cannot execute WinRAR inside DTS package

sql server 2000
i have a simple DTS package that extracts millions of records from a table to a csv file (simple transform data task). the next step in the DTS is an "execute process" task where i want to run WinRAR to compress that csv file.

win32 process: C:\Program Files\WinRAR\WinRAR.exe
parameters: A E:\OUTPUT\TEST\History_Archive.csv

however it fails with the message:
!  E:\OUTPUT\TEST\History_Archive.csv: The archive is either in unknown format or damaged

there is nothing wrong with the csv file as i can compress it manually using WinRAR from Windows explorer on the server.
i need to get the DTS working as i want to schedule it monthly.

thanks
LVL 19
frankyteeAsked:
Who is Participating?
 
BarthaxConnect With a Mentor Commented:
With the A command, WinRAR requires three parameters: "A", the RAR file to create and the file to add to the RAR file.

WinRAR A <rarfile> <file(s) to add>
0
 
k_rasuriCommented:
zip them instead of rar and see if it works
0
 
frankyteeAuthor Commented:
if it was up to me i would but management has ordered that we move to WinRAR because of its greater compression so i dont have that choice. Its an MIS db so we get heaps of large extracts etc so thats why we moved to winRAR.
0
Never miss a deadline with monday.com

The revolutionary project management tool is here!   Plan visually with a single glance and make sure your projects get done.

 
Anthony PerkinsCommented:
>>however it fails with the message:<<
When you run it manually or as a scheduled job?
0
 
frankyteeAuthor Commented:
when i run the dts manually. haven't scheduled it yet as its not finalised (nor working) and the dba doesn't want dodgy adhoc jobs floating around. Also winzip has been uninstalled so it has to be WinRAR. i've just been told that i should create a batch file that runs the winRAR and then execute that batch file directly but since i've posted this i'll rather just execute the WinRAR (if thats possible) as i dont understand why DST would give options to execute external exe but then not work! i think i'll have to investigate the parameter strings.
0
 
BarthaxCommented:
WinRAR thinks you have given it a RAR file to add stuff to - hence the notice that it doesn't recognise the format.
0
 
Eugene ZConnect With a Mentor Commented:
make sure that WinRAR.exe is installed on sql server box
use UNC path to file (\\servername\share)


use MS-DOS RAR  utility (located in winrar installation folder (prog files..)
you can call it with xp_cmdshell

  RAR Syntax

    RAR <command>  [ -<switches> ]  <archive>  [ <@listfiles...> ]
        [ <files...> ]  [ <path_to_extract\> ]
0
 
frankyteeAuthor Commented:
i ended up using a batch file to do this as i needed to record the process time etc.
but as i stated i wanted to know how to do this directly executing a win process in DTS so after some experimenting the solution posted by Barthax was the closest solution but i used different parameter switches like below (because it was used by one of my former colleagues in an earlier DTS that i found):
u -ibck -ep "full path and file name of rar file" "full path and name of file to archive"
i read the RAR help file and it did not show "-ibck" as a valid switch. but it worked anyway. does anyone know what it stands for?
i found that i had to put the full path of the file to be archived and not just the file name as otherwise RAR did not recognize it. Also how would the list of files be seperated? comma?

thanks
0
 
BarthaxCommented:
The -ibck command forces WinRAR to run in the background (should sit in the system tray) which prevents it from taking as much CPU as it can get.
0
All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.