Trouble sending emails from one exchange server to another within same routing group

I'm having an issue where one of the exchange servers in my domain (server A) is having trouble sending to users on another exchange server in the same domain (Server B).  However server A can get email from users on Server B as well as send to and from external users outside of the domain.

Both servers are in the same domain, exchange administrative group, and routing group.  Server B is the master of the routing group.

Am I missing something?
kenhen99Asked:
Who is Participating?
 
SembeeCommented:
You don't need to do anything with relay settings to send email between Exchange servers, so that will not be the problem. If you have changed your relay settings, remove it.

Storage groups? That could be the wrong type of group and maybe a reference to routing groups. However if the servers are in the same routing group then that will not be the issue either.

Test number 1 - can you telnet to port 25 of the other server? Test both ways, using all three formats

telnet ip.add.re.ss 25
telnet servername 25
telnet host.domain.com 25

All thee should succeed. If the cursor just flashes then something is blocking it.

Otherwise what has changed? Things don't break for no reason.

Simon.

--
If your question has been answered, please remember to accept the answer and close the question.
0
 
Exchange_SolutionCommented:
Just been sure that Server A have The Right to relay to Server B
Add the Server A IP Address to the Server B Relay Access
0
 
e_vanheelCommented:
Which version of Exchange are you running?  If you are running 2003, you may want to consider removing the routing groups between the servers and let the servers handle it themselves.
0
Making Bulk Changes to Active Directory

Watch this video to see how easy it is to make mass changes to Active Directory from an external text file without using complicated scripts.

 
kenhen99Author Commented:
Thanks for both replies, Server A is already allowed to relay through Server B (the subnet its on is allowed) and they  both are already members of the same routing group.
0
 
e_vanheelCommented:
Are the both in the Exchange Domain Servers security group? If they are not in the same subnet are they both using WINS?
0
 
kenhen99Author Commented:
Yes they are both in the exchange domain group and they are on the same subnet. I noticed that messgaes get hung in the queue and finally it says remote host has refused the connection when sending to server B.
0
 
e_vanheelCommented:
Try removing the storage groups.
0
 
kenhen99Author Commented:
Which storage groups?
0
 
kenhen99Author Commented:
Yes, all three of those telnet attempts are successful.  This is a new exchange cluster that came online a few weeks before I started here and now they want it up and running so no changes have been made but I doubt it has ever worked to begin with.

0
 
e_vanheelCommented:
Make sure the cluster name is added to the Exchange Domain Servers security group.  You may need to fail over the services or reboot to get the new group membership to take effect.
0
 
kenhen99Author Commented:
I added the cluster name to the exhcange server group and restarted both cluster members one at a time.  Still hvaing the same issue, it hangs out in the queue for a while before the queue states that the remote host has been dropped by the remote host.
0
 
kenhen99Author Commented:
I set up smtp logging on server A and here is what I see in regards to the other server.

18:49:10 (Server B IP) EHLO - 250
18:49:10 (Server B IP)  x-exps - 0
18:49:10 (Server B IP) x-link2state - 200
18:49:10 (Server B IP) MAIL - 250
18:49:10 (Server B IP) RCPT - 250
18:49:10 (Server B IP)  xexch50 - 354
0
 
kenhen99Author Commented:
Figured it out... they had a smarthost configured on the cluster pointing to an internal smtp server (where outgoing mail goes), removed that and let exchange do its thing within the routing group, thanks to all who replied.
0
 
kenhen99Author Commented:
How do I accept my own answer as the soluiton?
0
 
kenhen99Author Commented:
I have no problem dividing up the points, it would be nice if there was a way you could put your own answer as the soluiton as people often will go right to what was marked as the solution when searching on a problem.
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.