:
cactus_data,

Thank you for the clarification, I understand what you were getting at now. And since Randomize is not implemented as a function, there is indeed no other solution as the one you provide.

(°v°)
0
 
aikimarkCommented:
If you only want to see ONE ROW and there is an autonumber column, you can use the following:
SELECT Top 1 Field1
FROM Table1
WHERE ID > (Rnd()*(Select Count(*) From Table1))
0
 
filemanagerAuthor Commented:
Ok... I got the random SQL statement to work in MS Access, but when it's run from within VB it doesn't work... anyone know why?
0
 
harfangCommented:
Well, cactus_data did provide a full and detailed solution. But than again, there was no follow-up to the author's last succinct comment, mostly because the "why" was covered amply...
No objections from my part, but I would have recommended {http:#17974025} as the accepted solution.
(°v°)
0
 
mbizupCommented:
>there was no follow-up to the author's last succinct comment
That's why I recommended a refund...  Lets see if the author rersponds.
0
 
filemanagerAuthor Commented:
I ended up using puppydogbuddy's suggestion, in addition to adding:


        intRandomNumber = .RecordCount
        intRandomNumber = Int(intRandomNumber * Rnd) + 1
        For i = 1 To (intRandomNumber - 1)
            .MoveNext
        Next

after I opened the recordset. For some reason it always chose the same record, so the code above picked a random record out of the recordset.
0
 
filemanagerAuthor Commented:
Clairification: I used a modified version of puppydogbuddy's suggestion.
0
 
mbizupCommented:
filemanager,
You can select an answer yourself following these closing and grading guidelines:
http://www.experts-exchange.com/help.jsp#hs5
0
 
Gustav BrockCIOCommented:
> when it's run from within VB it doesn't work... anyone know why?

Sorry, missed that.

That's because you have to use similar code to what I've suggested also if you move your code to VB.
Indeed, a call to Randomize is mandatory. It not, you have your reason why:

> it always chose the same record, ..

/gustav
0
 
Gustav BrockCIOCommented:
> I used a modified version of puppydogbuddy's suggestion

So no points for Richard.

/gustav
0
 
harfangCommented:
Oh... did you really intend to accept my answer? It seems my misconception has been corrected by gustav in detail!
(°v°)
0
 
filemanagerAuthor Commented:
harfang, yes I meant to. I looked at the code I used and your suggestion was the closest to what I actually got working.
0
 
harfangCommented:
OK, then. Success with your project!
(°v°)
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.