Link to home
Start Free TrialLog in
Avatar of m8rix
m8rixFlag for Australia

asked on

safe domain name whois lookup

I have long been suspicious of certain whois tools "monitoring" names typed in and then stealing the name for them selves if it is free.
A couple of years ago I ran a whois on a list of possible domain names for my new site and found a really great one was free, two days later I went to purchase it and it was gone! Well apart from pissing me off, it made me very careful now and every time I have purchased a domain name since I have deliberately waited until I am ready to purchase to go through and find a domain name that is free and get it immediately.

The problem is that sometimes you may want to find a few free domains and give your self a week so you can think about which is best.

1) Is there a law against sites stealing your domain name ideas?
2) Is there a trusted site that is perhaps government run?
Avatar of m8rix
m8rix
Flag of Australia image

ASKER

correction
Is there a trusted *whois lookup* site that is perhaps government run?
Avatar of Kiran Paul VJ
try this its a good one

http://www.internic.net/

kiranvj
Avatar of jawahar_prasad
jawahar_prasad

ya..

whois.com
Avatar of m8rix

ASKER

Are these independent or government sites?
I agree with m8rix -- I think the main sites indeed DO catalog the requests they put into their search, and then someone later checks to see if they are good names, they register them, and then sell them.

I do NOT trust whois.com, or internic.net, or ANY major domain lookup.  I have tested them like m8rix has, and found that they do theive domain names untaken, although it is hard to prove without subpoenas.

I would take the opposite tack, m8rix -- I would use a small domain search that no one thinks for, and which only hotlinks to a major site like whois.   The one I use is -- http://www.mydiscountdomains.com/ --

Do your searches there, it interactively tells you which is available and which is not, in real time javascript -- ans since they cache the database directly, your queries NEVER get to the big thieves.  I have found that any searches I do there, no one ever gets the domain name before you do.

Good luck, and always be wary of big companies using you for their own profit.  
Avatar of m8rix

ASKER

Thanks for your reply scrathcyboy, however I don't think I can trust your answer on face value.

From the ICANN site I found this:
"VeriSign is the authoritative directory provider of all .com, .net, .cc, and .tv domain names"

and on the VeriSign site http://www.mydiscountdomains.com is not listed as a Certified .COM or .NET Registrar
http://www.verisign.com/information-services/naming-services/com-net-registry/page_002166.html#M

My guess is that they are a reseller. I would NEVER trust resellers, because there is more chance that they are corrupt than a certified registrar. Also they will often hide who they actually purchase the domains from.

At this stage I think I would be most likely to trust InterNIC or VeriSign
well you totally missed the point -- but go ahead.
Avatar of m8rix

ASKER

@scrathcyboy > I am not dismissing your answer, I was just hoping you could defend it with some supporting evidence. (That's what I meant by "face value" meaning "no real proof")
SOLUTION
Avatar of Kiran Paul VJ
Kiran Paul VJ
Flag of India image

Link to home
membership
This solution is only available to members.
To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.
Start Free Trial
ASKER CERTIFIED SOLUTION
Link to home
membership
This solution is only available to members.
To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.
Start Free Trial