• Status: Solved
  • Priority: Medium
  • Security: Public
  • Views: 274
  • Last Modified:

While Loop Question

Hi Friends,

I have a simple question but I couldnt figure it out whats going on...

I have a piece of code like

int k=0;
while(k++<=10)
      cout<<k<<endl;

cout<<"After loop k="<<k;

The printed values are 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11

and after the loop the value of k is 12.

How does C++ test the expression? Does it increase the value of k then test the expression or does it first test then increase the value of k


Secondly,

if you add QuickWatch for expressions k++<=10 and k the output is 3,6,9,12 and after loop the value of k=15

What is going on?


By the way I am using Microsoft Visual Studio.NET
0
MacroLand
Asked:
MacroLand
  • 3
  • 3
1 Solution
 
UrosVidojevicCommented:
Hi,

>> How does C++ test the expression? Does it increase the value of k then test the expression or does it first test then increase the value of k

in case of operator ++ it depends.

1.) if you use preincrement operator (++k). then C++ first increments k, and then use it in any expression that ++k is in.
2.) if you use postincrement operator (k++). then C++ use k for computing the expression that k++ is in, and afther that increments k.

In your piece of code you use postincrement operator and thats why you have k = 12 value at the end of loop.

value before                comparation                     increment
comparation
k = 0,                          (0<=10),                            k = k + 1 = 1;
k = 1,                          (1<=10),                            k = k + 1 = 2;
...
k = 9,                          (9 <=10),                           k= k + 1 = 10;
k = 10,                        (10 <= 10),                        k = k + 1= 11;
k = 11,                        (11 <= 10);                        this is the end of loop, but you still have k = k+1 = 12!

If you have used ++k, you wold have k = 11 at the end.

value before                increment                     comparation
comparation
k = 0,                          k = k + 1 = 1                k = k + 1 = 1;
k = 1,                          k = k + 1 = 2                k = k + 1 = 2;
...
k = 9,                          k = k + 1 = 10              k= k + 1 = 10;
k = 10,                        k = k + 1 = 11              (11 <= 10), false, end of loop.

For second question, I have really no idea :-).
0
 
AlexFMCommented:
k++
First k value is tested, then incremented.

++k
First k value is incremented, then tested.

I guess QuickWatch increments k during expression evaluation - good example of debugger which changes program results. Don't use QuickWatch expressions which change variable values.
0
 
MacroLandAuthor Commented:
Still have a little question.

Is it inherent to loops that even after exiting the loop, the value of the variable, in this case k, always increases.
0
Concerto Cloud for Software Providers & ISVs

Can Concerto Cloud Services help you focus on evolving your application offerings, while delivering the best cloud experience to your customers? From DevOps to revenue models and customer support, the answer is yes!

Learn how Concerto can help you.

 
UrosVidojevicCommented:
Loop can't change variable after exiting from it!
Every loop in C++ has some condition that is neccessary to be true in order to begin next iteration.

example:

while (this_condition) {}

for (...; this_condition; ...) {}

do {} while (this_condition);

note that this_condition is tested before / after(do..while loop) each iteration. So if you have some change on your variable in this_condition than it will be done each time when this_condition is true, even when the loop ends (this_condition is false in this case).
0
 
MacroLandAuthor Commented:
I get your point but

value before                comparation                     increment
comparation
k = 0,                          (0<=10),                            k = k + 1 = 1;
k = 1,                          (1<=10),                            k = k + 1 = 2;
...
k = 9,                          (9 <=10),                           k= k + 1 = 10;
k = 10,                        (10 <= 10),                        k = k + 1= 11;
k = 11,                        (11 <= 10);                        this is the end of loop, but you still have k = k+1 = 12!

comparation is false but still the value increases!!!
0
 
UrosVidojevicCommented:
It is not important whether comparation is true or false, k++ is in this comparation and therefore k increases.

in the last iteration you have:

k is 11,
(k++ <= 10) is (11 <= 10), which is false,
but C++ now must increment k (k is 12 now), because k++ was in expression.
As I already said, compailer saw k++ in comparation and therefore he must increment k. That is totally independent of value of comparation and must be done in both (true and false) cases!
0
 
MacroLandAuthor Commented:
OK It is clearer now. Thank you very much indeed.
0

Featured Post

Industry Leaders: We Want Your Opinion!

We value your feedback.

Take our survey and automatically be enter to win anyone of the following:
Yeti Cooler, Amazon eGift Card, and Movie eGift Card!

  • 3
  • 3
Tackle projects and never again get stuck behind a technical roadblock.
Join Now